Mouthpieces Got a new tenor mouthpiece

If you're having to adjust the pitch throughout the range, you have a mouthpiece mismatch.
Or, a sax that is very badly out of adjustment. Until I straightened the key racks and adjusted pad heights, my $315 (original case & shipping included) early 1950's Beaugnier Vito Low Bb Bari fixer-upper was like that.

And, the tuning on some beginner models aren't as good as a pro model.

Back in high school very early 1970's when I started playing a new Yamaha YAS-61 pro alto instead of the school loaner, suddenly I sounded better and played better in tune.

But, I still find myself tweaking my tuning, necessary to be in tune. So unless it is truly bad, I'll make nearly any instrument play in tune.

I guess it depends on what you mean to play in tune.
 
If you're having to adjust the pitch throughout the range, you have a mouthpiece mismatch.

Adjust the mouthpiece so that overblown Bell notes match natural fingerings with the least amount of input.

The easiest is C1 to C2 and G2.
That's exactly how I set up my instruments with respect to key height etc. Of course, the old adage is: You can only tune a piano that's in tune, er, sorry, I mean saxophone.

And I partially disagree with the MPC mismatch assessment, that is, if you mean that you have to play sharp at one end of the horn's range and flat on the other end, then I agree. But if you just have to adjust for individual notes, it is a matter of the horn setup. And if everything is sharp or flat, then your MPC is just in the wrong spot.
 
One thing not mentioned so far is that “short pipe” notes (B2, B3) are affected much more by mouthpiece movement than “long pipe” notes (B1). This is why the pitch matching between overtones and standard fingerings works.

If you can play in tune (with others) with the mouthpiece at the position where B3 and B1 are in tune with each other, you are doing something right. Learning to do that IMO is key to surviving on gigs, and has the further benefit that relaxing the jaw and lowering your input pitch improves your tone.

Besides, “It’s better to be sharp than out of tune.” Old joke, I know, but like all good jokes, there’s a nugget of truth there. Go listen critically to Cannonball and Phil Woods, arguably two past masters with the most beautiful tone. Ditto for Paul Desmond. They tend to the sharp side, especially in the upper register. But man oh man, what sounds those three had.
 
Or, a sax that is very badly out of adjustment. Until I straightened the key racks and adjusted pad heights, my $315 (original case & shipping included) early 1950's Beaugnier Vito Low Bb Bari fixer-upper was like that.

And, the tuning on some beginner models aren't as good as a pro model.

Back in high school very early 1970's when I started playing a new Yamaha YAS-61 pro alto instead of the school loaner, suddenly I sounded better and played better in tune.

But, I still find myself tweaking my tuning, necessary to be in tune. So unless it is truly bad, I'll make nearly any instrument play in tune.

I guess it depends on what you mean to play in tune.
I dropped ONE tiny sliver of cork on one of the regulation knobs when I overhauled / rebuilt the saxello and it made the horn unplayable, not borderline but full on unplayable. Rebuilding that instrument taught me so much about key heights, dependencies, weird gargles and whatever, and I am eternally grateful for it because those lessons made my other instruments so much better.
 
One thing not mentioned so far is that “short pipe” notes (B2, B3) are affected much more by mouthpiece movement than “long pipe” notes (B1). This is why the pitch matching between overtones and standard fingerings works.

If you can play in tune (with others) with the mouthpiece at the position where B3 and B1 are in tune with each other, you are doing something right. Learning to do that IMO is key to surviving on gigs, and has the further benefit that relaxing the jaw and lowering your input pitch improves your tone.

Besides, “It’s better to be sharp than out of tune.” Old joke, I know, but like all good jokes, there’s a nugget of truth there. Go listen critically to Cannonball and Phil Woods, arguably two past masters with the most beautiful tone. Ditto for Paul Desmond. They tend to the sharp side, especially in the upper register. But man oh man, what sounds those three had.
100% on everything.

Yes, you can still dress sharp, it won't affect your intonation but maybe sway the audience
 
Thanks all for you input.

Rule of thumb is always "tune sharp, play flat".
That's the approach I'm trying and it makes sense now.
A lesson, with an accomplished Saxophone teacher, might be a good idea.
Shut the computer off. 😜
I have great teacher but he's on holiday until next month so I browsed the web and asked here. If I haven't sorted it by then I'm sure he will.
If you're having to adjust the pitch throughout the range, you have a mouthpiece mismatch.

Adjust the mouthpiece so that overblown Bell notes match natural fingerings with the least amount of input.
There's no reason that a Soloist isn't compatible with a YTS-25 (@Colin the Bear - You have or had the same sax I believe, and a Soloist?)
I think a) I need to find the optimal mpc position, b) I need to adjust to the new mpc.
I will do the overblow exercise again later.
Or, a sax that is very badly out of adjustment.
AFAIK it is fine. It's me that is out of adjustment!

This is a great mpc, I just need to learn how to blow it properly.
 
but he's on holiday until next month so I browsed the web and asked here.
My 2¢/p/øre...
Given you're fussing with tone and tuning, as recommended in another thread this morning - and dozens of others - Use the teacherless time to practice with drones or suchlike.
Put the MP on in about the right place - and Practice; longtones, scales, patterns, tunes, noodling in one key/tone center from a drone MP3/App/iReal/etc. Then another.
This is frequently recommend. It's good for the playing and good for the ears. Also what I used to get used to a new MP (though I'm no role model for anything!)

Post in thread 'I have just bought an Otto Link Tone Edge for my tenor sax' Accessories - I have just bought an Otto Link Tone Edge for my tenor sax
 
Thanks @mizmar

I have been using drone tones (Thanks @skeller047) and practicing long tones as much as I can given the issues with my neighbour. I start each practice with scales and arpeggios, slowly and listening to each note trying to make it sound nice.

Quite an eye (ear?) opener for me! I thought I was coming along quite well but I think playing in the band many of my mistakes are 'hidden' or at least less noticeable. Playing alone and recording myself has highlighted many issues. I think I was getting overconfident and above myself. Lesson learnt!
 
Had another try today and some improvement.
Mpc now in a position that I can match B1 and B3 pitches on the meter and overtones B1 to B2.
Sounded better to me (more resonant and less flat) and the meter showed far more green smilies than yesterday; probably 10-20 cents off at times but that's me.

The learning process can be odd. Had the same with martial arts, you think you've 'got' something but in practice you haven't then a while later it comes naturally and you think WT?

Felt a bit down yesterday as I seemed to be getting nowhere. The new mpc has highlighted my limitations but at the same time has given me the impetus to persevere and hopefully improve.
 
The learning process can be odd. Had the same with martial arts, you think you've 'got' something but in practice you haven't then a while later it comes naturally and you think WT?
Of course it is.
"Getting something" intellectually or on-purpose is useless in martial arts. Any technique has to be in the "bones", ie muscle memory, pre-conscious or such, to be actuality usable. That's why repetition.

Equally you can't play in tune with a given tone on-purpose while actually playing a song. That's what I was getting at above. One needs, I believe, to connect the war and physiology directly; that's why repetition.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,235
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom