Saxophones the obscure, the overlooked

illinois j. - there is an example of rolled versus straight toneholes with the SML gold medal 1 / 2. it seems to me that the 2, with straight toneholes is a little freer, less earthy, the mk 1 with rolled toneholes richer but less breathy..... objective assessments would be hard to produce, i suspect.

wakyct - as for the couesnon, they are very inexpensive in france and can be excellent horns... i really like the tenors. i have no idea what they might cost in the USA, but i would bet you could get one in europe and import it and pay all appropriate taxes for far less than the price you quote.
 
Last edited:
[rolled tone holes] When I bought my used horn the seller also pointed this out as a plus, I think they were/are a mark of handcrafted "quality". The kind of thing that saxophone players (not necessarily makers/repairers?) get in their head as a distinguishing feature. ...
Well, that's pretty silly considering the additional level of machinery and tooling required to roll the edges of toneholes.

Handcrafted instruments (of which there have been exactly ZERO in saxophones since the days of A.Sax pere - all saxophones are mass production items with considerable investment in tooling and machinery) use soldered tone holes - see flutes.

I really think people ought to visit some factories - whether of saxophones or other goods - to understand just how things are ACTUALLY made in the real world. Hint: there are not a bunch of bearded craftsmen with hand tools and leather aprons and a foaming mug of beer on the workbench, lovingly making each individual saxophone one at a time. Nope, there's great racks of necks and bodies and keys and people doing repetitive activities over and over again. This is called "mass production", it's the foundation of the Industrial Revolution - subdividing tasks and specializing.
 
That's a bit unfair to the men and women who work on these instruments. Handcrafted doesn't mean that one "bearded" person makes one saxophone. That would be just silly. For any craft of complex objects, there's always some measure of specialization per craftsman, and a division of tasks.

Saxophones are pretty complicated contraptions, and you can't have machines just making parts on their own and humans just "assembling" them in the end like an IKEA table.

Of course the craftsmen use machines, but these are high precision jobs and each machine is carefully guided by the hand of man. And even in the times of Adolphe Sax, tools and machinery were needed to bend metal. Yet, he and his workers were craftsmen.

I watched visits of saxophone factories, Selmer and Yanagisawa, on youtube. For example the machine bending the brass to make a bell cannot do it on its own. A craftsman has to carefully guide the metal, by hand. Then hammer it, by hand. These skilled people are craftsmen, and the result is definitely handcrafted. You have engravers, you have people who fit and adjust the keys. All these people are not interchangeable.

Perhaps the process is different in cheap modern productions distributed on Amazon. But by looking at all the moving parts of well-made instruments, it is obvious that the intervention of skilled workers is necessary. All the more so in decades past, in the 1920s, 1930s, 1940s. These vintage instruments were obviously made by skilled workers. The term handcrafted seems deserved.
 
Last edited:
Hand of man 5.jpg


Hand of man 4.jpg


Hand of man 11.jpg


Hand of man 14.jpg

©Selmer
 
Last edited:
but these are high precision jobs and each machine is carefully guided by the hand of man.
Or women

But, even so, they aren't so much "high precision" as fiddly. Machines can be much higher precision than a person, but the more fiddly the task the more expensive (and unreliable) the machine.. and the cheeper the manpower looks.
Watch a smartphone factory video... The highest tec factories... Still got thousands of "craftsmen" and women doing the fiddly stuff.
 
Yeah 😛 Not sure that an electronic product mass produced at hundreds of millions per year can compare to a mechanical instrument of which Yanagisawa or Selmer painstakingly make a few thousands a year. Also I'm pretty sure the average time of apprenticeship to take a position at the Selmer or Yanagisawa workshops is tad longer than the one needed to be hired in a phone factory line in China. I'll bet they pay better, too.
 
Yeah 😛 Not sure that an electronic product mass produced at hundreds of millions per year can compare to a mechanical instrument of which Yanagisawa or Selmer painstakingly make a few thousands a year. I'm pretty sure the average time of apprenticeship to take a position at the Selmer or Yanagisawa workshops is tad longer than the one needed to be hired by a phone factory in China.

FWIW, Borgani has about a dozen employees and makes around 300 instruments a year.
 
Indeed. Borgani is an even better example (plus in the pictures, one can see aprons and beards). That's an average of 2 saxes per month per employee at Borgani. Hardly a "mass-produced" output.

Also, the mass-produced phone will be obsolete in 5 years. Many a saxophone is past a century old and still going strong. There's a reason for that: the techniques used to make them cannot easily be replaced.
 
Yeah 😛 Not sure that an electronic product mass produced at hundreds of millions per year can compare to a mechanical instrument of which Yanagisawa or Selmer painstakingly make a few thousands a year. Also I'm pretty sure the average time of apprenticeship to take a position at the Selmer or Yanagisawa workshops is tad longer than the one needed to be hired in a phone factory line in China. I'll bet they pay better, too.
It compares.
The reason I compare phones and saxes is exactly because the market for phones is huge, yet their ability to get to 100% automation is still limited. The market for saxs is smaller- even more so at the premium end - so even harder to justify the cost of complex plant for fiddly work.
sure, maybe the training for some jobs takes longer... But it's a fixed overhead.
 
Many a saxophone is past a century old and still going strong. There's a reason for that: the techniques used to make them cannot easily be replaced.
I suspect the reasons for that are;
- skilled service tecs
- built-in obsolescence (phones and £€¥$200 Horns)
- ever increasing innovation (phones, certainly not horns!)
 
How many of you have worked in a factory? How many of you have laid out production process flows for a manufactured product?

I'm guessing the number asymptotically approaches zero.

Well, I have.

Saxophones are mass produced objects. Obviously the smaller the production rate, the greater proportion of hand work (vide Borgani). But the shops like Borgani are not the norm. The Yamaha factory is the norm; at lower production volumes the tooling and equipment can't be justified so they end up increasing direct labor content.

In either the Borgani factory or the Yamaha factory, the individual assembler or fabricator is not making decisions on the design of the product. The person running the tone-hole-pulling operation doesn't decide to move the C tone hole a couple mm one way or the other.

Craftsman making of products consists of a situation where the person doing the fabrication work is also making the design decisions.

Saxophones are not "hand-crafted products" even though there are people doing hand labor to make them. I bet that the vast majority of you who responded to my post do not even OWN a SINGLE hand-crafted object. If you own original art, yes. If you have a custom bespoke guitar, yes. If you have an individually tailored suit, OK. But I look around my office and my house and other than the plants in my garden, there is almost NOTHING that is not mass produced.

Y'all should be THRILLED that this is so. The subdivision of labor that made the Industrial Revolution possible is also the thing that means we're all able to earn a living doing relatively light pleasant labor, and sit at a computer and talk to people halfway round the world. Take away mass production and the average person MIGHT be able to afford three suits of clothing in his life. The modern standard of living exists because of mass production.
 
But I look around my office and my house and other than the plants in my garden, there is almost NOTHING that is not mass produced.
It's a good challenge.
I'm 100% sure my reed flutes are crafted... £100 or so.
Oh and the contents of most books (like art you mention) - till ChatGPT sorts that!
... And 'er indoors' knitted hats 😱
 
It's a good challenge.
I'm 100% sure my reed flutes are crafted... £100 or so.
Oh and the contents of most books (like art you mention) - till ChatGPT sorts that!
... And 'er indoors' knitted hats 😱
Books are printed in a mass production process.
 
Craftsman making of products consists of a situation where the person doing the fabrication work is also making the design decisions.

In my opinion, craftsman making of products means the person's skill is involved in the hands on making of the product and most of its components.

If a saxophone maker copies a vintage saxophone part for part and makes it by hand, that isn't handcrafted?
 
Craftsman making of products consists of a situation where the person doing the fabrication work is also making the design decisions.
this definition, which is what you base your argument on, seems contentious. i don't think there's anybody here who would decry 'mass-production' except in regard to its clear excesses and planetary destruction. people who hit metal with hammers in order to form a shape predetermined by others are craftsmen. people who make things up as they go along are artists.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,423
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom