Playing the saxophone The Harmonic Minor scale without sharps and flats

[QUOTE="jbtsax, post: 289392, member: 1801" When I hear Dm7 in the key of C I hear a minor chord. I don't think of going to the key of D minor.

So why think D dorian, which is in the key of D minor?
I have always thought that D dorian as used in the ii V I in the key of C is the second mode of C major---not the first mode of D minor. But doesn't it depend upon the context? If the changes were Em7 A7 Dm then the D dorian would be in the key of D minor.
 
I like to treat a Dm7 in Key of C as 9 11 13 16,. Extending a Cmaj7 into a Dm7 and out the other side, sounds very pretty. Treating it as F6 inversion, I like to add passing/grace notes in semitone runs that blue it up.

I can't think in modes and for the most part, I can't remember their names. Dorian is easy the easy one to remember cos it's D to D in C.

All this stuff sounds complicated in words. The sounds explain themselves. I think theory is best explained while sat at a piano keyboard. Even one of them 12" Casio things makes it all make sense. I get very bogged down reading about theory. Not being academic, the numbers, letters etc start to look like a Greek recipe. If I understand the sound I can follow the theory.
 
I have always thought that D dorian as used in the ii V I in the key of C is the second mode of C major---not the first mode of D minor. But doesn't it depend upon the context? If the changes were Em7 A7 Dm then the D dorian would be in the key of D minor.
You wish...

C Am | Dm7 G7 | Em7 A7 | Dm7 G7| ...

"kind of" D minor. Actually a secondary dominant that does not substantially change the overall C major flavour, in particular at fast tempos
 
If the "melodic minor scale" occurs on the V...

Say we are in Am
Bm7b5 E7 Am

- On E7 you can use A melodic minor. It implies E9, though.
- On E7 you can use the scale containing b9 b10(AKA #9) #11 #5. In this case E7 becomes E7alt.
Incidentally it contains the same notes as F minor melodic, but it has no relation with Fminor whatsoever

I don't know at the moment which other Melodic minor he can be referring to, unless it is on ii or on i

I know what he's talking about. I read that book years ago and remember this one.

In Am again.

He talks about using D mm for the Bm7b5, F mm for the E7 and A mm for the tonic. He has names for all the melodic minor modes but the only one I ever remember without looking them up is super locrian for the 7th mode.

That's not what I'd do most of the time but it is viable and Levine also describes a nice trick involving this. You can take a little pattern on the II, transpose it up a minor 3rd for the dominant and then transpose it up a major 3rd over the tonic. It usually comes out sounding interesting, not least because the notes have different relationships to the root over each chord.
 
In Am again.
He talks about using D mm for the Bm7b5, F mm for the E7 and A mm for the tonic.
I see... I 've always seen that Dmm on Bm7b5 as the halfdim natural ninth chord.
All my favourite players use it, but I still cannot make that C# sound right if we are in A minor. I should work on it.

You can take a little pattern on the II, transpose it up a minor 3rd for the dominant and then transpose it up a major 3rd over the tonic. It usually comes out sounding interesting, not least because the notes have different relationships to the root over each chord.
Nice Coltranish gizmo. I must try (of course thinking on superimposed chords, instead)
 
Last edited:
Must say I do admire all of you guys,with your music knowledge theory but it is lost on me,sometimes when I start reading topics like this it kind of makes me think,do I have to have this knowledge myself to be able to play,it kind of puts me off from carrying on.But then I think well I started playing with no music background,passed a few grades,played six gigs with a band,can play some tunes,so I must have gained some knowledge,but not has deep like some people.I will carry on in my own time,but well done for you and your knowledge.Bumnote.
 
Must say I do admire all of you guys,with your music knowledge theory but it is lost on me,sometimes when I start reading topics like this it kind of makes me think,do I have to have this knowledge myself to be able to play,it kind of puts me off from carrying on.But then I think well I started playing with no music background,passed a few grades,played six gigs with a band,can play some tunes,so I must have gained some knowledge,but not has deep like some people.I will carry on in my own time,but well done for you and your knowledge.Bumnote.

There are several levels of music theory, and several approaches possible.
This thread could be read at several levels, simply ignoring it when it becomes an headache.

I get very passionate, since I hit my own head on approaches that slowed down my musical growth.
Ultimately I play in A minor when in A minor, but knowing where things might go is useful.

Unfortunately to communicate we need a common language that can look a bit weird. But it allows me and Pete to communicate, even if I had a very Italian music education (with a couple wonderful teachers, though) and he, clearly, hadn't.

But starting to grasp the language (i.e. assigning grades to notes and names to chords) is useful well before becoming Superlocrians (picture needed).
 
We are getting way off topic now (yes I know, I am partly to blame)
Must say I do admire all of you guys,with your music knowledge theory but it is lost on me,sometimes when I start reading topics like this it kind of makes me think,do I have to have this knowledge myself to be able to play,it kind of puts me off from carrying on.But then I think well I started playing with no music background,passed a few grades,played six gigs with a band,can play some tunes,so I must have gained some knowledge,but not has deep like some people.I will carry on in my own time,but well done for you and your knowledge.Bumnote.

You sound like an ideal customer for TamingTheSaxophone vol 2, out very soon.

Beginners theory for pop, blues, rock (not jazz)
 
Last edited:
I, for one, am enjoying this conversation, even though some of it is beyond my theoretical knowledge and almost all of it is beyond my (current) ability to apply in practice. Yes, in the end what matters is whether it sounds good to you, but if you're composing or improvising, you have a better chance of coming up with something that does sound good if you understand how the kind of music you're making is put together. It's great to read what such experienced players have to say on the subject.
 
Last edited:
You wish...

C Am | Dm7 G7 | Em7 A7 | Dm7 G7| ...

"kind of" D minor. Actually a secondary dominant that does not substantially change the overall C major flavour, in particular at fast tempos

That's what I mean by context. Playing and thinking D dorian over Dm does not necessarily put you in D minor.

I know what he's talking about. I read that book years ago and remember this one. . . .He talks about using D mm for the Bm7b5, F mm for the E7 and A mm for the tonic.

What are D mm and A mm?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,674
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom