Theory & Impro transposition - please do justify it (once and for all)

[zannad]

The problem is not the transposition, it's your obsession and refusal to see things from any other viewpoint.

Transposition is effective, works and won't go away, so you may as well accept it. Or move out of music completely.

"...accept it. Or move out of music completely."
Here we have also a music policeman trying to restrict and dictate what music should be...what make you think that music need transposition?
The opposite is true instead...in fact transposition is a music parasite - been there for ages for all the wrong reasons.

 

[zannad]

"...accept it. Or move out of music completely."
Here we have also a music policeman trying to restrict and dictate what music should be...what make you think that music need transposition?
The opposite is true instead...in fact transposition is a music parasite - been there for ages for all the wrong reasons.

oh, I've forgot,
Even the Imperial system is effective...and some prefer it to the Decimal system (go figure).

Right now the stench of mold is saturating my sensitive nostrils - please come up with some original arguments rather than the same tantrums (will ya?).

 

[Targa]

oh, I've forgot,
Even the Imperial system is effective...and some prefer it to the Decimal system (go figure).

Right now the stench of mold is saturating my sensitive nostrils - please come up with some original arguments rather than the same tantrums (will ya?).

Mold is a nice Welsh town, I see no reason for you to be so offensive to the inhabitants.

 

[old git]

"very personal problems?" :shocked:

It's seems history repeating itself...Galileo also was being accused of having some personal problems and even insane by the inquisition - that was when they had no other rational arguments to propose (just like yourself).

There was a rational argument proposing that our system was not geocentric. A guy called Nicolaus Copernicus published "De revolutionibus orbium celestrum" in 1543 proposing heliocentric cosmology, over half a century prior to Gallileo Gallilei's in 1610.

But don't worry about it. I used to be paranoid before realising they really were out to get me. On the other hand, if this was a wind up, congratulations from everyone.:welldone

 

[Tenor Viol]

There was a rational argument proposing that our system was not geocentric. A guy called Nicolaus Copernicus published "De revolutionibus orbium celestrum" in 1543 proposing heliocentric cosmology, over half a century prior to Gallileo Gallilei's in 1610.

But don't worry about it. I used to be paranoid before realising they really were out to get me. On the other hand, if this was a wind up, congratulations from everyone.:welldone

And Galileo's experiences were more to do with politics and less about cosmology as he went out of his way to be really offensive to someone who was looking after his interests. Dr. Allan Chapman at Oxford does a really good talk on this subject - the Vatican opened the files on the subject a few years ago.

I think the best thing for this thread is to put it to bed.....

 

[Nick Wyver]

I think the best thing for this thread is to put it to bed.....

Yup. That might be for the best.

But for those who can't be bothered to wade through all this, here's a summary:

Transposition's rubbish.
No it isn't.
Yes, it is. Give me reasons why it isn't then.
Ok, here's reasons 1, 2, 3 etc.
No it's rubbish. Give me reasons.
Ok, here's reasons 1, 2, 3 etc.
No it's rubbish. Give me reasons.
Ok, here's reasons 1, 2, 3 etc.
No it's rubbish. Give me reasons.

repeat ad nauseam.

 

[Pete Thomas]

I'll leave it up to democracy. The thread now has a poll.

To decide whether to keep it open or not. Please vote now!

 

[zannad]

To decide whether to keep it open or not. Please vote now!

Put it down safely Pete...
There's a lot of negativity and jealousy going on and very little else - keep it there though (don't delete it).

 

[Sunray]

I already closed it for me ... 🙂))

This message is hidden because "Shhhh you know who" is on your ignore list.