Theory & Impro transposition - please do justify it (once and for all)

Close the thread?

  • Close the thread

    Votes: 9 75.0%
  • Keep it open

    Votes: 3 25.0%

  • Total voters
    12
Status
Not open for further replies. This may be temporary.
I'm going to settle with mutual blind non-comprehension - I've read this thread end-to end and I still don't understand what you're saying that you do: I'm with those who think you're in effect playing by ear.

Reading music is not essential but provides much greater insight into the composer's intentions. The basics are not that difficult - complexity arrives with keys, harmony, counterpoint....

The reasons for the need for transpositon have been elucidated elsewhere: until someone republishes and reprints all of the music and reteaches everyone to play at pitch, with different fingerings for the same notes on different sizes of instrument (which to be fair is exactly what string players do for violins/violas/'cellos), it isn't going to happen. The time for it to have happened, if it was going to happen, it would have been when fully chromatic instruments became standard in the early C19th. It didn't happen then and it probably won't now.
 
I'm going to settle with mutual blind non-comprehension - I've read this thread end-to end and I still don't understand what you're saying that you do: I'm with those who think you're in effect playing by ear.

Reading music is not essential but provides much greater insight into the composer's intentions. The basics are not that difficult - complexity arrives with keys, harmony, counterpoint....

The reasons for the need for transpositon have been elucidated elsewhere: until someone republishes and reprints all of the music and reteaches everyone to play at pitch, with different fingerings for the same notes on different sizes of instrument (which to be fair is exactly what string players do for violins/violas/'cellos), it isn't going to happen. The time for it to have happened, if it was going to happen, it would have been when fully chromatic instruments became standard in the early C19th. It didn't happen then and it probably won't now.

The reasons for transposition apparently are always elsewhere - never here?!

Of course reading is useful - even if I can't play in real time (unless is relatively simple) I can still decipher a score - and if I have to play from it I check it first and then I put it away and play...still I'm doing it in C.
A point worth to consider is that during my first years I couldn't read music until the starting of the 3rd - so I had only 1 year of reading experience in Eb.
I've stated that myself...I'm playing mostly by ear - no mystery there...I've pointed out that maybe others who are more dependent on reading would have to work harder to de-transpose:
1) de-transpose all their scores from Bb o Eb or F in C - there are useful programs which are quite capable although some manual tweaking is often necessary.
2) re-asses the physicality of their instruments - stop fixating too much on the fact that alto, tenor and clarinet have similar fingering - these are different instruments.
3) have a go...this is the most difficult part - it was weird for a couple of days - but that long gap really helped somehow - let's say I made the most of it?!
Thinking what it could be for someone playing continously for 20-30 odd years?! :w00t:
Professionals in particular don't want to mess about - being an amateur has so many advantages sometimes ;}
I guess this is something that might suit some beginners...but then it would requires a new batch of teachers.
Ok...transposition for another million years then...(not for me anyhow).
 
to Tenorviol...
Sorry I missed your point - you don't understand what I'm doing?...Didn't I mentioned about the solfege? Afterall it was the reason why I left transposition.
If I have to learn a difficult passage, I sing it loudly or in my head using solfege - that way helps memorizing it better.
There are methods using movable DO solfege which are pretty useful (apparently) - in my case, I'm using an absolute solfege - if I call a note, that same note is related to the actual pitch not to the relative position within a specific key. A movable DO would be the first degree in any scale - for example in the key of F the first degree is F but in solfege with movable DO it would be called a DO while in my solfege I would call it FA. You lose the relationship of the degrees within a key but that's no big deal in my opinion (my choice).
See how interesting and fun can be being an amateur? No pro would dare come up with such system (or maybe they would after very careful considerations). ;}
 
Unless you want different fingerings for the Eb and Bb Saxophones, then transposition has to stay. Transposition just makes life simpler.
 
Reading music will never be as fun as playing by ear...save paper and the planet.

So, in other words, you're just against written music in general and are trying to convince everyone to just play by ear.

I think I get your message now. ;}

If we're going to do that we can toss out keys and notes altogether. Why even bother thinking in C?

Let's just play by ear and forget about musical notation altogether!
 
I think I've got it now too.

It's all because you can't sight read very well. So you're not going to bother with it.

Yes, I'm sure it's great fun being an amateur. You can ignore vast swathes of music just because it's too hard to read.
 
So, in other words, you're just against written music in general and are trying to convince everyone to just play by ear.

I think I get your message now. ;}

If we're going to do that we can toss out keys and notes altogether. Why even bother thinking in C?

Let's just play by ear and forget about musical notation altogether!

That's subjective - that was my opinion...
 
I think I've got it now too.

It's all because you can't sight read very well. So you're not going to bother with it.

Yes, I'm sure it's great fun being an amateur. You can ignore vast swathes of music just because it's too hard to read.

those views of yours also anachronistic (just like transposing) - nowadays you can use recorded music via Midi or direct audio via mp3/wav files - load a song on a program like Melodyne and you can analyze not only the musical contents but also the audio properties - far more comprehensive of what you find in a score.
 
I'm going to settle with mutual blind non-comprehension - I've read this thread end-to end and I still don't understand what you're saying that you do: I'm with those who think you're in effect playing by ear.

Reading music is not essential but provides much greater insight into the composer's intentions. The basics are not that difficult - complexity arrives with keys, harmony, counterpoint....

The reasons for the need for transpositon have been elucidated elsewhere: until someone republishes and reprints all of the music and reteaches everyone to play at pitch, with different fingerings for the same notes on different sizes of instrument (which to be fair is exactly what string players do for violins/violas/'cellos), it isn't going to happen. The time for it to have happened, if it was going to happen, it would have been when fully chromatic instruments became standard in the early C19th. It didn't happen then and it probably won't now.

I've missed that point: "...with different fingerings for the same notes on different sizes of instrument (which to be fair is exactly what string players do for violins/violas/'cellos)"
This is the missing link between Alto, Tenor, soprano and Bass saxes then...so there you are, you go all the right ingredients now.
Thanks for the useful hint.
 
If I'm playing/jamming (not using music) on my Tenor with C instruments they announce we're gonna jam in C, the hardest bit of work I need to do is call on my armoury of scales/licks/arpegios in my D...at that point on Im thinking in D, when they call out chords changes I just transpose at that point, took a bit of practice but second nature now. That's the only transposition I need to do; to do what you're suggesting would only mean for me to call that D a C instead..........surely if in aint broke why fix it? :confused:
 
Reading music will never be as fun as playing by ear...save paper and the planet.

Well, permit me to disagree with you. That is an undisputably subjective opinion. And before you characterise me as another anachronistic and unadventurous player stuck in "lethargy and inertia", I am, like most of the other contributors involved in this entertaining bit of troll-baiting, perfectly capable of playing both from a score and by ear.

Try to overcome your fear and just make the effort - try transposing; although to be fair you will probably need to develop the ability to read music to grasp this. It is not rocket science. 4-year-olds can do it. After a few weeks you stop even thinking about it and just do it. The human brain is a remarkable and adaptable organ and the sub-conscious mental effort involved in transposing is probably less than it takes to scratch your ear. Certainly a lot less than it takes to keep this ridiculous thread going........
 
those views of yours also anachronistic (just like transposing) - nowadays you can use recorded music via Midi or direct audio via mp3/wav files - load a song on a program like Melodyne and you can analyze not only the musical contents but also the audio properties - far more comprehensive of what you find in a score.

Tell you what. You get a recording of the Glazunov saxophone concerto and I'll get the score and we'll see who can play it quicker.
 
Pete...your position is exactly opposite to mine as you started de-transposed and then opted (coerced?) to transposing (like anyone else). You shouldn't have given up ;}

I didn't give up, I do both transposed and concert pitch, and I opted (not coerced) as I wanted to be able to play with big bands and orchestras.

My big problem was that initially I had taught myself for a couple of years, it wasn't until I did an audition for music college that I found out the saxophone was a transposing instrument. There was a site reading exam and they thought my reading was OK, but odd that I played it in the wrong key. I hurriedly had to relearn the fingerings so i would be able to play in the big band and orchestra.

However it meant that I was very good at reading from concert pitch parts on alto and thinking in concert pitch as well as transposed pitch, which is useful if you are playing in bands without any saxophone music.

However I would not recommend that way round, I think it's best to learn the proper transposed fingering firsat, especially if you ever intend to double on other saxophones.

Although I could think alto and concert pitch quite well, I really had to struggle when I decided to take up tenor and flute as I kep half thinking in the concert pitch equivalent fingering of Eb, on Bb and concert instruments.

For example, I'd play G on tenor (which is concert F) but I'd be thinking concert Bb because the concert pitch of Bb for alto G was so ingrained in my brain.

For a few minutes I was also annoyed about transposing, but it didn't take me long to realise the absolutely overwhelming advantages when it comes to learning another woodwind.

but surely at least it shows that the more natural way is just to play de-transposed.

No, I discovered that it wasn't. I had been mistaken.
 
Well, permit me to disagree with you. That is an undisputably subjective opinion. And before you characterise me as another anachronistic and unadventurous player stuck in "lethargy and inertia", I am, like most of the other contributors involved in this entertaining bit of troll-baiting, perfectly capable of playing both from a score and by ear.

Try to overcome your fear and just make the effort - try transposing; although to be fair you will probably need to develop the ability to read music to grasp this. It is not rocket science. 4-year-olds can do it. After a few weeks you stop even thinking about it and just do it. The human brain is a remarkable and adaptable organ and the sub-conscious mental effort involved in transposing is probably less than it takes to scratch your ear. Certainly a lot less than it takes to keep this ridiculous thread going........

we'll have to blame you for keeping this silly thread going!!!

Surely you are telling me to go back to transposing?! - Are you going bonkers? Done and over as far I'm concerned it's not me who need to let go of fears but you!
In evolutionary terms I'm ahead of you big time why are you asking me to go back? Just because you can't keep the pace?

You are right though...it's better to have both good ear and good reading abilities - yet, you can always tell when some music is being read because it lacks spontaneity and zest - if I had to choose between ear and reading well I know mine.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sorry, but you're twisting my point slightly: string instruments were never transposing instruments as they were always fully chromatic, so the need did not exist. It's also less common for players of one instrument to play one of the others in the stirng world.

Woodwind and brass were not fully chromatic instruments (with the odd exception) until modern keying systems and valves were devised and standardised, which was an extended period over the first part of the C19th. Among other reasons, it was the slowness of the standardisation process which probably mitigated against a changeover.

I play a number of instruments (I'm a novice on the sax), I sing a lot with various choirs. I expect to (and do) have to read numerous clefs and keys and timesignatures. No notation system is flawless - one of the problems with the system we use is it's poor at handling triple time measures (arguably the notes values in triple time - the triplets, dotted crotchets etc - should have separate symbols - but they don't and are very unlikely to change). This becomes obvious if you have to work through certain types of Medieval/Renaissance music with complex metrical relationships with tripla rhythms (they had specific time signatures to cope with this - now not used).

If you want to perform this music - amateur or professional - you have to work with the notation system we have to play this music. If you want to improve, you 'get on with it'. A viol tutor I know (who can play just about any plucked instrument on the planet - he's also a well-known lutenist) his method of getting people's brains around notation is to toss music at them in unusual clefs such as the soprano clef (G1) or baritone clef (F2) and saying 'play that'. Having been on the receiving end of that process, it works. My singing teacher is similar - he just used to toss music at me and say 'sing that'. In the early days I wasn't very good, nowadays I can make a reasonable stab at anything not too outrageous.


I can't see the justification for your 'method' at all, if it works for you, fine, but I think focusing on sight-reading skills is probably rather simpler .
 
we'll have to blame you for keeping this silly thread going!!!

Surely you are telling me to go back to transposing?! - Are you going bonkers? Done and over as far I'm concerned it's not me who need to let go of fears but you!
In evolutionary terms I'm ahead of you big time why are you asking me to go back? Just because you can't keep the pace?

You are right though...it's better to have both good ear and good reading abilities - yet, you can always tell when some music is being read because it lacks spontaneity and zest - if I had to choose between ear and reading well I know mine.

So now we've moved from merely suggesting a different way of doing things to proclaiming evolutionary arrogance?

Having read many of the posts in this thread I tend to agree with those who have suggested that what we have here is a person who has a mental block against reading music and is attempting to find some sort of "justification" for avoiding it.

I personally don't do well reading music real-time either. No matter what it's written in. Even if I'm playing a non-transposing instrument in the key of C I still can't just play a musical score smoothly by just sight-reading it.

As Dooce said, even a 4 year old can do it. But what Dooce failed to add is that it's actually easier for a 4 year old to learn to read music than say a 40 year old adult. So if you missed the boat when you were a child then what should have been a snap to learn can indeed seem insurmountable. Especially if you build up mental blocks against it judging it to all be unnecessary.

The bottom line for me is that each person should just do whatever works for them. Why proclaim evolutionary superiority over other people just because they prefer to do things differently from you? What's to be gained from that other than creating an atmosphere of animosity?

Instead of demanding that everyone else "justify" transposing, why not just let other people have their cup of tea and drink the flavor of tea you prefer. Why condemn everyone who doesn't do things your way?

There have been many great musicians who never really got into reading music much. They just played by ear, emotion, and feel, and they did great. I'm sure they didn't have problems with transposition either. They probably didn't transpose all that much.

That's another thing too. Take a really famous Jazz or Blues musician as an example. They played their own style of music and became famous for the pieces that they have created and played. And that's pretty much all they ever play. They really never have any need to transpose anything because all they ever play is their own music.

Compare that with a professional musician who's trying to make a living playing in orchestras or bands. They never get to play "their own music". They may not even have an original music! They live a life that it totally dependent upon reading musical score.

So everyone is not the same. What works for you, may not work for a professional musician who is looking for work. At an interview they might just be handed a piece of sheet music and asked to play it. From what I can tell, if that were to happen to you at an interview you'd be walking back to the unemployment office mumbling that everyone is evolutionarily inferior to you. But you'd be doing that whilst standing in the unemployment line. So where have you truly evolved to?
 
Instead of demanding that everyone else "justify" transposing, why not just let other people have their cup of tea and drink the flavor of tea you prefer. Why condemn everyone who doesn't do things your way?

I think this is what it's about. Live and let live, don't try to change the world or try to prove your preferred way is better than another.

I prefer to have transposing saxophones, but I fully appreciate anyone's right to learn them as non transposing. There can be advantages and there can be disadvantages, as long as people know the advantages and disadvantages of either then I wouldn't try to persuade someone to do it the same as me if they don't want to.
 
Not sure if this thread needs more fuel to the furnace, but here it goes...

I find playing music by ear just like speaking a foreign language. You'll get quite a long way just by speaking it. But if you don't bother to learn the written language, the syntaxes and proper grammar of the language, you miss out on a lot. Reading music (notes/scores) is just the same. If you don't bother to learn how to read music, you miss out on a lot. Even why it's a whole lot easier to have transposing instrument transposing. And don't come running claiming: 'I know how to read music. I know all the scales and note durations'. That's not reading sonny, that's just knowing the alphabet.
 
Status
Not open for further replies. This may be temporary.

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,593
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom