Saxophones the obscure, the overlooked

In my opinion, craftsman making of products means the person's skill is involved in the hands on making of the product and most of its components.

If a saxophone maker copies a vintage saxophone part for part and makes it by hand, that isn't handcrafted?
Well, you can decide to use different definitions for words than those that are generally accepted in the fields where they apply.

That doesn't change the FACT that the folks working in the factory are ASSEMBLERS or FABRICATORS of varying degrees of skill; they are not making design choices. The generally accepted industrial definitions of words tell us that what they're doing is not craft work; it's mass production with varying degrees of skill.

Don't get me wrong. What they're doing is honorable work. It's valuable to society. It's skilled work. It's just not handcraftsmanship.

Your second sentence doesn't make any sense to an engineer. What constitutes "making it by hand"? Does this mean every key cup is formed over a mandrel by hammer and hand, or is the maker allowed to use an OBI press and stamping tools to make a couple dozen key cups in a minute? Does it mean the person who solders the posts onto the body is allowed to put them any old place, or do they have to follow the drawings made by the designer? Are they allowed to use jigs and fixtures to position said posts, so the position will be consistent from one unit to the next, or do they have to position them by guess and by golly? Are you saying that each key arm is cut from sheet brass by a guy with a jewelers saw? Can they put together some stamping tools to stamp the key arms on the aforementioned OBI, thus saving hundreds of hours and achieving far better results?

Does the brass have to be melted in a coal forge right there in the plant and hand hammered to final thickness with a 4 lb. hammer on an anvil, or can they buy sheet brass from the local metals distributor?

I know I'm peeing in the wind, but I'm hoping to show that the whole idea of "handmade saxophone" is bogus from start to finish. Ain't no one never made a "handmade saxophone", from Adolphe Sax who ran an instrument FACTORY till now.
 
- you mentionned several times "rolled toneholes": are they something you look for? Why?
The fine vintage saxes with rolled tone holes often have wrapped "tone holes" (uneven) tone holes rims. That nothing to search for. I have owned post WWII Conn Artist 10M without and with rolled tone holes. They sounded and the key actions was the same. At least not notable to my ears. I asked a designer why he designed saxes with straight and rolled tone holes. Some sax players goes crazy when they see rolled tone holes. To make a wrapped rolled tone hole even needs some skill and time.
 
Was that Hawkins one the old gold-plated Selmer owned / being sold by Dave Davis in Yorkshire quite a few years ago ?
I believe I was in contact about this horn. At the time it was about £15000 but I was wary of the provenance. Not sure why now - that seems a reasonable price if the provenance was good. But if not it was a lot of money for one of those.

(BTW we have moved some OT posts about writing and grammar to the OT forum)
 
i too like rolled toneholes because they indicate to me a degree of care in manufacture. of course if they are warped they are a bastard to deal with. Keilwerth now solder their rolled bits onto a normal tonehole which seems bizarre to me for some reason and they still can't get them straight, according to Mr Howard.

as for germans, let's go a bit further into the obscure.....

the east german makers, as they became, mostly driven out of what is now the czech republic, were collectivised at various times, but some worked independently for quite a while, and in a looser grouping called MIGMA. among these are Werner Roth and Wolfram. i have tenors by each of these, the werner roth is beautifully built to very exacting tolerances - like the max keilwerth i mentioned earlier (above) i found it truly complicated to put back together - instead of posts or cradles all the springs want to go in little holes, which makes life difficult when re-assembling. i had a maurice boiste like that too.

g h huller, (as opposed to f x huller makers of the truly excellent "world" brand saxes) found themselves in east germany after WW2 and were quickly swept up into the collectives - B&S i think, but there was also weltklang. i can recommend their pre-war production, i have had very good (heavy) tenors with a powerful datk tone and unusual keywork designed to improve intonation around the bow, and altos with delicate engraving.
 
i too like rolled toneholes because they indicate to me a degree of care in manufacture

Regarding care in manufacture. after watching Matt Stohrer's video on the subject, there's rolled toneholes and rolled toneholes. It's much more difficult to make drawn toneholes (directly pulled out of the body) than to add-on toneholes by solering them on the body. Then, for the pulled toneholes, it's much more difficult to have them rolled than it is for soldered toneholes to be rolled.

For soldered ones, there's soft solder and hard (silver) solder, which also indicate a difference in care of manufacture. What you indicate about Keilwerth soldering rolled bits on to the chimney, that seems a step down from actually rolling any metal.

Very informative and clear videos here:
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IwmUa9BWu0E
 
i do agree about soldering rims on straight toneholes. as far as i know very few manufacturers after 1930-something soldered their toneholes, except for martin, who 'soft' soldered them. all the rolled toneholes i have experience of are drawn and turned. i never tried or even looked at a new keilwerth - i can't afford one. i always likie matt stohrer's videos.
 
Rolled tone holes are a solution for a problem that no longer exists, thanks due to advances in pad technology.

It was a selling point for a certain brand of vintage American horn that was deemed desirable for its sound and emulated by others. Horns, with and without rolled tone holes, by the same manufacturer sound much the same.

Funny how all the rest of the classic American horn manufacturers never incorporated rolled tone holes into their design, yet Conn eventually omitted it.
 
i said above that i have had direct experience of rolled and straight toneholes onn SML gold medals and i believe from my subjective view that they respond differently - the straight tonehole version is a bit more free and airy.
Rolled tone holes are a solution for a problem that no longer exists, thanks due to advances in pad technology.
 
t's much more difficult to make drawn toneholes (directly pulled out of the body) than to add-on toneholes by solering them on the body.
Drawn tone holes à la Conn was not difficult to do. The challenge was to earn earn enough money so the "pull-up-tone hole machine could be justified. I don't remember who owned the patent for "pull-up" machine? Haynes. They owned patent to the roll tone machine method as well? Silver soldering tone holes needs higher temperature than soft soldering tone holes. Both methods were labour intensive. Are they're any saxes with soldered tone holes that have rolled tone hole rims?
 
Last edited:
Rolled tone holes are a solution for a problem that no longer exists, thanks due to advances in pad technology.
According to Mr Matt Stohrer, what rolled toneholes did was mostly make the life of the pads last much, much longer.
Are you talking about the same problem for which rolled toneholes were a solution?
 
as far as i know very few manufacturers after 1930-something soldered their toneholes
King (H.N. White and King Musical Instruments) had silver soldered tone holes. King Super 20 !!!!!! Even the late Powell Eagle sax had silver soldered tone holes. Keilwerth ( Nauheim), Kohlert, (Winneden), Hohner (Tossingen) ... and I have also seen a Hammerschimdt with soft soldered tone holes. These four west-german manufacture made saxes with rolled tone holes in the 50's and 60's as well.
said above that i have had direct experience of rolled and straight toneholes onn SML gold medals and i believe from my subjective view that they respond differently - the straight tonehole version is a bit more free and airy.
As I wrote earlier Have have owned 47-48 Conn Artist 10M with both straight and rolled tone holes. With the same type of pads and set up by the "SML tech" I couldn't hear any difference when it to the tone. Bit the sound (included key, pad ) was softer on the one with rth. There was a little bit better "feeling" on the tenor with rth. I think there is a placebo effect?
 
Last edited:
conn1.webp
conn 2.webp
 
Rolled tone holes are a solution for a problem that no longer exists, thanks due to advances in pad technology.
All saxes , more or less, back in the 20's were suffering with uneven tone holes. To cure these problems Conn had the "Conn Reso-O-Pad", Beuscher had the "Snap-On-Pads", Holton had "The Holton Saxophone Pad" with the hard "Woolite" felt, waterproof never swelling kid skin ..... even Matin, that had less problem, with the soft soldered tone holes had pad system as well; "Perfect Pad ....". I don't know if H.N. White had a pad system ???? The turned a problem to sell more saxes?
 
Fwiw Martin was still using soldered on sockets in1962. The thickness and the bevel add rigidity to the horn. Pad technology is definitely better today. The contact surface area of a thick chimney, rolled tone hole or a bevel has benefits and drawbacks. Yeah better pad life, better sealing at the cost of a pad potentially sticking.
1962 Martin
1707681365154.webp


1930 Holton
1707681541087.webp


1933 Conn 6m the tone holes are straight cylinders.
1707681743847.webp

1707681909490.webp


By 1952 the RTH was long gone. Look at the shape change below. It’s almost rounded/conical.
1707682146472.webp
 
Fwiw Martin was still using soldered on sockets in1962. The thickness and the bevel add rigidity to the horn. Pad technology is definitely better today. The contact surface area of a thick chimney, rolled tone hole or a bevel has benefits and drawbacks. Yeah better pad life, better sealing at the cost of a pad potentially sticking.
1962 Martin
View attachment 25455

1930 Holton
View attachment 25456

1933 Conn 6m the tone holes are straight cylinders.View attachment 25457
View attachment 25458

By 1952 the RTH was long gone. Look at the shape change below. It’s almost rounded/conical.
View attachment 25459

I don't understand what you mean by "it's almost rounded/conical" - could you explain ?

Rhys
 
"Martin, Elkhart" (Wurlitzer) had soft soldered tone holes until they were bought by Leblanc, Elkhorn in c 1971. I think they made the late The Medalist and The Imperial with soft soldered tone holes as well. But I really don't know when the stopped making Martin saxes with soft soldered tone holes? Some info says the production was zero or very small the last years before the Leblanc era began.
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,420
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom