I'm going to settle with mutual blind non-comprehension - I've read this thread end-to end and I still don't understand what you're saying that you do: I'm with those who think you're in effect playing by ear.
Reading music is not essential but provides much greater insight into the composer's intentions. The basics are not that difficult - complexity arrives with keys, harmony, counterpoint....
The reasons for the need for transpositon have been elucidated elsewhere: until someone republishes and reprints all of the music and reteaches everyone to play at pitch, with different fingerings for the same notes on different sizes of instrument (which to be fair is exactly what string players do for violins/violas/'cellos), it isn't going to happen. The time for it to have happened, if it was going to happen, it would have been when fully chromatic instruments became standard in the early C19th. It didn't happen then and it probably won't now.
Reading music is not essential but provides much greater insight into the composer's intentions. The basics are not that difficult - complexity arrives with keys, harmony, counterpoint....
The reasons for the need for transpositon have been elucidated elsewhere: until someone republishes and reprints all of the music and reteaches everyone to play at pitch, with different fingerings for the same notes on different sizes of instrument (which to be fair is exactly what string players do for violins/violas/'cellos), it isn't going to happen. The time for it to have happened, if it was going to happen, it would have been when fully chromatic instruments became standard in the early C19th. It didn't happen then and it probably won't now.


