Well now …. I read the summary, which caused me to read the entire thread, 20 minutes of my life which I won’t get back, but I was thoroughly amused. However, I have a couple nits to pick regarding the original post.
Since when were Mark VI tenors inferior to Mark VI altos? Speaking as one of those experienced professional types, I think the opposite is more likely true, but only in some individual cases. I agree the sopranos are of somewhat lesser quality, but only because Yanagisawa showed the world what a soprano should be like. I have little experience with the baritones, and am really not qualified to speak in that area.
Second nit - no mention of Beaugnier horns. These are often mistaken for student models (many of them being branded Vito), but in fact tonally speaking are right up there with the best instruments in the world. They are also built pretty well, even if the keywork is a little clunky. They are often available here in the colonies for much less than $1K, and are generally ignored except by those in the know.
This is a great thread, thanks IllinoisJ for reviving it - I now return you to your good-natured discussions.