I feel I've evolved from the transposing stage to the de-transposing one - someone suggested me to go back to transposing
and then others attack me for pushing my views to others? :shocked:
It's not me pushing you but yourselves - you know you've put up with something you don't really understand for ages except for thinking transposition is aiding you (sounds like pushing a square into a circle)...
The complaints and the justifications I hear are all the same - transposition works for us leave us alone - ok...I accept that - but then, in a way it's a rather selfish thought - certainly you aren't going to convince a 14 years old boy who's just starting to play the sax that transposition is good because it worked for you.
In other words the justifications expected were a bit more global or universally accepted not related to single individual preferences.
When I pointed out that accepting a concept like "2+2=4 but then call that 4 with the label of 3" - that's is a kind of formula to describe the essence of transposition which is, dear I say: measurable - it's human nature to find linearity and simplicity - transposition goes the other way round.
While I wasn't expecting something so concise and clear - there was some hope for a more logic and objective justification than comments like: "I like it and it works for me".
It seems to me a vicious cycle started ages ago and keep repeating itself in a void - teachers should expect youngsters questioning the transposing system (seen many times in many music classes) yet the answers given are very unsatisfactory - many revolve to the "don't worry about it...just do it, you'll understand later" (yeah right).
The reading v ear issue wasn't needed - a complete red herring...
Just because I can't read in real time it doesn't mean I don't have a say or I don't understand the issue...although I can sympathize with some as it must be really awkward having to re-think their ways after using a certain system for so long.
and then others attack me for pushing my views to others? :shocked:It's not me pushing you but yourselves - you know you've put up with something you don't really understand for ages except for thinking transposition is aiding you (sounds like pushing a square into a circle)...
The complaints and the justifications I hear are all the same - transposition works for us leave us alone - ok...I accept that - but then, in a way it's a rather selfish thought - certainly you aren't going to convince a 14 years old boy who's just starting to play the sax that transposition is good because it worked for you.
In other words the justifications expected were a bit more global or universally accepted not related to single individual preferences.
When I pointed out that accepting a concept like "2+2=4 but then call that 4 with the label of 3" - that's is a kind of formula to describe the essence of transposition which is, dear I say: measurable - it's human nature to find linearity and simplicity - transposition goes the other way round.
While I wasn't expecting something so concise and clear - there was some hope for a more logic and objective justification than comments like: "I like it and it works for me".
It seems to me a vicious cycle started ages ago and keep repeating itself in a void - teachers should expect youngsters questioning the transposing system (seen many times in many music classes) yet the answers given are very unsatisfactory - many revolve to the "don't worry about it...just do it, you'll understand later" (yeah right).
The reading v ear issue wasn't needed - a complete red herring...
Just because I can't read in real time it doesn't mean I don't have a say or I don't understand the issue...although I can sympathize with some as it must be really awkward having to re-think their ways after using a certain system for so long.
