Saxophones the obscure, the overlooked

I've had the pleasure of holding tenors once belonging to both Coleman Hawkins and Joe Henderson ; both of which I believe the provenance to be legitimate.

Was that Hawkins one the old gold-plated Selmer owned / being sold by Dave Davis in Yorkshire quite a few years ago ?

I would have loved to see/hold/play/buy that, but the price was very high.

I recently bought the modified Berg Larsen baritone mouthpiece owned and played for years by Ronnie Ross. So far I haven't played it !

Rhys
 
That's the one Rhys yeah...it was a crazy price but it fluctuated over time ; I don't know if he ever sold it...the guy was erm...an original character...
You need to give that mpc a blow !!
 
there are definitely differences in tone between saxes, and modern saxes have the tendency to sound a bit thin, because, i suppose, they project better and are brighter in tone. i don't much like the way all saxes have to look the same nowadays. but it's about the sound. the modernest sax i have is a selmer SA80, and it plays really fast, sometimes all by itself in the box, but it doesn't sound as nice to my ear as something 40 years older.
 
That's the one Rhys yeah...it was a crazy price but it fluctuated over time ; I don't know if he ever sold it...the guy was erm...an original character...
You need to give that mpc a blow !!

I think the Coleman Hawkins tenor was sold. I've seen various pictures of it in an exhibiton in Europe and others online too. I don't know who bought it... I heard rumours it went to a museum?

1.jpg


2.JPG
 
Yes, many obscured and overlooked saxes out there. But "obscured and overlooked" saxes are also some kind of "into the mystic". Hard to get the right info from/about small manufactors or brandholders. And internet is a good carrier of rumors. When I started to buy and became interested in saxes in the mid 70's it was personal meetings, phonecalls, letters, books and magazines that were the carriers. Many of todays highly respected and - valued saxes were not among the best saxes according to professional players, teachers ..... . After WWII I think just one third of the european manufactors that produced sopranos and baritone. But if a sax is a good player, who cares what is engraved on the bell?
 
" into the mystic "...a bit of Van influence creeping in there Thom...
It must have been at least twenty years since I was around that horn Hank but yeah I reckon that's the one . Very nice indeed !!
 
As for the ammount of time spent on forums..
I'm still in recovery from the accident last June : also undergoing lengthy dental procedures so right now yeah I'm spending a lot of time here...I enjoy it !!
There is only so much playing you can do in a day : if I manage a solid four hours six days a week I'm happy . If the typical working day is estimated to be eight hours that leaves plenty of time on here ; listening to music ; transcribing etc etc...
Yup : I'm happy with my lot..
 
He makes the valid point that most comments about saxophones on forums are from poor players rather than competent professionals. He goes on to suggest that the conclusions reached might be different if the competent players were more vocal in the discussions. I agree with both of these statements, but this does not mean that the conclusions reached are any less useful for the amateur-standard players involved.

I totally agree with this, and didn't intend to suggest otherwise -- that's not inconsistent with my point, which was sort of on a different "flow chart" branch.

Beginners not only have insight of benefit to other beginners that better players may not offer, but are going to suffer more (knowingly or not) than stronger players when equipment is bad or in bad playing condition (though a better player may be more or less upset, s/he will be able to play through problems more "expertly" because more...expert).

Beginners won't have the degree of sensitivity or experience stronger players will have, to make an accurate judgment on what's happening, or whether the equipment is causing a problem (or maybe won't be bothered by problems). But that can just as easily be flipped around according to the people being compared. A really strong player can overcome a lot of weaknesses or flaws that a beginner can't. Who is more bothered is more personal (i.e. personality related), but a stronger player will have played more horns (generally speaking) and will have played horns in a greater variety of playing conditions, with or without problems, and is more likely to have experienced what horns should feel like when they're in optimal playing condition. That also makes a difference in how players respond to equipment in terms of forming opinions and giving reviews.

But that doesn't at all mean a beginner can't be more sensitive to equipment than a virtuoso.

A dear friend and mentor to me (since passed) was playing a King 615 tenor when I met him. Many would say he was the most virtuoso New Orleans-born saxophonist of his generation, maybe other than Nat Perrilliat, during his lifetime. When I met him, maybe 6 or 7 notes on his saxophone were truly functional, and there were rubber bands and literally bandaids here and there all over the horn. You would never have known, if you'd heard him play, that he was largely "whistling" (his word for it) when playing gigs on that horn, in that condition.

He was less bothered than a lot of beginners would have been in the same circumstance, but he could also do a lot more with the horn in that condition.

My point wasn't really related to any of that, but those are worthwhile points.
 
Last edited:
I have 2 SML Gold Medal 1s that are about 400 apart. one is a really good horn the other is magic. The differences are probably utterly insignificant to the audience BUT to me while I am comfortable with the one, the other, when I’m on, I can play without any thought, at times it even lets me over-reach my abilities without losing it.
 
I was once on a saxophone course given by an incredibly gifted international professional classical saxophone player.
He gave us amateurs a short talk about mouthpieces.
The talk basically contained three pieces of information:
1. Mouthpieces come in various tip openings.
2. Selmer make other mouthpieces besides the S80 C*, so these may be worth considering for anyone who wants to try something different.
3. Metal mouthpieces are BAD and are all very loud! We should stay away from them.
This sort of comment from a classical player (regarding jazz or pop) is normal. The problem is that they have no knowledge or appreciation of anything outside their own field. It's mostly the same vice versa too, but jazz players don't record hideous versions of classical pieces (they change them completely, which some might still find hideous, but it's in keeping with the essence of jazz) and yet the opposite is too often true of classical players/singers. They know so little of the genre they are dipping a toe into that they think that what they have delivered to be valid and on-point because it is accurate to the information asked of them in the manuscript.

The above scenario occurs because in the classical world there is very little range of accepted tonal difference. There are less 'normal' techniques that allow it too - no subtone for instance. Rules, rules, rules.
 
i've got versions of both of these horns david and i recommend them both. the model 6 will be harder and more focused than a buffet, perhaps the ergonomics are not as modern. i reckon the model 6 is the first 'poimbeouf' model.... but hang on a minute there is also a model 6 which is a 'nil melior', the previous series, and i've never played one of those. the olds parisian should be really good. i have an alto, which is really good and a tenor just slightly different which i'd have to say is VERY good, even marvelous. great tone. when i got the alto it had some fluff lodged in the octave pipe on the body (not the neck) and it took me a week to work out why it behaved so strangely. after i poked it out with a spring it works beautifully. my tenor is a super artiste of that period and differs only in having pearls in places every girl wants them. oh, and a high f#, i don't think the olds will have that. but if it's a good price i'd strongly recommend it, above the model 6, poimbeouf or not. (the poimbeouf model has those weird spindly pillars for the guards, which are engraved, and sheet metal). it's a different body and everything. as for the 'parisian' there are rumours that it uses SBA bodies from selmer which they didn't want because they were making the mk VI. at this time pierret were working either within the selmer premises or really close by, since they had managed to burn their factory down again.... i was told. i would recommend getting the olds parisian, definitely. mine came very heavily sprung and i've had to bend some keys, it's not the friendliest horn, but it sounds really great, shades of the classic tenors of the 50's 60's - one could almost believe the stories, it's like john coltrane played one.
 
I found similar info about Pierret/Selmer yesterday, as here: Saxophones - Olds Parisian and Parisian Ambassador

This is the Parisian (seller's photos):

IMG-20201208-WA0002.jpg

IMG-20201208-WA0004.jpg


The Modele 6 is the same as Helen's here: Bassic Sax Pix

The Parisian seller isn't filling me with much confidence at the moment but I'm short of tenors and long on altos. Also seems, from research ( here: Pierret History :: SaxPics.com ), the Modele 6 is a 1920's model which surprises me as it looks more modern.

I think the Parisian is 50's/60's although it could be as late as 70/71?

I have that "about to pull the trigger" feeling so I'd best be careful to do my due diligence before I get carried away!

What would you pay for either in good playing condition? Thanks for the info.
 
in good playing condition a desperate addict like myself would pay up to £1000. i say that because that's more or less what i got my super artiste for, all freshly done up. but 2 caveats: the olds is 'competition' level model - slightly less luxurious, actually the same - and it is a stencil. a more realistic price would be around 700 i suppose. but it is definitely worth more, in itself. in truth i would consider buying it myself for £500 plus, i think it could be passed on to a deserving citizen under the right circumstances.....
 
The Olds Parisian tenor has one small dent somewhere, pads all fine, he had an alto, thought he'd try tenor but didn't gel hence the sale.

Yes, I thought Competition stencil too which is why I was surprised that after giving the Competition alto such a good review, Steve Howard disliked the Parisian tenor so much, here: Olds ( Pierret ) Parisian tenor saxophone review

But I'm fairly sure that tenor isn't a Parisian but a Parisian Ambassador or plain Ambassador. Have a look... to me the differing l/h pinky table and white rollers mean it's one of those two inferior models. What do you think?
 
i think it's a parisian ambassador, as you say. anyway pierret models are enough to make your head explode. i suppose when you make them all by hand you can do whatever you want with the tube. i've got an alto they made for olds, the parisian, and it is a late competition stencil. a really good saxophone. just maybe a bit too bright for me, it's a modern tone, but it's not thin.
 
I'm going to give up the alto to someone else here. It's a Pierret stencil Modele 6 for Boosey & Hawkes, called the "Predominant" which the seller has had for 42 years!

On a buy it now at £220: Alto Saxophone Boosey & Hawkes | eBay

No idea if he'll deliver but seems a good guy chatting to him via eBay messages.

Right, now someone put me out of my misery and buy it (check what you're buying first).

Parisian seller hasn't come back to me so hopefully I'll not have to buy that one either! 😵
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,420
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom