Saxophones Trevor James Custom

The trevor james I got has a sloppy octave key on the neck, it almost rattles in its screw where it attaches to the neck. This might have come from the previous owner maybe and may not be a built quality issue from the beginning? I think the octave key mechanism is not as smooth operating as it should be. It works but not super smooth. The metal is so soft on these, you can litterally put a dent in it grabbing the bell with a strong hand and push a dent with your thumb! This cannot be good for the longitivity and regulation?
I often find that crook keys are somewhat loose on the pivot screw. It's not terribly problematic due to the way in which the key works - but if it gets a bit rattly then a drop of stiff grease will keep it quiet.

If the mech isn't smooth it's always worth examining the forks on the thumb key. It's often the case that milling marks have been left on them, which act like little ridges. A quick dress with a smooth file works wonders.

shwwimg_replacing_pin_tube.webp


Soft bell metal? It might be annealed. This is often done as part of the manufacturing process to relieve stresses and make the metal easier to shape. It's also often touted as a means of improving the tone (hey ho). It won't have an effect on longevity and nor will it affect the regulation.
 
Hi all. Sorry to re-open an old thread. I'm contemplating upgrading my alto to a Trevor James Signature Custom. The Raw doesn't appeal to me cosmetically, but it's how it plays that really counts so could settle. My dream finish would be red phosphor bronze lacquer, but no one stocks these, so it would likely be a case of order one and wait. There are some regular gold lacquer instruments in stock for sale.

The RAW XS seems a little pointless to me as surely in time it would look the same as a regular RAW -or am I missing something? I'm hoping someone like @Stephen Howard might be able to advise on new current models

So my question is: are there any real differences or is it all cosmetic?

I found my new, lacquered SC tenor to sound almost identical to my prior RAW; perhaps a bit more focused but very similar- both great. That said, The difference between lacquered and not is much more than cosmetic in my opinion. My RAW was very prone to verdigris; a little bit o’ green is cosmetically tolerable, and somewhat treatable with distilled vinegar, but that green slorp drips down rods and is somewhat destructive to springs and felts. While the Pisoni pads were perfect after 7 years, because of the previous issue, I’d never own another unlacquered horn though it did look bada$$! The SC is a fantastic horn. I’m not as comfortable with the new ergonomics of the right hand keywork and thumb rest; three weeks in, it just feels wrong as compared to my 2017.
 
I dropped David Farley a line about this and he says there's been no fundamental change of the design.
The sling ring position was moved a few years ago, and the angle of the crook was lowered - but that's it.
What's the alignment of your sling ring like? Dead straight up the line of the body tube?
If you're unhappy about the angle of the crook, drop TJ a line - they're usually happy to help out.

My own thoughts are that maybe the new horn has a higher/lower action than your previous one? This can make quite a difference to the feel. Other than that the lacquered model is the same horn as the RAW version.
 
Brass, verdigris, it's why it's lacquered innit?

Polishing horse brasses, door plaques and brass ornaments were regular bob a job task, and polishing uniforms with a button stick and brasso is a chore. Staybright buttons were such a relief.

Apart from the engineering problems, I don't like the look of raw brass. It just looks dirty and neglected to my eye. It conjures up an image of Windsor Davies shouting "orrible". 🤗
 
My teacher and I both play Signature Custom Altos, he has the Raw and I have the lacquered version.They're both the latest version with composite regulation felts (no cork).

Occasionally we swap horns during practice and there's really almost nothing in it. The action is a little different but that's just the setup, mine is very new and his is a couple of years old.
 
I dropped David Farley a line about this and he says there's been no fundamental change of the design.
The sling ring position was moved a few years ago, and the angle of the crook was lowered - but that's it.
What's the alignment of your sling ring like? Dead straight up the line of the body tube?
If you're unhappy about the angle of the crook, drop TJ a line - they're usually happy to help out.

My own thoughts are that maybe the new horn has a higher/lower action than your previous one? This can make quite a difference to the feel. Other than that the lacquered model is the same horn as the RAW version.
Hi Steve! Good to hear from you! I had dropped you an email on this. That’s crazy; who am I to question the head boffin (quoting you!)? That said, there’s no way; the right hand feels very different
I dropped David Farley a line about this and he says there's been no fundamental change of the design.
The sling ring position was moved a few years ago, and the angle of the crook was lowered - but that's it.
What's the alignment of your sling ring like? Dead straight up the line of the body tube?
If you're unhappy about the angle of the crook, drop TJ a line - they're usually happy to help out.

My own thoughts are that maybe the new horn has a higher/lower action than your previous one? This can make quite a difference to the feel. Other than that the lacquered model is the same horn as the RAW version.
Hi Steve, so good to see you! I dropped you an email, but you needn’t respond there. I’m no one to question the ‘head boffin,’ quoting you there! That said, there’s no way Dave is correct that between 2017 and 2023 that there’s no change. The ring may be slightly to the left, but I’m sure that the thumb rest has been moved and the side keys tucked way into the body. That right hand just feels very different and I’m still having a hard time adjusting, but it’s getting better! Thanks!
 
Hi Steve, so good to see you! I dropped you an email, but you needn’t respond there. I’m no one to question the ‘head boffin,’ quoting you there! That said, there’s no way Dave is correct that between 2017 and 2023 that there’s no change. The ring may be slightly to the left, but I’m sure that the thumb rest has been moved and the side keys tucked way into the body. That right hand just feels very different and I’m still having a hard time adjusting, but it’s getting better! Thanks!
I thought it better to reply here in case anyone else has come across this problem.

I reckon if David says there's been no real change then there's been no real change - and he ought to know.
But like I said, they're very helpful if you have any queries and I'm sure they'll at least be happy to sort out the crook angle issue. Drop them a line and see.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,503
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom