Saxophones the obscure, the overlooked

Any chance of getting back to the original topic?
It was really interesting.
sorry, do you have any specific queries? i can say couesnon (boasting again) but i can also state that they have some splendid and underrated saxophones. their sopranos sound uniquely sweet, flute-like. the alto model with the long guard resembling a yamaha is fairly well-known but has several variants, there are earlier saxes with a quite different design, and the tenors sound magnificent. they often have rolled toneholes and a switchable g# linkage.
 
Reading this three years later. Lovely initial post, very informative, thank you. Although I agree that reading it as one long paragraph with no separation made it challenging. For clarity, and for future reference, I've boiled it down below. These are all French-made, correct? What about lesser-known British-made, German, Italian, etc?

--
  • Selmer mk VI tenor not as good as alto
  • SML super 45: best you’ve ever played
  • SML Gold Medal tenor, either mk 1 or mk II : magnificent roaring beast
  • SML Gold Medal alto mk 1 : sweet and warm
  • SML soprano is wonderful, as is the couesnon - among the best you’ve ever played
  • Courtois: remarkably well built with a bright, clear tone, excellent intonation and good ergonomics. Often have rolled toneholes.
  • J Gras: warm-toned with high build quality
  • Dolnets: avoid 'studiums, and M70. The Bel-air and the Royal Jazz are exceptionally good
  • Pierret ‘Super Artiste' from the 40's to the 60's have strikingly spindly keyguards with all sorts of engraving, these include the modele 6 , the excellent modele 8 (I never saw a modele 7, but there surely must be one) Super Artiste and Artiste Competition models. Dry, focused, bluesy tone. Later Super Artiste were made in the Selmer factory.
  • Beaugnier, sax-only company, produced tight, solid, good sounding saxophones. Best-known model is the 'special perfect'
  • Couesnon altos and tenors sound marvellous - best are marked ‘monpoly conservatoire', but over time vary considerably, some (also at some point badged as Besson) have rolled toneholes and a switchable g# linkage on the little finger table, later models do not, but have a high f#.
  • Malerne : solidly built saxes with good intonation
  • Robert Drouet saxes : delightful hand-made instruments with an exceptionally sweet tone but may need a vintage or large-chamber mouthpiece to keep in tune.
  • Maurice Boiste: same regarding mouthpiece. Some are called 'virtuoso' , weigh a ton. Yours was beautifully made, with not a fraction of lateral movement of the keys on the rods, a wonderful, lockable g# coupling and a deep golden lacquer finish. The 'serie artiste' play better, with good intonation and a tone like a Courtois.
  • Lyrist: best you recently got. Perhaps Adolphe Sax's son's company or owned by Courtois.Selmer bought it in 1928. The alto Briard model has rolled toneholes and sounds beautiful, rich, fat and warm down low, almost like a tenor, and has good intonation.
 
Oh that's very nice, thank-you. A bit of correction for Lyrist – NO connection with any Sax, but one member of the collective was Robert Drouet, who later went on to make his own. This information from the heroic jean-jacques at 'luthiervents' – heroic because he actually does research....... only in french.

as for other europeans, i'm not an expert on italian horns, i have had borgani 'macerata' curved soranos and they are great fun. grassi 'jade' tenors are good, but don't pay too much, they are not MK VI's.

there are loads of germans, and some of them are czech. Kohlerts are good until the mid sixties. Kohlers ("empor") are lovely. there are 3 keilwerths and 2 hullers. julius keilwerth still goes. long-running series called 'new king' and - better model - 'tone king'. rolled toneholes. they got better and better i think, but they're all built like battleships and sound enormous. Richard Keilwerth can be discounted, he's a clarinet man. Max Keilwerth made 'pure tone' saxes and supervised the production of hohner's 'president' saxes. i don't know what his supervision entailed, but the president is an excellent tenor, rather kohlert-ish, slightly more restrained than a julius keilwerth, and a very good alto, tight and accurate. 'pure tone' are quite raree, impeccable build, i had one apart and COULD NOT put it back together for several days because everything was so tightly engineered. works beautifully when you do.... a class act. players in the balkans love them.

fx huller made 'world' saxes, their altos sound so sweet it is a marvel. nearest thing is a conn new wonder. not so sure about the tenors, strangely enough. gh huller also made saxes all this time, ended up in e germany, earlier tenors are great, big and gruff and powerful. there were 2 adlers, a robert oswald and an oscar. oscar made a LOT of saxes and i have a 'gloria' and a 'triumph' i have seen also
'racso' (ignore these)
'sonora' (rather good)
the 'gloria' is okay but i'm not very happy with the intonation, i think the right mouthpiece is required; and this is ture also of the 'triumph', but the 'triumph' is INCREDIBLE.

i have a boosey and hawkes 'imperial' alto, which is really a nice sax. i have a weird 'boosey' which is horrible and sounds like a kazoo,.

i have to go and lie down now, if i can clear a space.
 
Well now …. I read the summary, which caused me to read the entire thread, 20 minutes of my life which I won’t get back, but I was thoroughly amused. However, I have a couple nits to pick regarding the original post.

Since when were Mark VI tenors inferior to Mark VI altos? Speaking as one of those experienced professional types, I think the opposite is more likely true, but only in some individual cases. I agree the sopranos are of somewhat lesser quality, but only because Yanagisawa showed the world what a soprano should be like. I have little experience with the baritones, and am really not qualified to speak in that area.

Second nit - no mention of Beaugnier horns. These are often mistaken for student models (many of them being branded Vito), but in fact tonally speaking are right up there with the best instruments in the world. They are also built pretty well, even if the keywork is a little clunky. They are often available here in the colonies for much less than $1K, and are generally ignored except by those in the know.

This is a great thread, thanks IllinoisJ for reviving it - I now return you to your good-natured discussions.
 
pierret produced from the 40's to the 60's the modele 6 , the excellent modele 8 (i never saw a modele 7, but there surely must be one) .
Here is a model 7, with quite a striking keyguard brace:

kgrkbc8uajqt4o5fd83b.webp




s-l1600.webp
 
Well now …. I read the summary, which caused me to read the entire thread, 20 minutes of my life which I won’t get back, but I was thoroughly amused. However, I have a couple nits to pick regarding the original post.

Since when were Mark VI tenors inferior to Mark VI altos? Speaking as one of those experienced professional types, I think the opposite is more likely true, but only in some individual cases. I agree the sopranos are of somewhat lesser quality, but only because Yanagisawa showed the world what a soprano should be like. I have little experience with the baritones, and am really not qualified to speak in that area.

Second nit - no mention of Beaugnier horns. These are often mistaken for student models (many of them being branded Vito), but in fact tonally speaking are right up there with the best instruments in the world. They are also built pretty well, even if the keywork is a little clunky. They are often available here in the colonies for much less than $1K, and are generally ignored except by those in the know.

This is a great thread, thanks IllinoisJ for reviving it - I now return you to your good-natured discussions.
beaugnier - very sorry if not. they made saxes for everyone else.... leblanc (hence vito), louis augu, noblet..... very nice saxes. i thought i did mention them, naming the special perfect, for example. i have here now some great beaugniers, the tenors sound marvelous, really gruff and vintage. somehow the keys are in the wrong places... this is me, of course, with my square puffy hands made for gripping spades. this one has rolled toneholes, a rocking octave key, a split D, a g# link switch, engraved bow..... etc. an augu 'royal conservatoire'.

i can only talk about what i've used, and MK VI's are inconsistent, of course, like all these venerable machines. the best altos i had had some weird thing about them, one with an SBA neck (great!) one with bits of keilwerth on it, for which i was almost lynched (frightening! but the horn sounded glorious, truly classic..... but only THAT sound).
 
avoid 'studiums, and M70.
I did have ask M70 once. It had a very distinctive sound which I liked a lot for certain things. IIRC though the keywork was somewhat dodgy looking in places, a sort of "added on" top F# which had a key cup that cut into the tenon receiver.
 
I did have ask M70 once. It had a very distinctive sound which I liked a lot for certain things. IIRC though the keywork was somewhat dodgy looking in places, a sort of "added on" top F# which had a key cup that cut into the tenon receiver.
that's interesting pete; i have seen a couesnon with such a hole, but for a g i think, and i have now an adler 'triumph' which does the same thing.
 
I agree the sopranos are of somewhat lesser quality, but only because Yanagisawa showed the world what a soprano should be like.
The MKVI sopranos were lesser before there were Yanagisawas
I have little experience with the baritones, and am really not qualified to speak in that area.
I was never impressed by the MKVI baritones. The stupid MKVI price hike we saw in tenors and to a slightly lesser extent with allots, didn't seem to happen to the baritones until quite a few years later.
 
peterpick, I have more questions:
- you mentionned several times "rolled toneholes": are they something you look for? Why?
- do all these models you mention have the model name engraved on the bell?
- how many of these French makers were merged or bought into the Selmer company?
- can you think of examples of models with very ornate engravings covering more than just a bit of the bell?
 
"rolled toneholes": are they something you look for? Why?

When I bought my used horn the seller also pointed this out as a plus, I think they were/are a mark of handcrafted "quality". The kind of thing that saxophone players (not necessarily makers/repairers?) get in their head as a distinguishing feature. However I've read conflicting opinions on this and I'm also curious what an objective take on it would be.

In the spirit of the thread, there is a prolific seller on our local Craigslist who is a teacher/tech, they recently posted a nice looking Couesnon Monopole Conservatoire II alto: Couesnon Monopole Conservatoire II alto saxophone Just Serviced. - musical instruments - by owner - sale - craigslist. $1600 USD, recently serviced. How does this compare pricewise with what folks have seen I wonder?
 
🙂🙂 Very interesting Peter.. I was recently asked if I could resurrect a "Paramount Paris" Alto sax which Sarah had bought off ebay for £232. It had not been treated well and required more than a little ingenuity, but as I quite like a challenge carried on. After a couple of weeks it was finished and, although I was really sceptical if it would ever sound good, was amazed at the tone and the great intonation..A bit of work online gave some gen. Made in Chicago by the Frank Co for marching bands. This I took with a bit of salt. However, as I did the work, it was most interesting to find that there was no front F and the G sharp was at the rear of the horn. Sufice it to say that the sax turned out really well and she has a good early horn.. Any more info Sarah would be pleased to know as I would myself.. Regards 🙂🙂
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,420
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom