A few more observations as I dig into this Ashton padded 10M...
As expected, the chief cause of the indistinct feeling as the key cups close is an uneven pad seat.
Below are the Bis Bb and top B pads - both pressed down lightly until the first contact with the tonehole is felt. What you see here is a classic case of 'back end bite', whereby the rear of the pad hits the tonehole before the front. Pads like this will close, but it requires a little bit of extra force (i.e. making the player do the work that the pad ought to be doing) and the payoff for this is a slightly squishy feel under the fingers. And that's on top of an inherent squishiness in the pads.
Here's the B pad removed from the key cup.
Now this is something that really ticks me off. Look at the state of the key cup...it's nowhere near flat.
It took me less than a minute to flatten this key cup - and I can't for the life of me see why on earth you wouldn't do that job while you were changing the pad. In fact not doing so just makes your life harder, because you'll be trying to seat a pad in a wonky key cup...and quite possibly onto a wonky tonehole (as indeed is the case here).
Note the construction on the pad. It's a synthetic core wrapped with a synthetic skin and backed with a cardboard base - so essentially a traditional design.
In attempting to reset the pads I've found that the existing seat is thermally stable. This has pros and cons; on the plus side it mean you can remove a pad, work on the key cup and tonehole and then refit the pad - which then requires you to match up the existing impression with the tonehole. On the down side there doesn't appear to be any way to alter the seat - such as by ironing the pad.
This leads to the situation seen on the lower shot. The pad is clearly too thick for the cup angle (and it's also somewhat...lumpy). Given that there's no way to correct this I've had to match the seat to the tonehole and forget about making it look presentable.
Some early conclusions then. I can see that the pads work. Where they're less than perfect I can tweak the setting (after a fashion) to achieve a good seal. Can't do too much about the feel, though a properly set pad feels better under the fingers than one that's biting at the back.
It seems to me that much reliance has been placed on the (somewhat suspect) ability of the pads to conform over anomalies - but it's also clear that it hasn't worked terribly well. Either the setting process was faulty...or the pads have a degree of recovery in them (as ordinary pads do) and this hasn't been accounted for and adjusted out.
So it's beginning to look like the problem with this particular job isn't so much the pads as the repad job itself. And it wasn't cheap.
I'll carry on and see if anything else crops up...