Playing the saxophone Different Bb alternative fingerings

True.

One thing that hasn't been discussed (unless I missed something) regards choices of doublers. I started on clarinet and yes, for the left hand the choices are slightly different than for sax. Thus, what others may consider as being less preferrable I find work for me.

Besides, as long as we both are able to achieve the same result musically up to tempo without undo hardship or degrading our performance, then it boils down to preferences.

Regarding drawing lines in the sand over Bb fingering choices, I hope we do not eliminate posters like in The Weakest Link TV game show. πŸ˜‰

Is it time to add a poll?
I had a head start on clarinet for about 15 years before I started playing sax properly. The bis key was a huge struggle, but I persevered as I saw the advantages.
I agree that smooth facility is the only goal and that can be achieved in any way, hence my flute analogy (as they have to make do with a relatively awkward F# (as far as us sax and clarinet players go) and their stock Bb is 1/1, not the alternative thumb fingering.
I got very got with the side throat Bb on clarinet, even when going up to C, because of the better sound before learning about β€œresonance fingerings” - also awkward and a somewhat re-learning of the clarinet but with massive payoff.
 
No I can see how they are smashed together. Odd scale. Strikes me as being very jazzy for a rock sound.
I think it sounds jazzy if a jazzplayer play it in fast tempo as Parker did. R&B sax ballads Bobby Forte and Noble Watts mixed scales as well. And even blues guitar players ... . To make a better Bis key touch would help me. To roll over to in more smooth way. The bis key touch is lower and there is also a gap. Something like this but it's made for old Conn saxes wo Bis key.
 
The ergonomic bis thing above looks quite effective, as thomsax says the usual bis key (on most saxophones I've had my hands on certainly ) is very awkwardly placed / designed to the degree I've always given it a big 'Nah..'
Obviously I can see the utility of a bis key as an option.
 
The ergonomic bis thing above looks quite effective, as thomsax says the usual bis key (on most saxophones I've had my hands on certainly ) is very awkwardly placed / designed to the degree I've always given it a big 'Nah..'
Obviously I can see the utility of a bis key as an option.
If the bis key is not placed properly of course it will be awkward to use. However, I don't agree that the usual bis key is awkwardly placed on most saxophones. Or maybe I've just played different horns than you have. On my '65 Mark VI tenor, a '50 Buescher Aristocrat 156 tenor, and '39 Series One 'art deco' Aristocrat tenor, the bis key is perfectly placed to roll on & off with the index finger. Have they somehow misplaced it on more modern horns? I'd be surprised if that was the case.
 
If the bis key is not placed properly of course it will be awkward to use. However, I don't agree that the usual bis key is awkwardly placed on most saxophones. Or maybe I've just played different horns than you have. On my '65 Mark VI tenor, a '50 Buescher Aristocrat 156 tenor, and '39 Series One 'art deco' Aristocrat tenor, the bis key is perfectly placed to roll on & off with the index finger. Have they somehow misplaced it on more modern horns? I'd be surprised if that was the case.
Had loads of saxophones thru my hands over the decades, 'vintage' in the main inc most of the American usuals, never had a mk 6 though ( ok I did use someone else's mk6 alto a couple of times in the early 80s ! )
Maybe my short stubby fingers don't do bis key very well :confused2:
I'd certainly need a bis key 'levelled up' and fiddled to be nearer the B like Thomsax's link or something, if it were to have a chance of working for me
 
I play three tenors: "The Martin Magna Tenor", "Martin Handcraft" and "The New King". The best Bis key is on the Magna. The worse is on the New King. On all three, the Bis key touches are not on the same height as the B and A key touches. So just to built up the bis key pearl holder would help? A round piece of brass .... . The gap between the B and A key touches and the Bis key varies as well, 2-3 mm to 6-7 mm.
 
I play three tenors: "The Martin Magna Tenor", "Martin Handcraft" and "The New King". The best Bis key is on the Magna. The worse is on the New King. On all three, the Bis key touches are not on the same height as the B and A key touches. So just to built up the bis key pearl holder would help? A round piece of brass .... . The gap between the B and A key touches and the Bis key varies as well, 2-3 mm to 6-7 mm.
Yes, it's not unusual to find the bis key pearl at a different height than the B touch. Build up the one that's lower. Done!
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,317
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom