I do hope @annw has not been put off by this runaway discussion.
I do find it fascinating.
My (online) reed flute (nay) teacher has been working hard on a new online teaching and resource (eg transcriptions etc) site. It's exciting because, unlike sax, he has no competition. We discuss aspects quite often; it's always good to get perspectives, I'm freshly through the beginner / early intermediate phase, have dwelled in the Metropolis of online sax teachers and have European ears. Several suggestions have been included; a series on singing Solfège, something about rhythmic patterns.
Then there's the packaging; online only, online+Skype, online+recorded exchange etc. It's actually very hard question. Two things are certain. 1/ If developing a sax emboucher and playing in tune is hard, it's 100x harder on this instrument /tradition (with fractional tones etc.). 2/ 90% (who knows, depends on the individual and their level) of what he does on Skype can be done with the online resources for most people making his "in person" time more efficient / valuable.
Finally, before I signed up for lessons I could actually play a couple of octaves and some tunes (from his and other YouTube demos) and had researched the musical system; and only signed up for lessons because I had run out of places to go; but having signed up I have committed to doing things his way (mostly) as an individual experience. He has certainly helped improve my music playing in general. I haven't run out of places to go on sax, far from it.
It's a mixed bag.
Some people need to lean on a teacher to get going, others to get inspiration; while others still find it frustrating or actually enjoy a spell of autodidacting. For some (many) a teacher is an essential part of the puzzle; for some, just an additional bit of the quilt.
I do find it fascinating.
My (online) reed flute (nay) teacher has been working hard on a new online teaching and resource (eg transcriptions etc) site. It's exciting because, unlike sax, he has no competition. We discuss aspects quite often; it's always good to get perspectives, I'm freshly through the beginner / early intermediate phase, have dwelled in the Metropolis of online sax teachers and have European ears. Several suggestions have been included; a series on singing Solfège, something about rhythmic patterns.
Then there's the packaging; online only, online+Skype, online+recorded exchange etc. It's actually very hard question. Two things are certain. 1/ If developing a sax emboucher and playing in tune is hard, it's 100x harder on this instrument /tradition (with fractional tones etc.). 2/ 90% (who knows, depends on the individual and their level) of what he does on Skype can be done with the online resources for most people making his "in person" time more efficient / valuable.
Finally, before I signed up for lessons I could actually play a couple of octaves and some tunes (from his and other YouTube demos) and had researched the musical system; and only signed up for lessons because I had run out of places to go; but having signed up I have committed to doing things his way (mostly) as an individual experience. He has certainly helped improve my music playing in general. I haven't run out of places to go on sax, far from it.
It's a mixed bag.
Some people need to lean on a teacher to get going, others to get inspiration; while others still find it frustrating or actually enjoy a spell of autodidacting. For some (many) a teacher is an essential part of the puzzle; for some, just an additional bit of the quilt.


)