Playing the saxophone The Harmonic Minor scale without sharps and flats

He recommends 3 different melodic minor scales over minor ii V I. I still need to understand/absorb that one.

If the "melodic minor scale" occurs on the V...

Say we are in Am
Bm7b5 E7 Am

- On E7 you can use A melodic minor. It implies E9, though.
- On E7 you can use the scale containing b9 b10(AKA #9) #11 #5. In this case E7 becomes E7alt.
Incidentally it contains the same notes as F minor melodic, but it has no relation with Fminor whatsoever

I don't know at the moment which other Melodic minor he can be referring to, unless it is on ii or on i
 
ii - V7 - I in the key of C

ii - the notes of the D dorian - 2nd mode of C major---1, 3, 5, and 7 of that mode "outline" the chord.
V7 - the notes of the G mixolydian - 5th mode of C major---1, 3, 5, and 7 of that mode outline the chord.
I - The C ionian - the 1st mode of C major---1, 3, 5, 7 of that mode outline the chord.

There are lots of choices over V7 "altered" chords. The "diminished whole tone scale" - 7th mode of melodic minor is a useful choice IMO.
 
Last edited:
ii - V7 - I in the key of C

ii - the notes of the D dorian - 2nd mode of C major---1, 3, 5, and 7 of that mode "outline" the chord.
V7 - the notes of the G mixolydian - 5th mode of C major.........


Alternatively instead of all those modes, why not make it easy?

Dm7 G7 C. My first thought is, scale of C. Life 9and improvising) goes by too quickly to faff around with dorians, mixolydians and ionians in this context.

In my experience chords pass very quickly and there is not enough time to work out modes.
 
Alternatively instead of all those modes, why not make it easy?

Dm7 G7 C. My first thought is, scale of C. Life 9and improvising) goes by too quickly to faff around with dorians, mixolydians and ionians in this context.

In my experience chords pass very quickly and there is not enough time to work out modes.

How about saying the C scale from D to D and the C scale from G to G? That still incorporates 1, 3, 5, 7 of those "scales" spelling out the chord. In my thinking learning to improvise (or compose) is about learning scales and chords since melodies are made up of scale steps and chord tones along with other related intervals.

@Pete Thomas I'm curious. What would you have a student practice when learning to play over changes with altered dominant 7ths?
 
How about saying the C scale from D to D and the C scale from G to G? That still incorporates 1, 3, 5, 7 of those "scales" spelling out the chord. In my thinking learning to improvise (or compose) is about learning scales and chords since melodies are made up of scale steps and chord tones along with other related intervals.
But why using Dorian, Ionian and Myxolydian, when "Major" is enough in a context in which we are clearly in C major?
 
But why using Dorian, Ionian and Myxolydian, when "Major" is enough in a context in which we are clearly in C major?

And, getting back on topic, harmonic minor is enough when clearly we are in C minor.

In a minor key, what are the corresponding modes if you want to think along the same lines as dorian, mixolydian ionian for a major II V I?
 
But why using Dorian, Ionian and Myxolydian, when "Major" is enough in a context in which we are clearly in C major?

Here we are getting down to the nitty gritty. 🙂 The dm7 chord has a D minor tonality---not a C major tonality. In the D minor the F can be stressed, in C major tonality it cannot. In C major tonality the G can be stressed, but in the D minor tonality it cannot.

C major indeed does delineate the note choices, but IMO it does not help the player to group those notes as does thinking or hearing the notes as modes built on the C scale.
 
Here we are getting down to the nitty gritty. 🙂 The dm7 chord has a D minor tonality---not a C major tonality.

Here it gets hot: D minor is originally an F major added 6 in 3rd inversion.
It is a subdominant chord in the family of C major. As C major as the A minor in I vi ii V.
There is no change in mode.

In a minor key, what are the corresponding modes if you want to think along the same lines as dorian, mixolydian ionian for a major II V I?
Locrian, Phrygian Dominant, Aeolian. Obvious....
 
Here it gets hot: D minor is originally an F major added 6 in 3rd inversion.
It is a subdominant chord in the family of C major. As C major as the A minor in I vi ii V.
There is no change in mode.


Locrian, Phrygian Dominant, Aeolian. Obvious....

Ouch
 
Here we are getting down to the nitty gritty. 🙂 The dm7 chord has a D minor tonality---not a C major tonality.

I don't see that.

It is not a Dm chord in the key of D minor with a D minor tonality. It is functioning in the key of C with a C tonality.

If, every time you have a IIm7 V7 I progression, you have to think in three separate keys, then you are making your life very difficult.
 
And, getting back on topic, harmonic minor is enough when clearly we are in C minor..

In a minor key, what are the corresponding modes if you want to think along the same lines as dorian, mixolydian ionian for a major II V I?[/Q] Your point is well taken that thinking in terms of modes doesn't work well for harmonic minor because of the ii7b5. Unless I am mistaken, it does work for melodic minor
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I am now becoming hopelessly befuddled and confused

This is why I am trying to make things appear simple, there is no need, IMO, to make it complicated.

This is my thinking:

If you are in the key of C, a C major scale is good.

If you are in the key of C minor, a scale of C minor is good.

All of the so-called modal stuff is what overcomplicates things.

If you are in C, then a C scale (or blues scale) will work. Use your ears to help make it musical.
 
I don't see that. It is not a Dm chord in the key of D minor with a D minor tonality. It is functioning in the key of C with a C tonality. If, every time you have a IIm7 V7 I progression, you have to think in three separate keys, then you are making your life very difficult.

My use of the term "tonality" denotes whether the chord is major or minor. Perhaps that is the wrong term. When I hear Dm7 in the key of C I hear a minor chord. I don't think of going to the key of D minor.
 
I am going to make a last contribution here quoting Duke Ellington: "If it sounds good it is good."
You are throwing the stone and hide your hand...
Duke is one of my biggest idols. He wrote stuff inspired by his more or less literate band members (and some of them where serious harmony geniuses, like Hamilton or Gonsalves) and the greatest Billy Strayhorn.

He had a habit: after his bunch of arrangers/copyists finished a chart (and you can hear how he refreshed old tunes with new arrangements), he rehearsed the chart and ask the players if they would change any note.
If they would, sod the theory and keep the changes.

Recommended listening: Isfahan
 
My use of the term "tonality" denotes whether the chord is major or minor. Perhaps that is the wrong term. When I hear Dm7 in the key of C I hear a minor chord. I don't think of going to the key of D minor.

Here goes the misunderstanding.
Tone and mode... (translated from Italian)

Tone: C
Mode: minor

This is the main "tonality". Within this context chords cover different functions (mostly three).
If we go from one key to another, we modulate.

So:
C F G7 C (I IV V of C major ) C7 F Bb C7 F (we modulated to F)
F has different harmonic functions; subdominant of C or tonic of F

(something might got lost in translation...)
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,674
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom