Playing the saxophone Different Bb alternative fingerings

I don’t know but I do recall it being referred to as a fork Bb. Maybe that’s also not a proper thing.
Not sure about that. I think the forked fingering on clarinet is the Chalumeau B natural / clarion F# with RH 1st finger and extra key with 3rd finger (and of course LH 123 too)
 
Well, I'm pretty much a die-hard bis key user. The bis Bb is what I use about 95% of the time. With side Bb the other 5% or so. I do it automatically, without even having to think about it. Has this video been posted on here? Check it out:
My teacher showed me the bis key before sideBb and latterly 'long/forked' Bb. Definitely a roll on roll off motion but I don't think about it and it seems to work for me. I've only used long Bb in a few passages where it's easier for me than sideBb or bis.

My original query was intonation issues with long Bb. I'm sure I read about it on here* and some said depending on the horn L1+R1 or L1+R2 can affect intonation.

I tried L1+R1 & L1+R2 on the 5C and Soloist E again....L1+R1 best, Soloist L1+R2 best. Same horn different mpc.

It's not important just interesting to me.

* Found the conversation Playing the saxophone - F# fingering problems
 
For Bb I generally use B+Bis or A+side Bb but find for some passages long Bb is easier.
On a YTS-25 with the 5C mpc I can get decent Bb with any of L1+R1/R2/R3. On my newly acquired Soloist E L1+R2 and L1+R3 are ok but L1+R1 sounds flabby.
Is this due to the mpc, the horn or me?

Off to rehearsal so you argue amongst yourselves until I return later tonight. 😉
Thanks in advance.
Your job as a musician is to PRACTICE until you can achieve as nearly as possible the same pitch and timbre for each fingering of each note on your instrument.

The standard Bb for flute , and in my opinion it should be on saxophone but there are historical reasons why people don't want it to be, is 1 and 1 - index finger of each hand.
 
Just for fun, today I fooled around with the 1+1 Bb fingering and even though I will stick with the bis Bb, I will admit that the 1+1 fingering works fine for some passages. And I had no problem playing it in tune. But I don't find it any easier than the bis Bb. Maybe because I'm so used to the bis key. And there are situations where the bis key is far preferable, imo.
 
The standard Bb for flute , and in my opinion it should be on saxophone but there are historical reasons why people don't want it to be, is 1 and 1 - index finger of each hand.
When younger I used it less. I use it more frequently now. It comes quite natural in a good number of situations. I'm unfamiliar with historical reasons, can you explain?
1+2 is very useful too :thumb:
Yes, it has its place too, been there done that.
 
I feel like I've missed the boat somewhere, since I use just B+bis 99% of the time.
The alternate fingerings have their place, they are just the saxist's tool bag for certain situations. I find them useful particularly when there is part to be fingered quickly, they help make the notes flow better. As alluded to earlier, they are there for special cases, not for every case.
 
It works as well as 1+1, but neither are anywhere near as useful as the bis key.
Well different strokes for different folks, I never use the bis key ever, my normal Bb's are the two long ones. put simply 1 is good for flat keys 2 is good for # keys.
When it was advised to me as a kid it was reasoned that you're better using the main action of the instrument rather than, for instance, the side Bb which is more in the nature of a trill key. the bis key to me is very awkward and non intuitive, purely IMHO.
Be interesting to know what Mr Sax himself envisaged originally.
 
I would like to hear the differnece between Bis key and side Bb key. They re not sounding the same on my saxes. I think the B/H+A + side Bb key is clearer. It didn't stop me from using the Bis key.
 
Larry Teal extract
teal 2.webp
 
Switching between alto and clarinet, sometimes in the same song, I keep it simple so as not to confuse my fingers. It's confusing enough that the same pitch has different names on saxophone and clarinet. Add to this the 12th jump and chaos can enter. Pick up the sop and oh dear, my brain hurts.
My brain won't accept lh1 as flat.
 
FWIW, although I learned to use 1+1 for “In the Mood” in my first big band about 50+ years ago, my go-to Bb fingerings are bis and side Bb. I have no idea of the fractions of use as it depends on the context of the passage.
 
I never use the bis key ever
the bis key to me is very awkward and non intuitive

If you've never used it and haven't practiced using it, no wonder it seems awkward. If you watch that video by Greg Fishman that I posted, he explains its use pretty well. It's no harder to finger bis Bb than B using the left index finger. In plenty of situations, it's more efficient to use one finger, when possible, than two fingers. G minor arpeggios, Bb major or minor arpeggios, A-Bb-A triplets, for just a few (of many) examples make the case for the Bb bis key, as opposed to 1+1 Bb fingering.

If you never try, or practice using, the bis key or side Bb key, then you're stuck with 1+1. Of course, if the bis key isn't properly placed or adjusted on your horn so that you can roll off & on it easily, with just the slightest rotation of your index finger, then that would be a problem. Maybe that's the case with your horn?
 
If you've never used it and haven't practiced using it, no wonder it seems awkward. If you watch that video by Greg Fishman that I posted, he explains its use pretty well. It's no harder to finger bis Bb than B using the left index finger. In plenty of situations, it's more efficient to use one finger, when possible, than two fingers. G minor arpeggios, Bb major or minor arpeggios, A-Bb-A triplets, for just a few (of many) examples make the case for the Bb bis key, as opposed to 1+1 Bb fingering.

If you never try, or practice using, the bis key or side Bb key, then you're stuck with 1+1. Of course, if the bis key isn't properly placed or adjusted on your horn so that you can roll off & on it easily, with just the slightest rotation of your index finger, then that would be a problem. Maybe that's the case with your horn?
Naturally i've tried the bis key, (on different saxophones over the years) I'm aware of the concept of it, for me it just doesn't work as a fingering option.
..again, I've used side Bb, of course.. when I got the old Tune a Day book as a kid it's the first choice in the chart and I used it as the Bb initially. However, as I mentioned previously, a little later on I had various conversations with two ex dance band players from the swing era, both very experienced musicians, who both, independently suggested the long Bb's to be the way ahead, one adding the detail that it's preferable to use the main action of the saxophone whenever possible, which makes perfect sense, to me and I find works well. Hence either of the long Bb's are my usual choice depending on context.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,323
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom