Tech/maintenance Why have pads had the same design for 150 years?

Sometimes. But in cases where there was water in the pipes they couldn't solder so they used leather until somebody came up with the bread trick.
That is also a time when some water pipes where made from lead using the first industrial twin screw extruder. Could be tricky to solder lead pipes as they melt almost as fast as the solder.
 
As an innovator in saxophone pads I feel I should react to this topic. First I want to point to Iwan Müller was the first known inventor to use a leather felt pad and a metal ligature around 1810. So This pad exists for more than 200 years. Of which my silicon pad project only used 17. Making it the longest R&D project I have ever done. The fastest was to bring a new product in production in three hours and the second longest was to introduce a new concept in candy in 9 years.
I am a bit embarrassed by this, but it is a one man project with minimal back-up against the gold standard in pads backed by most of the saxophone world.

So why did I decide to go against the gold standard. Just as Edmund Hilary said: because it was there.
Now for the argumentized version. There is a small flaw in the gold standard of a leather felt pad on a perfectly flat tone hole. Saxophones are made of bendy material so the tone holes do not stay flat in the long run.
Correcting this without using abrasive methods is a Sisyfus labor. Using a file means that you lose some material and in the long run the tone hole becomes too shallow for leather pads.

So the project is to make a usable seal on a non-flat saxophone tone hole. You can do this with a leather pad, but it is sub standard and doesn't last as long as a leather pad on a flat tone hole.
All other pad projects I know of work with the assumption of perfect flat tone holes and have a similar small flaw.

At the moment I am confident in fitting small and medium sized pads in a reasonable time. Small corrections can be done in one day due to the hardening time of the silicone paste used.
The order of my present priorities for this project are:

1 have fun
2 doing large pads faster
3 understanding the differences between rolled and straight tone holes for this method
4 ordering the first industrial made version of these pads
5 expanding to ringpads for a padless system
6 looking for a more optimal type of silicon.
 
As an innovator in saxophone pads I feel I should react to this topic. First I want to point to Iwan Müller was the first known inventor to use a leather felt pad and a metal ligature around 1810. So This pad exists for more than 200 years. Of which my silicon pad project only used 17. Making it the longest R&D project I have ever done. The fastest was to bring a new product in production in three hours and the second longest was to introduce a new concept in candy in 9 years.
I am a bit embarrassed by this, but it is a one man project with minimal back-up against the gold standard in pads backed by most of the saxophone world.

So why did I decide to go against the gold standard. Just as Edmund Hilary said: because it was there.
Now for the argumentized version. There is a small flaw in the gold standard of a leather felt pad on a perfectly flat tone hole. Saxophones are made of bendy material so the tone holes do not stay flat in the long run.
Correcting this without using abrasive methods is a Sisyfus labor. Using a file means that you lose some material and in the long run the tone hole becomes too shallow for leather pads.

“Don’t stay flat in the long run”??? Why would you make such a statement?

“In the long run the tone hole becomes too shallow…”. How is it that people are playing saxes over 50 years old? Shouldn’t those tone holes have disappeared a long time ago?

So the project is to make a usable seal on a non-flat saxophone tone hole. You can do this with a leather pad, but it is sub standard and doesn't last as long as a leather pad on a flat tone hole.
All other pad projects I know of work with the assumption of perfect flat tone holes and have a similar small flaw.

At the moment I am confident in fitting small and medium sized pads in a reasonable time. Small corrections can be done in one day due to the hardening time of the silicone paste used.
The order of my present priorities for this project are:

1 have fun
2 doing large pads faster
3 understanding the differences between rolled and straight tone holes for this method
4 ordering the first industrial made version of these pads
5 expanding to ringpads for a padless system
6 looking for a more optimal type of silicon.

I’m all for you having fun with your projects, but your claims are just false.

As to rolled vs straight tone holes, modern pads work just fine on either.
 
“Don’t stay flat in the long run”??? Why would you make such a statement?

“In the long run the tone hole becomes too shallow…”. How is it that people are playing saxes over 50 years old? Shouldn’t those tone holes have disappeared a long time ago?



I’m all for you having fun with your projects, but your claims are just false.

As to rolled vs straight tone holes, modern pads work just fine on either.
Agreed with one exception. Working on lots of sopranos lately, I did find that the depth of the seat, that is how far the center cushion sticks into the tone hole definitely makes a difference in intonation. Gorilla grip makes the notes play sharp. But that's really just noticeable on sopranos, even on alto, there is hardly any difference.
Grinding down tone holes, with a little bit of swabbing one may lose 1/10 of a mm in the course of 50 years. so that's the part I don't buy.
As for rolled tone holes, I can see an effect with respect to seat depth but other than soprano, nobody will be able to hear the difference.
 
Saxophones are made of bendy material so the tone holes do not stay flat in the long run.
Correcting this without using abrasive methods is a Sisyfus labor. Using a file means that you lose some material and in the long run the tone hole becomes too shallow for leather pads.
It has not been my experience that once a tonehole has been correctly* levelled, it does not stay flat. I regularly work on horns that I'd carried out tonehole work on decades ago - and aside from a little dressing to remove hardened gunk deposits from the rims, they're as flat now as they ever were. And if they're not it's always as a result of damage.
If the work is done properly it's a one-time operation - and if remedial work is necessary, the initial process of mechanical levelling will reduce the amount of dressing required to the region of a few thou.

* Taking into account the flex in the tubing during the levelling process.

Toneholes only become too shallow because of inappropriate levelling methods. The exclusive use of rotary (or large flat) files defers to the lowest dip - resulting in an excess of metal being removed. This is not a problem with the process - rather the method.
Non-abrasive levelling methods require a fair degree of skill, experience and bespoke tooling - so yes, it's initially a slow process...but one that speeds up considerably once you've 'got your eye in'.
 
“Don’t stay flat in the long run”??? Why would you make such a statement?

“In the long run the tone hole becomes too shallow…”. How is it that people are playing saxes over 50 years old? Shouldn’t those tone holes have disappeared a long time ago?



I’m all for you having fun with your projects, but your claims are just false.

As to rolled vs straight tone holes, modern pads work just fine on either.
still only opinions and no arguments?
 
Agreed with one exception. Working on lots of sopranos lately, I did find that the depth of the seat, that is how far the center cushion sticks into the tone hole definitely makes a difference in intonation. Gorilla grip makes the notes play sharp. But that's really just noticeable on sopranos, even on alto, there is hardly any difference.
Grinding down tone holes, with a little bit of swabbing one may lose 1/10 of a mm in the course of 50 years. so that's the part I don't buy.
As for rolled tone holes, I can see an effect with respect to seat depth but other than soprano, nobody will be able to hear the difference.
There are some technicians who can keep it to 1/10 of a mm but there are a lot more technicians who work at 2 mm in 30 years.

For some reason my pads work different with rolled tone holes, so I made no statement on leather pads
 
It has not been my experience that once a tonehole has been correctly* levelled, it does not stay flat. I regularly work on horns that I'd carried out tonehole work on decades ago - and aside from a little dressing to remove hardened gunk deposits from the rims, they're as flat now as they ever were. And if they're not it's always as a result of damage.
If the work is done properly it's a one-time operation - and if remedial work is necessary, the initial process of mechanical levelling will reduce the amount of dressing required to the region of a few thou.

* Taking into account the flex in the tubing during the levelling process.

Toneholes only become too shallow because of inappropriate levelling methods. The exclusive use of rotary (or large flat) files defers to the lowest dip - resulting in an excess of metal being removed. This is not a problem with the process - rather the method.
Non-abrasive levelling methods require a fair degree of skill, experience and bespoke tooling - so yes, it's initially a slow process...but one that speeds up considerably once you've 'got your eye in'.
It is good to hear that I am a bit pessimistic on the bendy character of saxophones. Still dents and dent work can affect the flatness of the tone hole. I have a lot of technicians in my family so I know how difficult non-abrasive leveling is and I decided to reach the same effect with a method more fitting to my skill level.
 
It is good to hear that I am a bit pessimistic on the bendy character of saxophones. Still dents and dent work can affect the flatness of the tone hole. I have a lot of technicians in my family so I know how difficult non-abrasive leveling is and I decided to reach the same effect with a method more fitting to my skill level.
I think your original statement was rather more than a bit of pessimism - it came across more like "I have studied this phenomenon in depth and can categorically say that...".

Yep, dents and dentwork can affect the flatness of the toneholes - but this stands true for any method of padding. You can undoubtedly build some tolerance into a new design, but there will be limits as to what it can achieve - and a corresponding effect on the feel.
 
Agreed with one exception. Working on lots of sopranos lately, I did find that the depth of the seat, that is how far the center cushion sticks into the tone hole definitely makes a difference in intonation. Gorilla grip makes the notes play sharp. But that's really just noticeable on sopranos, even on alto, there is hardly any difference.
Grinding down tone holes, with a little bit of swabbing one may lose 1/10 of a mm in the course of 50 years. so that's the part I don't buy.
As for rolled tone holes, I can see an effect with respect to seat depth but other than soprano, nobody will be able to hear the difference.

Woodpads was positing that the repeated act of filing tone holes over the lifetime of a horn rendered the tole hole to get ever shorter - the Cheshire Cat Effect.
 
It is good to hear that I am a bit pessimistic on the bendy character of saxophones. Still dents and dent work can affect the flatness of the tone hole. I have a lot of technicians in my family so I know how difficult non-abrasive leveling is and I decided to reach the same effect with a method more fitting to my skill level.

Yes, dents can affect the flatness of tone holes... Is that really the norm for saxophones in their lifetime? I have been playing for 50+ years and never damaged a tone hole. Does everyone else bung up their tone holes in normal use?
 
So? Do we have an answer to the thread title question?

Cleanly there's no shortage of alternative pad designs - and little obvious reasons engineers at Yamaha, Salmer etc. couldn't get something else to work.

What seems odd to me is that there's clearly a demand. From beginners being told to check for leaks when they can't get some tone or other; to pro's only allowing their favorite tech to repad etc. you'd'v thought "Guaranteed leak free" would be an appealing selling point.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,464
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom