Pete Effamy
Well-Known Member
I had a head start on clarinet for about 15 years before I started playing sax properly. The bis key was a huge struggle, but I persevered as I saw the advantages.True.
One thing that hasn't been discussed (unless I missed something) regards choices of doublers. I started on clarinet and yes, for the left hand the choices are slightly different than for sax. Thus, what others may consider as being less preferrable I find work for me.
Besides, as long as we both are able to achieve the same result musically up to tempo without undo hardship or degrading our performance, then it boils down to preferences.
Regarding drawing lines in the sand over Bb fingering choices, I hope we do not eliminate posters like in The Weakest Link TV game show. π
Is it time to add a poll?
I agree that smooth facility is the only goal and that can be achieved in any way, hence my flute analogy (as they have to make do with a relatively awkward F# (as far as us sax and clarinet players go) and their stock Bb is 1/1, not the alternative thumb fingering.
I got very got with the side throat Bb on clarinet, even when going up to C, because of the better sound before learning about βresonance fingeringsβ - also awkward and a somewhat re-learning of the clarinet but with massive payoff.
