Tech/maintenance Why have pads had the same design for 150 years?

@Stephen Howard - do I recall you saying not too long ago, on the topic of levelling tone holes, that the mere act of tilting a horn from horizontal to a more vertical playing position can slightly distort a tone hole which has been levelled when horizontal? This makes sense, but also means the levelling needs to be done in the final playing position or the pad needs a degree of flexibility to accommodate this flexing.

I'm not sure a hardening silicon sealant, used as the sealing material, would allow for this slight flex unless it too has the same amount of flex as the tone hole, or a leather pad, or some other material.

What's your thought on this @Woodpad ?
 
@Stephen Howard - do I recall you saying not too long ago, on the topic of levelling tone holes, that the mere act of tilting a horn from horizontal to a more vertical playing position can slightly distort a tone hole which has been levelled when horizontal? This makes sense, but also means the levelling needs to be done in the final playing position or the pad needs a degree of flexibility to accommodate this flexing.
Yep, that's correct. Taking a horn from a supported horizontal position (on the workbench) to an unsupported vertical one is going to stress the body tube. It's not by much - about a thou or so here and there - but it's still worth accounting for.
To be sure, most pads will accommodate that amount of flex with relative ease when fresh and new - but given it takes so little time to account for it, it seems silly not to. And, of course, it pays dividends further down the line when the pads harden up.

Like I once said...the fewer variables the better.
 
Yep, that's correct. Taking a horn from a supported horizontal position (on the workbench) to an unsupported vertical one is going to stress the body tube. It's not by much - about a thou or so here and there - but it's still worth accounting for.
To be sure, most pads will accommodate that amount of flex with relative ease when fresh and new - but given it takes so little time to account for it, it seems silly not to. And, of course, it pays dividends further down the line when the pads harden up.

Like I once said...the fewer variables the better.
Surely that can't be as significant a factor, relatively speaking, by comparison with the 'play' in key mechanics and hinge rod gaps depending on vertical and horizontal position. Overall, adjustments that get done with the instrument lying on a work bench, rather than upright, are thus likely to be ever-so-slightly out of perfect, to an extent measurable in 'who cares' units.
 
Surely that can't be as significant a factor, relatively speaking, by comparison with the 'play' in key mechanics and hinge rod gaps depending on vertical and horizontal position. Overall, adjustments that get done with the instrument lying on a work bench, rather than upright, are thus likely to be ever-so-slightly out of perfect, to an extent measurable in 'who cares' units.
It depends what standards you're trying to achieve.
Thing is, if you adopt an "It'll do" approach - where do you draw the line? So you have a slightly warped tonehole. Meh. And some free play in the keywork. Pffft. And maybe a few less-than-perfect pad seats. Hey-ho.
This is all fine - if you don't care...or until you encounter a client who does care. And there are plenty of those out there.

Y'see, it all adds up. A thou here, a thou there. A significant leak (i.e. one that will have a noticeable effect on the response of a horn) can be as little as a thou. That's the thickness of a thin cigarette paper. If you have one of those on, say, the low C pad you'll find that you have to press that little bit harder to produce a clean, full note.
Now chuck in a bit of wear on the key so that the back of the keycup lifts when you press the key down. That's another 1 or 2 thou leak. And if the tonehole's a bit out of whack the length of the leak increases.
Now add in all the other leaks down the horn and you're looking at knocking off a worthwhile percentage of the response of the horn.

And here's the thing. All horns leak. Even right off the bench you're going to find leaks. They're not precision machines. Stuff moves, stuff flexes, things expand and contract. You have to account for these by dialling in compromises. You set a horn up by the book...then you throw the book away and play it, making the appropriate adjustments as necessary.

It really doesn't take much effort to sort all these things out - you just have to give a damn...and you end up with a horn that's able to give its very best. It's all in the details.
 
I appreciate the considered reply. I wasn't trying to suggest that such things don't matter, or don't add up. Indeed I have had years of frustration playing with what turned out to be almost invisibly tiny leaks in some soldered toneholes. I even find that leaving the neck receiver screw loose on what seems a perfectly snug tenon fit can adversely affect my sound, despite all notes being playable. My view is that the 'sagging' of a tonehole out of perfect through holding the sax in its vertical position surely has to be way down the list of those issues.
 
I appreciate the considered reply. I wasn't trying to suggest that such things don't matter, or don't add up. Indeed I have had years of frustration playing with what turned out to be almost invisibly tiny leaks in some soldered toneholes. I even find that leaving the neck receiver screw loose on what seems a perfectly snug tenon fit can adversely affect my sound, despite all notes being playable. My view is that the 'sagging' of a tonehole out of perfect through holding the sax in its vertical position surely has to be way down the list of those issues.
So let's take the 'snug' tenon as an example. Merely being snug is not an indication of a good fit. I can make a tenon joint as stiff as you like...and it can still leak. If the locking screw is doing anything other than juuuuust pinching up the tenon sleeve it means the receiver is being distorted - and that's when it starts to leak. So the detail here is to get the joint snug AND leak free without the screw being done up. If the screw makes a difference either way there's something out of whack.

I simply apply that process to the toneholes. If they deform by a thou when the horn is upright, why not sort it out? That extra response is right there...just waiting in the wings. Why not take it?
Not only does it give you more 'oomph' it also increases the length of time in which a pad will maintain a workable seal as it ages - and for a player that translates into a longer period of time before the horn has to go back on the bench.
And I can't see many players thinking that that's not something that's worth putting near the top of the list.
 
Since you're kindly taking the time to respond, let me just make the comment that (inspired by your 'sugru' octave key fix), I incline toward the future of pads going that way, with a more thermoplastic material (more in a separate thread here). Having such self-sealing pads would save having to make final adjustments with the sax upright, at target temperature and humidity (whatever those may ever be thought to be), etc.
 
Since you're kindly taking the time to respond, let me just make the comment that (inspired by your 'sugru' octave key fix), I incline toward the future of pads going that way, with a more thermoplastic material (more in a separate thread here). Having such self-sealing pads would save having to make final adjustments with the sax upright, at target temperature and humidity (whatever those may ever be thought to be), etc.
Yup, and I've commented on the prospect before. As such I'm more than happy to sit back and see what, if anything, comes to fruition.
 
Since you're kindly taking the time to respond, let me just make the comment that (inspired by your 'sugru' octave key fix), I incline toward the future of pads going that way, with a more thermoplastic material (more in a separate thread here). Having such self-sealing pads would save having to make final adjustments with the sax upright, at target temperature and humidity (whatever those may ever be thought to be), etc.
Remember the octave pips are not like conventional tone holes (The hole is much smaller) so easier to seal with cork, which cannot be done effectively on larger toneholes.

Plus the octave mech design means that the user doesn't close the holes as they would with the other notes so player feel isn't so important -Sugru once set is pretty hard and unyielding -it's probably going to feel very different and noisy.

I'll refrain from speculation as to how effective Sugru would be at sealing long-term.

Trying to compensate for bad toneholes is addressing the symptom and not the initial problem.
 
So? Do we have an answer to the thread title question?

Cleanly there's no shortage of alternative pad designs - and little obvious reasons engineers at Yamaha, Salmer etc. couldn't get something else to work.

What seems odd to me is that there's clearly a demand. From beginners being told to check for leaks when they can't get some tone or other; to pro's only allowing their favorite tech to repad etc. you'd'v thought "Guaranteed leak free" would be an appealing selling point.

I don’t believe that the answer to the perfect pad is Super-Squishy NeverLeak. And as soon as the design stiffness specification increases, it will lose its ability to accommodate the dented tone hole that some claim is inevitable.

I prefer skilled technicians to work on my horns because they adjust the mechanism so well and their work is robust. I leave the choice of pads to them.
 
The short answer is Why not? Until some hypothetical super materials come along that allow a truly worthwhile departure from established practice, perhaps conventional pads work fine enough?
 
Alright. What is your question?...which do you want to addess?

... The short answer...
To which question? 😄 Leaving aside that flakiness


It's the form of answers that fascinate me. There's the "yet another new pad design" brigade but there's the "fix the tone hole and any decent pad will work" perspective; with a modicum of others structural issues etc. and yet the market and economics says sell saxophones that are likely, sooner or later, to spring a leak.
Why that's the structure of the industry has not been elaborated.
 
Last edited:
I think it’s perfectly possible to make a “precision” saxophone that has keywork that is precise and doesn’t wear appreciably over time, and remains relatively easy to repair and adjust. Which opens the door to different and more precise types of seals for the toneholes.

But not out of brass tubes and steel rods and pivots. Maybe miniature ceramic bearings, and aluminum frames for the keys, or some other approach I can’t think of.

But it would be expensive… the fact is that the current approach with leather and felt pads, and cork, felt and slippery plastic adjustment materials, works just fine. Pads certainly have changed over the years, as have the adjustment materials, but it’s minor evolutionary steps. I suspect we will see more of them as time goes on. But I doubt they will be unrecognizable.
 
But not out of brass tubes and steel rods and pivots
I think that's the bottom line.
All the components are at about the same level of flakiness. Improve the rods and pivots hugely and your left with flaky tone holes and pads. Improve the pads hugely and your left with flaky rods and so on. Probably a $£€¥lots has all the bits done a bit better. Or a top tech would raise the stakes on everything. But they all the bits have to be improved in sync.
 
"Squishiness" in itself is a topic for research, let alone finding a new material that seals.

I spent a year and a half sifting through all kinds of synthetic material to find the perfect one for my new pads.
When the prototype horns went out for the first road test by techs and players here the main feedback wasn't on function, though the design needed some tweaks, but on "feel".

The pads didn't feel like traditional leather ones and this difference was off-putting. Too soft.
Now if my pads had preceded leather ones it would have perhaps been the leather ones which felt odd.
It's finding what folks are used to, feel-wise, as well as the mechanics of the new pads.

Add to this my desire to make my pads vegan, self-levelling, individually height adjustable, each one easily removable and replaceable (no glue needed), waterproof, airtight, washable, and you need to be in for the long haul. I hope to complete my work one day soon...
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,458
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom