Well, you can decide to use different definitions for words than those that are generally accepted in the fields where they apply.In my opinion, craftsman making of products means the person's skill is involved in the hands on making of the product and most of its components.
If a saxophone maker copies a vintage saxophone part for part and makes it by hand, that isn't handcrafted?
That doesn't change the FACT that the folks working in the factory are ASSEMBLERS or FABRICATORS of varying degrees of skill; they are not making design choices. The generally accepted industrial definitions of words tell us that what they're doing is not craft work; it's mass production with varying degrees of skill.
Don't get me wrong. What they're doing is honorable work. It's valuable to society. It's skilled work. It's just not handcraftsmanship.
Your second sentence doesn't make any sense to an engineer. What constitutes "making it by hand"? Does this mean every key cup is formed over a mandrel by hammer and hand, or is the maker allowed to use an OBI press and stamping tools to make a couple dozen key cups in a minute? Does it mean the person who solders the posts onto the body is allowed to put them any old place, or do they have to follow the drawings made by the designer? Are they allowed to use jigs and fixtures to position said posts, so the position will be consistent from one unit to the next, or do they have to position them by guess and by golly? Are you saying that each key arm is cut from sheet brass by a guy with a jewelers saw? Can they put together some stamping tools to stamp the key arms on the aforementioned OBI, thus saving hundreds of hours and achieving far better results?
Does the brass have to be melted in a coal forge right there in the plant and hand hammered to final thickness with a 4 lb. hammer on an anvil, or can they buy sheet brass from the local metals distributor?
I know I'm peeing in the wind, but I'm hoping to show that the whole idea of "handmade saxophone" is bogus from start to finish. Ain't no one never made a "handmade saxophone", from Adolphe Sax who ran an instrument FACTORY till now.
