He makes the valid point that most comments about saxophones on forums are from poor players rather than competent professionals. He goes on to suggest that the conclusions reached might be different if the competent players were more vocal in the discussions. I agree with both of these statements, but this does not mean that the conclusions reached are any less useful for the amateur-standard players involved.
I totally agree with this, and didn't intend to suggest otherwise -- that's not inconsistent with my point, which was sort of on a different "flow chart" branch.
Beginners not only have insight of benefit to other beginners that better players may not offer, but are going to suffer more (knowingly or not) than stronger players when equipment is bad or in bad playing condition (though a better player may be more or less upset, s/he will be able to play through problems more "expertly" because more...expert).
Beginners won't have the degree of sensitivity or experience stronger players will have, to make an accurate judgment on what's happening, or whether the equipment is causing a problem (or maybe won't be bothered by problems). But that can just as easily be flipped around according to the people being compared. A really strong player can overcome a lot of weaknesses or flaws that a beginner can't. Who is more bothered is more personal (i.e. personality related), but a stronger player will have played more horns (generally speaking) and will have played horns in a greater variety of playing conditions, with or without problems, and is more likely to have experienced what horns should feel like when they're in optimal playing condition. That also makes a difference in how players respond to equipment in terms of forming opinions and giving reviews.
But that doesn't at all mean a beginner can't be more sensitive to equipment than a virtuoso.
A dear friend and mentor to me (since passed) was playing a King 615 tenor when I met him. Many would say he was the most virtuoso New Orleans-born saxophonist of his generation, maybe other than Nat Perrilliat, during his lifetime. When I met him, maybe 6 or 7 notes on his saxophone were truly functional, and there were rubber bands and literally bandaids here and there all over the horn. You would never have known, if you'd heard him play, that he was largely "whistling" (his word for it) when playing gigs on that horn, in that condition.
He was less
bothered than a lot of beginners would have been in the same circumstance, but he could also do a lot more with the horn in that condition.
My point wasn't really related to any of that, but those are worthwhile points.