Saxophone beginners Where do I start? (complete beginner)

I do hope @annw has not been put off by this runaway discussion.

I do find it fascinating.
My (online) reed flute (nay) teacher has been working hard on a new online teaching and resource (eg transcriptions etc) site. It's exciting because, unlike sax, he has no competition. We discuss aspects quite often; it's always good to get perspectives, I'm freshly through the beginner / early intermediate phase, have dwelled in the Metropolis of online sax teachers and have European ears. Several suggestions have been included; a series on singing Solfège, something about rhythmic patterns.

Then there's the packaging; online only, online+Skype, online+recorded exchange etc. It's actually very hard question. Two things are certain. 1/ If developing a sax emboucher and playing in tune is hard, it's 100x harder on this instrument /tradition (with fractional tones etc.). 2/ 90% (who knows, depends on the individual and their level) of what he does on Skype can be done with the online resources for most people making his "in person" time more efficient / valuable.

Finally, before I signed up for lessons I could actually play a couple of octaves and some tunes (from his and other YouTube demos) and had researched the musical system; and only signed up for lessons because I had run out of places to go; but having signed up I have committed to doing things his way (mostly) as an individual experience. He has certainly helped improve my music playing in general. I haven't run out of places to go on sax, far from it.

It's a mixed bag.

Some people need to lean on a teacher to get going, others to get inspiration; while others still find it frustrating or actually enjoy a spell of autodidacting. For some (many) a teacher is an essential part of the puzzle; for some, just an additional bit of the quilt.
 
Two things are certain. 1/ If developing a sax emboucher and playing in tune is hard, it's 100x harder on this instrument /tradition (with fractional tones etc.).
I’m not sure I agree.

You’re saying that this instrument demands 100% of all the nuances/techniques or it is considered wrong, or just not playing it properly.

Well, let’s say that western traditions demand that cellists play with all the skill and nuance of Du Pre, and tenor players aren’t really playing properly unless playing like Brecker.

The fact that players like Murray Perahia, Brecker (and everyone I can think of) talk about the never ending array of things to learn tells you all you need to know. If you are driven to keep improving then all instruments and all styles of music will happily take pretty much all the hours you have on this earth.
 
Last edited:
I’m not sure I agree.

You’re saying that this instrument demands 100% of all the nuances/techniques or it is considered wrong, or just not playing it properly.

Well, let’s say that western traditions demand that cellists play with all the skill and nuance of Du Pre, and tenor players aren’t really playing properly unless playing like Brecker.
I didn't say that. The 100% is a random number - and I meant 100x! And I was talking about a beginners ("developing"). And I was comparing to the sax... I'd guess un-fretted instruments are also piles harder than fretted ones - but I don't play strings.

This flute has no mouthpiece and your blowing at the end hole; so you're embouchure does a lot more work in tuning than on a sax (or even a transverse flute). And no keywork. Each note has to be tuned balancing air pressure, angle, voicing. And, like the recorder etc. Lots of half holes, cross fingering and general wrangling.

It is not unusual that someone has to spend weeks trying before even generating a note.

And I think talking about top flight musicians is a red herring. We're talking about teachers and beginners; not (semi) professionals and coaching.
 
From above:
"It is not unusual that someone has to spend weeks trying before even generating a note."

One lesson with a competent flute teacher, would solve that problem.
All instruments have their challenges, and any Oboe player will claim the greatest degree of difficulty, repeatedly. :cheers:
 
From above:
"It is not unusual that someone has to spend weeks trying before even generating a note."

One lesson with a competent flute teacher, would solve that problem.
No not at all. This is why my teacher told me.
Again, I was comparing to the sax. And I'm talking about an end brown reed flute not a boehm, transverse flute.
 
un-fretted instruments are also piles harder than fretted ones
No. This is my point. They all have problems that come into focus at different points.

Unfretted means more in tune as the player becomes the “compromise “. Fretted means knowing where to put your fingers but tuning can be a nightmare when certain types of chords are together - as the guitar then ceases to work 💯
 
Last edited:
It is not unusual that someone has to spend weeks trying before even generating a note.
At least there are no 10-note Bill Evan’s chords to get your fingers around or read. Once you get the blowing and a bit more what else is there? (I’m not saying this takes a small amount of time - but while other instruments progress more easily in come areas, they don’t in others).
 
Gosh, I've touched a nerve.
Shame, because I thinks it's one of the most fascinating things in music; how creative musicians can take even the most simple instrument and push the boundaries of what's possible and musical.
The saxophone is a great example. It was clearly designed to get squaddies into marching bands with minimum effort - and yet generations of players have found all the nuances to make it an extremely versatile tool.

At no point have I thought or said being a good musician on one instrument is intrinsically harder or easier than on another. That'd be a weird thing to think.

But the sax just is easier to get started on then some other instruments .. and harder than others.
 
Last edited:
Now that we seem to have veered totally off topic we should maybe split the thread but it seems it bit of a daunting task. So I’ll continue about teachers here for now.

There are some really good teachers but there are also some not so good. I know this having given lessons to students who were also teachers or about to become teachers.

It’s almost impossible to know how good a teacher is without some objective criteria of the students’ progress, even than the individual students aptitude for specific types of learning would completely skew that data.
Perhaps an admin could split the thread where it turns into the teacher vs self exploration thread.
I intend to do that...one day.
 
Certainly. I was making a specific comparison, though, not claiming anything about mastery or general musicianship... Just what does it take to be a settled beginner.
But for me, the part about having to use ¼ tones etc and talking about starting out is akin to wanting a sax player to have good intonation and play with vibrato. From the off.
1/ If developing a sax emboucher and playing in tune is hard, it's 100x harder on this instrument /tradition (with fractional tones etc.)
this is your quote. That’s advanced stuff. You can argue that it’s part of the instrument but (for the main part) so is vibrato to flute, oboe, sax, strings, guitar. Yet we don’t think about vibrato in the first lesson. And articulation? Bowing? Holding a violin so that you don’t get RSI in a few years?
 
That’s advanced stuff.
Not as I was taught. By a teacher!
I wanted to learn the instrument to learn the maqam system and that's how the teacher teaches it. And that includes 45¢ and, indeed, 10¢ offsets for some notes from the get go (in principal! It's hard!). In his system / tradition; in which he otherwise stays close to ET.

To be fair, the D tuned Nay plays E and B flat and half flat with "natural" fingering, E and B natural are half holed. So those aren't the hardest thing. But there's a range of tuning challenges as I mentioned above. Beginner is the second octave. The first octave is hader to tune, in general, and (for D instrument ) low Ab through to B are all open top holes + wrangling! More like sax altissimo above G... And that's end beginner early intermediate. It's a pretty rubbish instrument. God knows how is survived over 3000 years.

But, sure, 2 years and we haven't touched - his standard curriculum doesn't get to - vibrato or many idiomatic decorations. Still working on intermediate core skills (tuning timing; straight playing well). Then, apparently, improvisation...

Anyway.

I know that uncountable numbers of school kids get into playing recorder pretty quickly and will never give a Baroque recital.
Getting a tune out of a sax is a bit harder.
And getting a tune out of a nay even harder...

Ps.

Taking of recorder, here's an interview by Sarah Jeffries with a nay player.

View: https://youtu.be/CvXH4uhoLw8?t=4m19s


I also note that Sarah, who often has a go on other instruments, didn't touch this one.
 
Last edited:
As an adult, one may not need tutoring but for a season. A good instructor can help with intonation, phrasing, use of alternate fingerings, selecting the right mouthpiece and reed combination, improving one's technique, and etc.

Think of it as someone coaching you, as in TV series, The Voice, taking you where you are at and moving you toward show performance. They take you from where you are at, and move you further ahead.

There are good instructors and so-so instructors. Finding a good one is a key.

Fortunately for a time here in New Mexico, the government offered low tuition to senior residents at state colleges and universities. About 5 years ago, I took a semester long Jazz Ensemble Class at Eastern New Mexico University, it cost me around $60.00 US. It was a lab class. Although I could take for credit, I took it for grade.

It was a small class of about 10 students. The instructor, a graduate student took us through various methods of expression. We finally performed at their Spring Concert. I forgot what the tune was, but I played alto. It was thrilling to play before a full audience.

I aced it.
 
Not as I was taught. By a teacher!
I wanted to learn the instrument to learn the maqam system and that's how the teacher teaches it. And that includes 45¢ and, indeed, 10¢ offsets for some notes from the get go (in principal! It's hard!). In his system / tradition; in which he otherwise stays close to ET.

To be fair, the D tuned Nay plays E and B flat and half flat with "natural" fingering, E and B natural are half holed. So those aren't the hardest thing. But there's a range of tuning challenges as I mentioned above. Beginner is the second octave. The first octave is hader to tune, in general, and (for D instrument ) low Ab through to B are all open top holes + wrangling! More like sax altissimo above G... And that's end beginner early intermediate. It's a pretty rubbish instrument. God knows how is survived over 3000 years.

But, sure, 2 years and we haven't touched - his standard curriculum doesn't get to - vibrato or many idiomatic decorations. Still working on intermediate core skills (tuning timing; straight playing well). Then, apparently, improvisation...

Anyway.

I know that uncountable numbers of school kids get into playing recorder pretty quickly and will never give a Baroque recital.
Getting a tune out of a sax is a bit harder.
And getting a tune out of a nay even harder...

Ps.

Taking of recorder, here's an interview by Sarah Jeffries with a nay player.

View: https://youtu.be/CvXH4uhoLw8?t=4m19s


I also note that Sarah, who often has a go on other instruments, didn't touch this one.
But it defines the instrument more. As for recorder, notwithstanding its own idiosyncracies, it doesn't require an "embouchure", just an airstream.

But, having digressed, whatever the instrument, it's possible to do something drastically wrong from the very beginning. In which case, perhaps a teacher might help...

We're all familiar with the "I love sax" (or whatever it was) album of the '80's with the mouthpiece on the wrong way up on the album cover? Well, it's playable like that....
 
There is a slight error in my post above. We performed about 5 weeks after the class started. (As a senior I've become more OCD, Old-Cranky-and-Dangerous - curmudgeon to those across the pond. :banana:)

This is a portion of the programme, I was in Jazz Combo #3, played alto. (States me on tenor, but programme was produced ahead of time.) The combos played first, then the singers, followed by the "big band" ensemble.

2020-02-20 ENMU Spring 2020 Jazz Program-0b.webp

Thursday, February 20, 2020, Buchanan Hall, 7:00 p.m., Eastern New Mexico University, Portales, NM. The above is the first portion of the programme.

Although I opted for grade, an option could be auditing (participating without grade) a college level course. My degree is not in music, but after conferring with the university staff permitted me to attend this class.

This is another option for those who are intermediate to advanced players.
 
Those of us who advocate having a teacher/mentor/experienced friend to give advice are not advocating finding an old-fashioned by-the-book teacher.

It seems to me that argument against a teacher/guide/coach always seems to involve worst-case scenarios.

All I/we are trying to do is keep you going, get the best out of it, don’t “descend into a sax-depression “ through being right royally stuck or going down the wrong route since forever.

Thom, I also think you’re on my side of the argument actually because you’re not really self-taught are you - lots of Rock Sax workshops and this guy and that guy - it’s a hive of a learning community, not a lonesome shed.

Reminds me of a quote from Richard Bach:

“Argue for your limitations and, sure enough, they’re yours”

From the day one as sax honker I've been searching for input for my sax playing. Recordings, magazines, books, sax playing persons .... and I solve my "problems" with the info I got. I'm still doing this. That's how most people are working. When I say I'm self-learned I mean that I haven't haven't followed the traditional way like playing in concert bands or having sax lessons from a sax teacher. I took some lessons back in the mid 70's. I played football back then and I thought a teacher could help me to play more and in a more efficient way. It didn't turn out well for me. So without the blues and rock jam sessions in Copenhagen I would probably not been honking today.

I've been flourished with the saxophone for nearly 60 years. I've met lots a sax players/sax owners on different levels through the years. I'm a curious person, so I often ask questions. And they ask me questions. I don't think it's so special to play an instrument in the way I do. It's like playing football, hockey, cooking .... you need enthusiasm, dedication, some basic skills and to be in the right environment.

I made friend with a Rock & Roll saxophonist, Andrew Clark, who was writing in Saxophone Journal; "Rock & Roll Saxophone". Andrew was the leader at the workshops, I made them happen. I didn't play at the workshops. But I was there.

Personally I don't believe in traditional "student - sax teacher" teaching when it comes to adults. It's different with children.It's very strange for me that an adult person is "graded" when it's music education on voluntary basis.

I consider my self as an autodidact RockSax player. I don't believe in traditional saxophone teaching. I live in Sweden. You, Pete Effamy, prefer traditional sax teaching and you live in UK. That's great. A well educated sax teacher and a fine player and a woodshed honker (self-learned and not particular good as player) can work in the same direction to avoid that the sax depression is not going too deep. Maybe we shouldn't share the same "arena" to promote sax learning?
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,427
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom