Tech/maintenance Why have pads had the same design for 150 years?

Another thought... why is it new pads are wedged shut to create an indentation from the tone hole in the pad surface, and what force is applied? A different force will compress the felt underneath to a different depth and the resulting hardening of the felt in its compressed state will alter the final feel of the keywork surely?

Lightly compressed felt will retain some impact absorption whereas hard compressed felt will feel like the key cup is hitting metal.

So, what measurement do the factories use when applying force to new pad wedges?
And why is this needed anyway? Wouldn't it be better to leave the pad surface as is so that it has a little flexibility on impact? Or is the compression to swallow up any unevenness in the tone hole rim, moulding their waviness into the pad?

If using neoprene or silicone for a pad, as some have done, would that not seal well each time AND cope with any tone hole undulations?
 
Another thought... why is it new pads are wedged shut to create an indentation from the tone hole in the pad surface, and what force is applied? A different force will compress the felt underneath to a different depth and the resulting hardening of the felt in its compressed state will alter the final feel of the keywork surely?

Lightly compressed felt will retain some impact absorption whereas hard compressed felt will feel like the key cup is hitting metal.

So, what measurement do the factories use when applying force to new pad wedges?
And why is this needed anyway? Wouldn't it be better to leave the pad surface as is so that it has a little flexibility on impact? Or is the compression to swallow up any unevenness in the tone hole rim, moulding their waviness into the pad?

If using neoprene or silicone for a pad, as some have done, would that not seal well each time AND cope with any tone hole undulations?
New pads are wedged shut very slightly, at least if it is done right, there should be only a very shallow "seat". But when you start playing, the seats will develop anyway depending on the grip strength until the pads settle for the status quo - with the player at hand and the key in question. And the pad in question as well. In the case of the palm and side keys, it is a bit more the initial wedge but even there, the spring tension will add a little over time.

And if you don't play a horn for an extended period of time, you may lose the "memory" of the pad seats and you'll have to play for a few hours until things are back.

Neoprene and some synthetic materials become sticky and brittle over time and you would start ripping tiny pieces of material out of the body of the pad that would cling to the tone hole.

So my answer to the original question is "why ask why?"
 
I was reading a thread elsewhere last night where someone suggested silicone could get sticky and then someone else said not, here: https://www.saxontheweb.net/threads/silicone-pads-anyone.360270/#post-3974804

I can see that an open call foam type of pad, like the Truseal ones, or even closed cell where the surface is foam like, could hold saliva and that in turn could leave a sticky surface to the pad but the same holds true for leather with it's pores, even if waterproofed.

A smooth faced silicone foam pad may be the answer.

Why ask the question?... because it was there... in my head.
 
Regarding plastic, during the first lockdown I had a torn pad and no way to get it replaced so I put cling film over it, it needed tightening from time to time but kept me going, with a good seal, for a couple of months. It was the top E so quite small but plastic can work. Of course it had a firm leather pad underneath it but it could have been a synthetic base.
I have successfully sorted a torn pad with a circle of brown plastic packaging tape, created and fitted without removing the key, using no more than the scissors and tweezers on a swiss army knife.
 
As a pad surface, not far off. Waterproof, sound reflective, durably sticky (applied to a dry pad), and even a close enough colour to look the part (at gig distance).
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,463
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom