Playing the saxophone track tablature (fingering) from musicXML format

In the time it took to read this thread I could have learned to read. It's not very hard.
Letters A to G and the ascending spaces spell face. And we're away.
It takes longer to boot up the pooter.
Solution looking for a problem that doesn't exist. imo. But maybe I'm a luddite.
I feel that the point of music is playing with other people. If we're all on the same page it simplifies things. If you have a different book in a different language, you better have good ears and be very quick on the uptake.
 
The other thing is that standard notation communicates things that tab can't. If I see a sixteenth note ascending run and I'm in the key of F#, and there are no accidentals written, I know it's a F# major scale and I just play it. If I try to decipher a bunch of tab to figure out that I need to play an F# major scale, the music will run off and leave me by the time I figure it out.

For 99% of people, without learning disabilites, and vision correctable to the point of being able to read, just learning how to read standard notation and learning fingerings from a fingering chart, will be the very fastest and most reliable method to learning the fingerings that go with notes; plus it allows you to play any music written since about 1650 without any translation.

We're seeing another case of "if the only tool you have is a hammer, every problem looks like a nail" except in this case it's more like "if the only tool you have is the space shuttle, every problem looks like it needs to be solved in orbit".
 
My perspective is that since dusting off my sax a few years ago and getting involved in a band, I am learning not only the sax but also music in general and the theory behind it. I have a very long way to go.
Your system is very high tech for which I compliment you and reminds me of a paint by number kit. It could be a good beginning tool along with a fingering chart. Still, there are alternate fingerings to consider for many notes that work better when playing some tunes. There are also different scales (that I am still working on) and one would play a swing melody differently than jazz or classical. Being in a band has taught me the importance of playing my part of a particular piece and coordinating that with the other members. If everyone played the melody at the same time, the music would not be as enjoyable to the group or the audience.
Our director speaks of learning music being much the same as learning a different language. I guess it depends on whether a person only wants to know enough to get by during a short trip or if he is planning on living in his new country. I'd like to be here for a long time and become fluent some day.
Again, I do compliment you on your achievement. It may be helpful to many just starting out.
 
In my opinion, if anyone wants to learn to play the saxophone, then there is a certain amount of work that has to be done and which cannot be avoided. For example, you have to learn to play the scale of G. Whether you do this while reading notes is optional, but learning that LH123 is G and learning how to go from there to A, B, C ... without visual assistance is essential.

The beginner also wants to learn to play simple tunes. This is traditionally by ear (listen to the tune then try to play the right notes) or by note reading. Each has its advantages and disadvantages. Reading the notes can seem rather overwhelming at the start.

The human computational problem with learning from notes is that initially two computational steps are required to turn the picture of the note into the fingering:
1. This symbol represents s a G
2. To play G, I hold down LH 1,2,3
The first step can be avoided by writing down the note names.

This tool teaches the beginner to play tunes using fingering charts combined with note lengths written in conventional notation. But personally I think the amount of visual processing required to turn a fingering chart into a fingering is far greater than that which is required to process traditional music notation. So the tool replaces conventional music notation with one which is less frightening, but more difficult. Fingering charts may be useful for learning the first three tunes slowly (Twinkle twinkle little star, and friends), but after that I think they will be counterproductive. I defy anyone to play " In The Hall Of The Mountain King" (one of the given examples) from a fingering chart.

I noticed some bugs:
The note names (e.g. E5) are not the normal saxophone names (E1).
The pitches played are wrong (they correspond to a C-instrument, not a Bb or Eb instrument)
G# fingering is wrong. Ab fingering is correct.
Bb fingering uses the bis fingering. I suggest using the side Bb fingering as default
The symbols given for pauses are mostly wrong

The optional "French notation" is confusing for anyone who knows English Sol-Fa, because the usage is different. For example, "Fly me to the moon" starts on a D, which is French "Re" but English "Do". I think that anyone who knows enough to understand Sol-fa notation is not going to need this tool. But the French notation is switched off by default.
 
I'm not attacking it!
Fact is, people learn in different ways and want to achieve different things and have different challenges... Even more so with those of us coming to music playing a little late in life. Some want to learn all angles (me, I even spend time reading ethnomusicology!), some want to improvise, others want to play a tunes. We're grownups and we each have to find our own rout. It's all good!

PS
Even mucking about with music in software is, IMHO, legit. Some time ago i ripped the speaker out if a dead tablet, hooked it up to a raspberry pi and programmed it to play the blues. Then blew up to speaker. It's all fun.
I was not offensed at all @mizmar, nor by other mates in this forum. By the way, thanks a lot for all your feedbacks, I loved them all. It is constructive and help me understand point of views of others, learn, find some hidden angles I've not seen yet and move forward on the way to learning sax 🙂
 
In my opinion, if anyone wants to learn to play the saxophone, then there is a certain amount of work that has to be done and which cannot be avoided. For example, you have to learn to play the scale of G. Whether you do this while reading notes is optional, but learning that LH123 is G and learning how to go from there to A, B, C ... without visual assistance is essential.

The beginner also wants to learn to play simple tunes. This is traditionally by ear (listen to the tune then try to play the right notes) or by note reading. Each has its advantages and disadvantages. Reading the notes can seem rather overwhelming at the start.

The human computational problem with learning from notes is that initially two computational steps are required to turn the picture of the note into the fingering:
1. This symbol represents s a G
2. To play G, I hold down LH 1,2,3
The first step can be avoided by writing down the note names.

This tool teaches the beginner to play tunes using fingering charts combined with note lengths written in conventional notation. But personally I think the amount of visual processing required to turn a fingering chart into a fingering is far greater than that which is required to process traditional music notation. So the tool replaces conventional music notation with one which is less frightening, but more difficult. Fingering charts may be useful for learning the first three tunes slowly (Twinkle twinkle little star, and friends), but after that I think they will be counterproductive. I defy anyone to play " In The Hall Of The Mountain King" (one of the given examples) from a fingering chart.

I noticed some bugs:
The note names (e.g. E5) are not the normal saxophone names (E1).
The pitches played are wrong (they correspond to a C-instrument, not a Bb or Eb instrument)
G# fingering is wrong. Ab fingering is correct.
Bb fingering uses the bis fingering. I suggest using the side Bb fingering as default
The symbols given for pauses are mostly wrong

The optional "French notation" is confusing for anyone who knows English Sol-Fa, because the usage is different. For example, "Fly me to the moon" starts on a D, which is French "Re" but English "Do". I think that anyone who knows enough to understand Sol-fa notation is not going to need this tool. But the French notation is switched off by default.
Thanks for all these details @nigeld
Regarding the E5, E1 and so on, I'm simply reading the data in the musicXml file. You are totally right, I'm not transposing nothing at all between Tenor sax or Alto sax. By the way I do not understand the difference and the nuances, but I'll look into this forum, I'm sure it is explained somewhere 🙂.

- G#, I will look at that. You was talking about G4# or G5# ?
G4#.webp
G4#

G5#.webp
G5#


- Bb "side" as default. Oki, I'll look at it too. I also need to find somewhere in the forum how to move my hands and finger to play these damnly hard palm keys. I'm stucked on that part and I am not able to play high notes ("one step beyond "killed me on that parts and I spent like 10 days to find a way to growl a bit 🙂. )
 
Soprano and tenor sax are transposing instruments in Bb. This means that when the player fingers a C the instrument sounds a Bb. In other words it plays a tone down from what is written. (In the case of the tenor it is an octave and a tone down.)

Alto’s and baritones are in Eb. This means that when the player fingers a C then instrument sounds an Eb. In other words it plays 3 semitones higher than written. (Actually an alto plays down an octave, so it is 9 semitones lower than written. The bari is an octave lower than that.)

If a player wants to play along with your app then you will need to do the appropriate transposition.
 
So jazz theory has it's place in giving untalented people a means of aping improvisation and instead emphasizing becoming "fast fingered"... with mostly with nothing to say musically.

As someone who has spent a lot of time over the last few years learning some jazz theory and it's application, I have benefitted greatly from the structure it has give to my practice and to my exploration of a musical form thet I have come to love. Does that make me untalented? I really don't care. I do know that it's made me a better musician and improvisor than I would have been without it.

It may sound like I'm panning jazz theory,

Well, yes, it does rather.

but it's most useful for untalented players and gives them goals to achieve in developing very fast technique.

My technique is pretty slow (I must be extra-untalented, I suppose) but I'm a lot better than I used to be at finding consonant notes or tensions when I want them.
 
Last edited:
As someone who has spent a lot of time over the last few years learning some jazz theory and it's application, I have benefitted greatly from the structure it has give to my practice and to my exploration of a musical form thet I have come to love. Does that make me untalented? I really don't care. I do know that it's made me a better musician and improvisor than I would have been without it.



Well, yes, it does rather.



My technique is pretty slow (I must be extra-untalented, I suppose) but I'm a lot better than I used to be at finding consonant notes or tensions when I want them.
There is no doubt that the academic path works very well for some people and may be the best way for them to advance themselves as a player. What's most important is that you and others enjoy what you are doing. If you love that style of music and the academic path assists, then that can only be a good thing. I also apologize if it seemed a "rough" assessment and hurt anyone's feelings

The entirety of my (seemingly) thoughtless tirade is to highlight the fact that sax players have been taught this academic approach regardless of their ability or the fact that there is little/no public desire to hear 1950s/60s jazz. This has potentially hampered players who may have otherwise enjoyed a creative path and other musical styles that have better prospects for an aspiring professional.

I simply hope that those interested in music are self aware and have the opportunity to make appropriate choices. This has not been the case as players have been continually directed towards an academic path. The advice that (supposedly) Bird and others have given to learn it all then forget it may have worked for them, but the formulation of "jazz theory" didn't exist in their time. It's come about by retro-analysis of what those players did with the intention of teaching students to play in the same way one would teach principles of engineering. Fundamentals (General music theory) is one thing, dictating a style of improvisation that is tied to a specific time and style that is long past is quite another. Consider this: Those players and the style you love may not have come about if those players were taught that the only acceptable way to play was to imitate the style and technique of players from 1910. Music and the arts move on.

We are what we play. if you spend ten years studying and playing based on an academic cut and paste type of jazz improvisation, then you may not have engaged your ability to truly compose as an improviser (if you have that ability to begin with). The attitude that one must learn the mid 20th century "jazz vocabulary" is a falsehood compounded by encouraging students to ape a jazz hero from that era instead of developing their own voice and being a part of today's music. Once again if all you want is to play in an old jazz style that's OK. It's however IMHO not OK to foist that on others. It's well and truly time for that to stop.
 
The biggest problem with this method is that your "music reading" will never get any faster. As @turf3 said, an experienced player can read ahead and see scale/arpeggio patterns. The fact remains that traditional notation is incredible in how much information it can hold, and how quickly the player can read it - easily in very fast "real time".

Other forms of 'notation' can be more useful in certain situations, like the Nashville Number System. It can be quite an extensive set of rules but in a situation when a singer knows a song that the band doesn't, and providing it has pretty simple harmonic movement/chord make-up then showing the chord number via hands at the time of changing chord works very well.

Back to this fingering system of note-learning - I think players are better off knowing no theory at all and letting their ear guide them, because any question you might ask of a reading player is likely to confuse them.
 
I think players are better off knowing no theory at all and letting their ear guide them,
You can learn theory that way. It'll be your theory, but it may make just as much sense as the conventional theory. Before there was YouTube, Abersold and CDs, there were guys like Bird listening to classical music and thinking, "that's it! I wanna play that!" and finding those notes on the alto. It's not the path, but it's a path.
 
You can learn theory that way. It'll be your theory, but it may make just as much sense as the conventional theory. Before there was YouTube, Abersold and CDs, there were guys like Bird listening to classical music and thinking, "that's it! I wanna play that!" and finding those notes on the alto. It's not the path, but it's a path.
Sure, that was my point, in that there is no limit on how far 'ear learning' can go and it has been tried and tested by many for years. The main thing is that progression is there, whereas a fingering chart might make you think that you've seen the same sequence of fingerings before but you won't know why, unless you allow your ear to start guiding you. If it's a melody that you don't know though, this can't happen. Most popular melodies are predictable, and a fair amount of guesswork can take place with regard to likely next note choice, but it's easy to come unstuck. My experience with students that did things like write the note names over the music merely shut the other tools down. The best way would be to write less of the note names in over time, but many don't.
 
This tool teaches the beginner to play tunes using fingering charts combined with note lengths written in conventional notation. But personally I think the amount of visual processing required to turn a fingering chart into a fingering is far greater than that which is required to process traditional music notation.
I agree, but then it's not that easy to look at this objectively once you alread have learnt to read music conventionally
So the tool replaces conventional music notation with one which is less frightening, but more difficult.
Exactly. Some people do seem to have a fear of learning to read music so on the face of it there may be a market, although Luc is not looking on this as commercial.

I originally thought maybe this is kind of like "training wheels" - it may get someone off to a start with playing (if they have a fear of music notation) but then maybe the training wheels analogy fails, unless it results in them (sooner or later) losing the wheels.

But I have to say that I agree with those pointing out the limitations of this kind of system. It would be interesting to hear from someone who tries this out, then goes on afterwards to learn to read musc conventionally.
My experience with students that did things like write the note names over the music merely shut the other tools down. The best way would be to write less of the note names in over time, but many don't.
And you mihght argue that many people who do this do have a stumbling block or fear of music reading and go on to play absolutely well without reading (helps to have a good ear) but then will regret it if they ever find themselves in a situation where reading music is necessary.

In the time it took to read this thread I could have learned to read. It's not very hard.

I don't understand your issues with reading?

I think it is a sort of phobia with some people. We often don't understand other peoples' phobias but they exist.
 
Last edited:
but then will regret it if they ever find themselves in a situation where reading music is necessary.
Yes, but those of us who did learn to read music might always say this. It only becomes true though if there is a ‘crossing of the line’. Ear-only musicians can also say that read-only musicians are compromised. Again, that would only be true if the readers crossed the line into a situation which required a bit of improvisation maybe - the most obvious might be a Show that had the odd improvised solo.

Many players like one genre and don’t move across the musical boundaries - and they might also consider that any work in another musical direction is wasted as it isn’t needed for their own musical world. I like being well-versed in Classical and Jazz clarinet, jazz and pop sax. A good mate of mine followed the same path as me - being a near-orchestral pro clarinet player but swerving at the last minute into the career that we’ve had. We talk often of what would have happened had we concentrated on less breadth, but that was always what made us tick and fuelled our intellect and passion. We couldn’t have changed that, it is what it is.
 
Yes, but those of us who did learn to read music might always say this. It only becomes true though if there is a ‘crossing of the line’. Ear-only musicians can also say that read-only musicians are compromised.
I have no argument with that, it can cut both ways. I agree there is usually value in both ear and reading as well as theory knowledge I believe (but depending on genre and context)
 
Last edited:
I think it is a sort of phobia with some people
I'm not sure phobia is, often, the thing. People have different abilities to process symbols in; maths, music, language; from full fat dyslexia through to those who can hear a symphony orchestra when looking at a score or see the big bang when looking at a tensor equation. And even that isn't correlated, I know people who can read several European languages, Arabic, Hebrew etc. but can't get beyond +-/*.

I'm a bit dyslexic and what's always fascinated me are those people who suffer deep emotional anxiety when they see a writing mistakes. Some people not only have little insight into the challenges of others but are fundamentally invested in their own abilities, beyond rational discussion. I wonder, sometimes, not what is wrong with people who struggle to read music/maths/a language; but what is wrong with people who get upset by that.
 
Sure, that was my point, in that there is no limit on how far 'ear learning' can go
And I agreed with you. It's even possible that if you lean too heavily on reading and theory, you'll sound too much like _____. I think your (self-educated) theory is more interesting than traditional theory. But there's no argument here. Just "To Each His Zone".
 
I'll thank @lucbonnn for starting this thread as I have enjoyed hearing the opinions of café-dwellers more experienced in saxophone, and indeed music, than myself.
To address the original post, as someone having worked in e-learning, I have the utmost respect for the time and energy I know has gone into this.
But consider:
comparison.png

The amount of visual information to process on the left far exceeds that on the right. The image on the right actually conveys more information, in that you can 'see' the relationship of the sounds.
This system, like putting coloured stickers on piano keys, or similar 'shortcuts' I think puts a layer between the user and the music, which needs to be moved on from as quickly as possible. The main problem: the user will never read the fingering diagrams quickly enough in real time.

Note I have used my own image above as the image on the site is this:

wrong.png

This is inaccurate and serves to make the musical notation seem more complicated. Actually the notation takes up a lot less space. In reality there would need to be another 50 fingering diagrams to represent the music shown.

I find the copy on that site rather presumes the laziness of the musician "You do not want to learn boring and complicated traditional music theory?" As someone in education I dislike when people frame the process of learning, or making some effort, sound onerous. If it is approached as enriching and satisfying the student can enjoy it.
I used to hate maths at school and think it was boring, when I needed to use it in programming I found it fun to work with. Many a student was discouraged by bad teaching methods.
The site talks of 's***ty music sheets', I've always found musical notation quite beautiful even when I didn't understand them.

For people who don't read at all, or don't intend to (perfectly valid, the Beatles-Hendrix method) the program would be of less use than just learning by ear. For people who have dyslexia/ phobias about reading music, they may as well just learn by ear.
So I struggle to see a good user-case beyond being a temporary salve/delay.

Most people could learn the note on the stave at the same time as learning where the fingers go with minimal effort.

Some people will actually have a condition preventing them from getting to grips with notation, but I believe the majority of non-readers just overthink how complicated it is. A factor in adult-learning, is thinking you have to master it all. This is well-documented in language acquisition, i.e. children learning to speak are totally at ease with not understanding a lot of what is going on, until they do. Adults have a much harder time with this, they feel they have to understand everything, rather than gradually building on what they know.
I am not a good reader, I know basic notes, major scales, but don't yet understand the marks for articulations, timings etc. but I just learn stuff as I come across it. It has made a lot more music accessible to me. Learning something new is enjoyable if you don't approach it as a chore.

As far as the wider discussion goes, as long as you are making music and enjoying yourself, I think it's all good, from ear-only to advanced jazz theory. It depends on what your goals and available time is. I sometimes see colleges advertising jazz theory and think what they will mainly produce is jazz theory teachers. That's okay too.

I was listening to a radio interview with Tony Kofi who self-taught with just a saxophone and his mum's jazz records. I imagine a lot of people start similarly. He ended up going to study 'properly' in Berklee and then went on to teach at the Julian Joseph Jazz Academy where he says "there is absolutely no sheet-music in sight".

You can hear the interview here (access may depend on your region): Life Changing - The near-death experience that made me a musician - BBC Sounds

Different strokes for different folks.
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,717
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom