Saxophone beginners Where do I start? (complete beginner)

You know, there exist multiple teachers, with multiple ways of communicating and instructing. They don't all get the "this is the one true way" chip implanted.

Rather than throwing out the baby with the bathwater, it might be worth actually interviewing multiple instructors, pointing out one's own particular status, and ASKING "so, what would you sugggest for me?"
I agree. I often get the sense that those who say they don't learn well from teachers actually have rarely tried, and certainly haven't expressed what they want to learn. "Get me started", or "I want to learn altissimo", or "how do I play in tune better?" and so on. To me, and I might be wrong of course, it often comes across more as stubbornness, for the sake of it.

It's good that the OP here is considering moving their position, and even if they don't go with a teacher, I still think that some of the perception of what a teacher would do and bring has moved away from teaching them classical music or teaching them hardcore jazz 2-5-1s.
 
You know, there exist multiple teachers, with multiple ways of communicating and instructing. They don't all get the "this is the one true way" chip implanted.

Rather than throwing out the baby with the bathwater, it might be worth actually interviewing multiple instructors, pointing out one's own particular status, and ASKING "so, what would you sugggest for me?"
Different strokes. I've aways played to make money, not to conform.

I do wonder if some find that everything I post is wrong.
 
I often get the sense that those who say they don't learn well from teachers actually have rarely tried, and certainly haven't expressed what they want to learn. "Get me started", or "I want to learn altissimo", or "how do I play in tune better?" and so on. To me, and I might be wrong of course, it often comes across more as stubbornness, for the sake of it
With respect, I don't learn well from teachers. From age 8 till now; in any subject or discipline.
Not saying I've learned nothing in class or from guidance. But I don't like it and much prefer exploring a subject for myself; and I accept enjoy taking wrong tunings or dead ends; they are part of learning.

I have a reed flute teacher because there's not enough information available in English, in books or the web. And his discipline for timing is pushing me forward on my weakest foot, which I appreciate. But I already knew quite a lot going in so can steer things when I need to. But it would be quite hard to "express what I want to learn" if I hadn't done a pile of self-learning first.

Being autodidakt is as much a skill as anything. If self-learning is stubborn, maybe leaning in a teacher is, what? Limp? No....

... There is no right or wrong.
It's a personal choice, specially for adults. And depending on what someone wants to achieve.
 
I think you've taken what I've said out of context somewhat there, @mizmar. I'm not saying self learning is stubborn. I'm saying that the people I encounter who often say they don't learn well from teachers come across as stubborn.

I too very much enjoy going and learning about something, pressing ahead, trying to figure things out myself. I'm pretty good at it in a lot of areas as well. But I'm also well aware of a time for some humility, and when seeking guidance from another is actually a better option. And I don't put all teachers in the same bucket - some are good, some are not. If I'd had any decent physics teachers when I was a kid, I'd probably be a physicist now - but unfortunately they were all tired old men who thought that Newton was the be all and end all.

I genuinely think that almost all beginner saxophonists will fare better and advance quicker with a few lessons to begin with. After that, on the right path, sure go do your thing. But I've seen so many people just unable to make a sound for a long time, which must be incredibly frustrating, and then a few simple pointers resolves that.

The age of the internet and the wealth of information it brings is great, but also a problem too
 
Re - learning the basics like blowing into the mouthpiece: that's why I bought several beginner courses on Udemy from a variety of sax players - to teach me the basics - they will all say similar things, but in different ways, and I'm sure I will pick up something valuable from them all.
You seem to have made your mind up on this point, which is fair enough, but what's missing there is feedback. You may think you're doing what it says in the book/video, but not be.
 
I think you've taken what I've said out of context
Maybe. But the broader context is - yet another - thread where someone who says they want to kick off by themselves get dog-piled.

I genuinely think that almost all beginner saxophonists will fare better and advance quicker with a few lessons to begin with.
I'm sure it's true mostly.
But why not let to OP try?
Surely a reply like "well it's tough for many people, but this or that YouTube or book has a pretty good guidance. Have a go, if your frustrated, get back to us or find a teacher" is good enough?

It's not like the Cafe hasn't had threads discussing this before, as a stand alone discussion.
 
Last edited:
I love it, the OP asked a very simple question: "Where do I start?" and ends up with "The Bible meets Kamasutra" as answer.

The easiest way to start really is to watch Nigel McGill

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FTMMcrkp5Jc&list=PLu48E1CZQ-_0fGnYB2WOFcTCvQD_TfPwt
and work your way through the beginner series.
Since it is human nature to require everything being explained to you in at least three different ways, I refer to @skeller047 's post earlier for more resources.

As a former private teacher, and a long time player (60+years now), I say your instincts are important and just because some random people on the internet tell you something doesn’t mean it’s true. But if the vast majority of people familiar in the field say the same thing, it’s worth looking at.

That said, I think there are a couple of resources that haven’t been mentioned that you should seriously look at.

Jay Metcalf (Better Sax on YouTube bettersax.com) runs a good online school.
Jamie Anderson (Get Your Sax Together on YouTube) ditto
Nigel McGill (Sax School Online on YouTube, saxschoolonline.com) ditto

These folks have excellent resources for beginners and I suspect you will get more out of them than the courses for beginners on Udemy and the like. Want to learn CAD? Udemy or Coursera or Skillshare are great. Want to learn music? Maybe look elsewhere.

Please do look at Taming The Saxophone, buying those books will a) get you pointed in the right direction and b) help fellow musicians, as profits go to charity.

One book not yet mentioned that should be on every saxophonists bookshelf is The Art of Saxophone Playing by Larry Teal. The sections on mouthpiece placement, embouchure, air support etc. are excellent.

I applaud your determination! Try it your way, be on the lookout for things you might be doing incorrectly, and most of all, enjoy the process. Music is like the universe, it’s capability to reveal more truth to us is infinite.

Once you feel secure enough for the next level, check out Scott Paddock, SirValorsax on YouTube, they are great resources but way above your current needs.
 
Maybe. But the broader context is - yet another - thread where someone who says they want to kick off by themselves get dog-piled.


I'm sure it's true mostly.
But why not let to OP try?
Surely a reply like "well it's tough for many people, but this or that YouTube or book has a pretty good guidance. Have a go, if your frustrated, get back to us or find a teacher" is good enough?

It's not like the Cafe hasn't had threads discussing this before, as a stand alone discussion.
Did you read my first response or two? Most of what you're talking about as piling in has actually been responding to other people.
 
I love it, the OP asked a very simple question: "Where do I start?" and ends up with "The Bible meets Kamasutra" as answer.

The easiest way to start really is to watch Nigel McGill

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FTMMcrkp5Jc&list=PLu48E1CZQ-_0fGnYB2WOFcTCvQD_TfPwt
and work your way through the beginner series.
Since it is human nature to require everything being explained to you in at least three different ways, I refer to @skeller047 's post earlier for more resources.



Once you feel secure enough for the next level, check out Scott Paddock, SirValorsax on YouTube, they are great resources but way above your current needs.
But what is the difference between any of the courses and teaching? They're all still teaching....

The difference with an in person teacher is that they can react and respond to your playing. Which is invaluable
 
Did you read my first response or two? Most of what you're talking about as piling in has actually been responding to other people.
I wasn't referring to your responses as piling on. Piling is all the "get a teacher" posts. It's a collective action.

Look. No one is saying an real, live teacher is not an individual value. Obviously it is. Human feedback is unique. You're videos demonstrate what great things can be achieved even with more advanced support. I'm sure the OP knows that; knew that before starting the thread... 6 pages. But no one is going to die if she stars without one.
 
Last edited:
Did you read my first response or two? Most of what you're talking about as piling in has actually been responding to other people.
Yes, I understand and that was my point, "responding to other people" instead of answering a simple question.

It's like a student asks something and I get into a discourse and when the student raises a hand I brush him/her off saying "hey I wasn't talking to you!"
 
Last edited:
But what is the difference between any of the courses and teaching? They're all still teaching....

The difference with an in person teacher is that they can react and respond to your playing. Which is invaluable
There is a huge difference, I can look at online material at my leisure and without pressure and fear of embarrassment, no cutting my day in half because I had to take that personal lesson. And, there is a risk of misunderstanding the one or other thing or getting hung up on a specific word, which is why I referenced @skeller047 's post for alternative ways of teaching the same thing.

Yes, there will be a point where a personal interaction with other sax players will prove beneficial but OP or Ann appears to be a smart person who can figure things out by herself. And for sure I had enough bad teachers in my life to understand why she rather goes her own way.
 
Good news, at least in Yandex search engine, the Café is the 6th hit using the string, "saxophone embouchure".

2024-11-25 Yandex saxophone embouchure.webp
 
I wasn't referring to your responses as piling on. Piling is all the "get a teacher" posts. It's a collective action.
It comes down to whom you ask - generally, if you ask a pro musician (someone who has encountered many pitfalls and knows how to circumnavigate them), they’ll give you the advice as such.

“I’m going to go down High Street because I’d like to visit the museum.”

“Don’t. It’s a dead end. Take Market street or you’ll be wasting your time”

For many, they may answer that they’d likely enjoy seeing High street anyway, and have plenty of time to kill. But ask a pro player a question and you’re most likely to get a précis of what/how/when etc
 
No, figure out when or if she is ready to find somebody to help her.
I think this is what I went through as a mostly self taught musician. In the end I think the fact I remained basically self taught was a good thing. So I would not feel comfortable saying that every beginner needs s teacher, there are those are fine or better off without. And that may be the case here.

But relying on online stuff may or may not be good because some of it is crap.
 
It comes down to whom you ask - generally, if you ask a pro musician (someone who has encountered many pitfalls and knows how to circumnavigate them), they’ll give you the advice as such.
Absolutely. But pros - and most talented amateur/semi-pros - have not, for the most part, encountered the problems of late starters. People who haven't played music, maybe, since they where a kid if ever... But has learned about themselves, how they learn etc.
A really good teacher understands that. But a lot of teachers are just surviving between proper work.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,428
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom