Tech/maintenance Why have pads had the same design for 150 years?

@stitch - I recall reading something similar from @helen involving silicone but hadn't seen your one before.
Hers is here: A New Concept In Saxophone Pads: MDF & Silicone | The Bassic Sax Blog

The off the shelf neoprene version you linked to is here: Tru-Seal Website
Looks very similar to Jim Schmidt's: Sax Products Archives - JS Engineering
I am no expert in these matters, but if I were to look for a new material to replace pads in saxophones, I would be looking towards silicone.

But not like the solution that is mentioned in Helen's page you are referring to. That sounds like a DIY-fix that isn't very durable or fit for its purpose (using liquid silicone that is developed for completely different reasons for instance). And it also sounds very time consuming....

I have seen silicone products that have a good, lasting flexibility, are quite durable (more than neoprene for instance) and look like they could make an airtight seal on saxophone pads. It has the advantage that It could be made just like current pads and could be fitted to all existing saxes.

Not sure if they might not have a tendency to become sticky over time. But I guess that one could make some kind of silicone that doesn't stick.
 
The majority of overhauls I do (my own saxes included) use Music Medic Tan, Music Medic White and Chocolate Roo, and Pisoni Pro pads, all of which are on the "firmer"side of the spectrum. I agree that these pads require flat toneholes and well fit keys much more than softer pads that are more "forgiving". I have played on these types of pads long enough that I have become accustomed to the positive feel when the pad touches the tonehole and seals instantly without the additional travel into a deeper impression.

What pads do you stock and install that have the "bit of give" that you prefer?
Depends on the job. I like Pisoni Premium Deluxe, and the LP Pro - but for general work I use Pisoni Mypads.
 
@Wonko - the Trueseal pad top layer is made from open cell neoprene sealed with a spray on layer of silicone.

Neil Slade's DIY version linked to in post #3, and citing Trueseal as perhaps a better alternative, uses closed cell neoprene, aka diving suit rubber.

It sounds as though the open cell structure may hold the silicone spay in place. How this combination is better than neoprene alone I have no idea but I'm guessing Trueseal experimented and found this the best.
 
Maybe, as Neil says, closed cell neoprene would solve the breeding issue, however are leather, felt, and card pads any better as a "sterile" solution?

Then look at all the other nooks and crannies inside a saxophone where bugs can breed. Sure we pull through to dry it, but do we then put that pull-through into the wash after a single use? No, we leave it to fester and then shove it back down to smear some of its newly bred bugs onto our freshly laid spittle after the next play time.

Maybe forget the foam, but what else could safely give a modicum of cushioning between a solid backing and closed cell neoprene facing? I think whatever we do, unless we dip the whole sax in a bathtub of boiling water after every use, there will always be bugs galore!
 
There are a number of closed cell foam products out there but I used to work with some of them for thermal insulation of cryo cooling, condensation barrier and eventually they all turned into sponges. This may have had something to do with the low temperatures (-40C) but the breakdown happened at the outside of the material facing room temperature. It might be worth a shot but don't think that because it is new it has to be superior.
 
Shoes have been made from leather for thousands of years and there are other materials but leather is still the most pervasive material. If you ever had shoes made from vinyl, you'll know why.
Vinyl, which became ‘faux leather’ or ‘vegan leather’, and is now more expensive than its real leather alternatives
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,459
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom