Theory & Impro transposition - please do justify it (once and for all)

Close the thread?

  • Close the thread

    Votes: 9 75.0%
  • Keep it open

    Votes: 3 25.0%

  • Total voters
    12
Status
Not open for further replies. This may be temporary.
I feel I've evolved from the transposing stage to the de-transposing one - someone suggested me to go back to transposing :w00t: and then others attack me for pushing my views to others? :shocked:

It's not me pushing you but yourselves - you know you've put up with something you don't really understand for ages except for thinking transposition is aiding you (sounds like pushing a square into a circle)...

The complaints and the justifications I hear are all the same - transposition works for us leave us alone - ok...I accept that - but then, in a way it's a rather selfish thought - certainly you aren't going to convince a 14 years old boy who's just starting to play the sax that transposition is good because it worked for you.
In other words the justifications expected were a bit more global or universally accepted not related to single individual preferences.

When I pointed out that accepting a concept like "2+2=4 but then call that 4 with the label of 3" - that's is a kind of formula to describe the essence of transposition which is, dear I say: measurable - it's human nature to find linearity and simplicity - transposition goes the other way round.
While I wasn't expecting something so concise and clear - there was some hope for a more logic and objective justification than comments like: "I like it and it works for me".

It seems to me a vicious cycle started ages ago and keep repeating itself in a void - teachers should expect youngsters questioning the transposing system (seen many times in many music classes) yet the answers given are very unsatisfactory - many revolve to the "don't worry about it...just do it, you'll understand later" (yeah right).

The reading v ear issue wasn't needed - a complete red herring...
Just because I can't read in real time it doesn't mean I don't have a say or I don't understand the issue...although I can sympathize with some as it must be really awkward having to re-think their ways after using a certain system for so long.
 
Sorry, but you're twisting my point slightly: string instruments were never transposing instruments as they were always fully chromatic, so the need did not exist. It's also less common for players of one instrument to play one of the others in the stirng world.

Woodwind and brass were not fully chromatic instruments (with the odd exception) until modern keying systems and valves were devised and standardised, which was an extended period over the first part of the C19th. Among other reasons, it was the slowness of the standardisation process which probably mitigated against a changeover.

I play a number of instruments (I'm a novice on the sax), I sing a lot with various choirs. I expect to (and do) have to read numerous clefs and keys and timesignatures. No notation system is flawless - one of the problems with the system we use is it's poor at handling triple time measures (arguably the notes values in triple time - the triplets, dotted crotchets etc - should have separate symbols - but they don't and are very unlikely to change). This becomes obvious if you have to work through certain types of Medieval/Renaissance music with complex metrical relationships with tripla rhythms (they had specific time signatures to cope with this - now not used).

If you want to perform this music - amateur or professional - you have to work with the notation system we have to play this music. If you want to improve, you 'get on with it'. A viol tutor I know (who can play just about any plucked instrument on the planet - he's also a well-known lutenist) his method of getting people's brains around notation is to toss music at them in unusual clefs such as the soprano clef (G1) or baritone clef (F2) and saying 'play that'. Having been on the receiving end of that process, it works. My singing teacher is similar - he just used to toss music at me and say 'sing that'. In the early days I wasn't very good, nowadays I can make a reasonable stab at anything not too outrageous.


I can't see the justification for your 'method' at all, if it works for you, fine, but I think focusing on sight-reading skills is probably rather simpler .

I appreciate your invitation for improving my reading skills but to be honest with you - as someone has already pointed out - I can't be bothered....I don't have any inferiority complex about it and reading music is right at the bottom of my priorities because of the types of music I'm interested and because I don't have the time and resources needed to achieve a satisfactory level (if ever).
In a similar way - I'm not pushing no one here to use electronic gear and audio/midi software to analyze music - and in my opinion these techno gadgets are invaluable.

The essence (which is relevant to this discussion) about the strings instruments example is that they are very similar and they are all in C - yet players are often expected to play more than one of them - so I don't understand why some sax players would get confused if they opted for de-transposing...(so where exactly is that I'm twisting your point?).

My method wasn't the one under scrutiny or in need to be justified - only my vanity failed me ;}
 
I think this is what it's about. Live and let live, don't try to change the world or try to prove your preferred way is better than another.

I prefer to have transposing saxophones, but I fully appreciate anyone's right to learn them as non transposing. There can be advantages and there can be disadvantages, as long as people know the advantages and disadvantages of either then I wouldn't try to persuade someone to do it the same as me if they don't want to.

The point here wasn't about trying to convince anyone...although I gave a few hints here and there and while I gave some hints about my method I did try to keep it under wraps for a while (but I failed).
Honestly, I thought there might be something a bit more substantial about the origins of transposition - in all these years of music I've deciphered many puzzles: why are there 7 notes in a scale? Why 12 keys?, why chords are structured in a certain way? why transposition (and so on...). the only one which eludes me is transposition...6 years ago, before I restarted playing the sax I attended a OU course (involving classic and baroque music studies) I did for an instant managed to nail it down...but is such a complex matter involving different factors and outcomes that is very tricky to keep in mind - I guess I'll have to go up to the loft and get those OU texts to find that elusive answer once more...
Underneath, there is also a very ambitious idea...yet, I'd better to get all the data right before the final jump ;}

don't worry folks...transposition in going to stay for a very very long time....
 
excuse me...what are the alternatives? As far as I know there isn't any (except thinking in Do like I do and a few others) - but please do let me know...I'm all EARS.
There is in my opinion too much inertia and lethargy for thinking about alternatives...

The alternatives are basically what you're proposing - to pitch all instruments in C, give them a sufficiently extended range that we don't need different fingerings for the same written notes.

Trouble is we have learned to love the different voices of the differently pitched instruments in the same family. And most of us don't want to learn different fingerings.

Incidentally, I'd argue against your assertion that violin/viola/cello/double bass require different fingerings. Double bass I clearly different, but the other three are the same - except for different positions on the strings due to the different scale.
 
Incidentally, I'd argue against your assertion that violin/viola/cello/double bass require different fingerings. Double bass I clearly different,

It is also different in that (like guitar and bass guitar) it is a transposing instrument. It is transposed by one octave.

And while on the subject of lower instruments, alto players who then take up baritone are very grateful that they play transposed parts in treble clef, if the baritone was not a transposing instrument, they would then need to learn bass clef in order to read baritone parts.

Transposing for saxophones and brass is of definite advantage to most players, and does not exist to confound or confuse them.
 
Might have read something like that in "Mein Kampf".

Apologies for being serious.

you are being real silly now...
Then I suggest to look really into how Nazism managed to develop...was because of too many people not asking too many questions perhaps? A bit like transposition!!
 
you are being real silly now...
Then I suggest to look really into how Nazism managed to develop...was because of too many people not asking too many questions perhaps? A bit like transposition!!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin's_law

Be warned everyone, when this happens it makes me think it's time to close a thread. It's an interesting topic, but seems to not always bring out the best in people.
 
It is also different in that (like guitar and bass guitar) it is a transposing instrument. It is transposed by one octave.

And while on the subject of lower instruments, alto players who then take up baritone are very grateful that they play transposed parts in treble clef, if the baritone was not a transposing instrument, they would then need to learn bass clef in order to read baritone parts.

Transposing for saxophones and brass is of definite advantage to most players, and does not exist to confound or confuse them.

Still repeating the same stuff Pete...until you can't prove the opposite we are stuck.

I've read an article once - apparently reading music doesn't help the ear - the eye (rather than the finger) takes some "bias" away from the ear...(that was the essence of that article - if I've got the time I'll google it and link it here...).
Now, I suspect the real problem isn't the reading music itself but reading in transposing terms - the brain and the subconscious are always there registering everything we do - the ear register a note as DO (real pitch) but you consciously call that DO a LA - there is a discrepancy which the subconscious can't accept - there is no matching code = messing about.
This is why reading transposing music isn't good for the ear (not reading music itself). Reading in DO (de-transposing) perhaps would solve that issue....
 
For me it's not an issue about reading different clefs etc - the point is that I would have to learn and use different fingerings to play the same concert pitch note on an alto and a tenor. As it is, a written C in a transposed part uses the same fingering.

Having said that, I agree that there is probably an ear issue as many players seem to prefer to stick to just Bb (eg sop & tenor) or just Eb (eg alto & bari) and some say they have developed a sort of perfect pitch for the transposed sound.

Pete
 
For me it's not an issue about reading different clefs etc - the point is that I would have to learn and use different fingerings to play the same concert pitch note on an alto and a tenor. As it is, a written C in a transposed part uses the same fingering.
This is what you're doing already. It's the written/tranposed notes that have the same fingering. But I guess that's what you meant to say.

Having said that, I agree that there is probably an ear issue as many players seem to prefer to stick to just Bb (eg sop & tenor) or just Eb (eg alto & bari) and some say they have developed a sort of perfect pitch for the transposed sound.

I only played a sop once. Apart from my terrible tone, it was easier because it's in Bb, like my favourite - the tenor. But I've been playing a lot more alto recently, and I'm learning to accept the difference. A bit like left or right foot gear changes on motor bikes(not to mention the different gear patterns)... Or driving a car with the steering wheel on the other side to what you're used to and having to use the other hand to change gear.
 
Yes Kev, I have been playing alto much more recently too - I find it comes as a bit of a shock when I first pick it up after playing tenor/soprano but soon adapt - there is a difference between using your ears to hear relative pitch and hearing absolute pitch so don't find it a drawback.
Pete
 
I may be trying not to respond to this guff but at least I expect to understand the words.



What exactly does that mean?

Oh, and I read an article once, too.

You say transposition works for you...but you don't know if starting thinking in C from day one for all of your instruments would have been even better...especially for your ear.
At least I have more to say as I've experienced both (about 50/50 by now)....for me there is no doubt which works better - but then it might be subjective as I've always been playing mostly by ear.
If reading music has some negative effects on earing abilities I would say that the real issue is reading transposed score not reading music itself - in fact I'm helping the cause for reading music - the proper way: all in C = more consistency = more positive reinforcement - Skinner and the behaviourists would have a say on this issue.
 
For me it's not an issue about reading different clefs etc - the point is that I would have to learn and use different fingerings to play the same concert pitch note on an alto and a tenor. As it is, a written C in a transposed part uses the same fingering.

Having said that, I agree that there is probably an ear issue as many players seem to prefer to stick to just Bb (eg sop & tenor) or just Eb (eg alto & bari) and some say they have developed a sort of perfect pitch for the transposed sound.

Pete

good point there...
Perfect pitch isn't really that relevant but many would pay ££££ to have it...
My hint is that the more consistent the exposure to pitch the more consistent our perception of it - in other words if a new born baby grew listening an out of tune piano for years then his/her perception would be messed up when listening properly tuned music - those who have perfect pitch were blessed by a more "tempered" and well tuned environment (or course genes might also be relevant too).
Learning music and especially reading it in an inconsistent way related to the pitch might be detrimental for the ear.
 
Playing in D when Concert pitch is C shouldn't be a problem because you have to be able to play in D anyway. In fact you should be able to play any note in any key (preferably in any Clef). On the other hand it would be a bloody nuicance if I read the note C and had to use different fingering from C-Melody, Bb and Eb saxes. (C/Bb/Eb/F... trumpet/Horn/Barythone etc.)

You have to learn how to play different keys anyway, so why add to the burden of making people having to learn different fingering for read note?

Learning to play music is just like learning a different language. If you learn it by ear only, you won't have to bother with letters like 'æ', 'ø', and 'å' (which may be considered transposing letters). Then, in fact, you'd be an illiterate in that language. No big deal for a second or third language. If, on the other hand, the written language is of interest (which it should be) then transposing suddenly start making sense. Take the letter 'æ'. It's the same as the letter 'a' in 'bad'. Why not use 'a' in Norwegian like any normal bloke would, you might argue. That's because a Norwegian 'a' is like the Latin note 'a' in 'LA'. This is transposing. It's no way around it unless you make an alphabet that contains all the letters imaginable. And that has been tried... and rejected.
 
Status
Not open for further replies. This may be temporary.

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,597
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom