Playing the saxophone The Harmonic Minor scale without sharps and flats

In music education we often frame our instruction on the principle of "transfer" which basically means to use something previously learned as a foundation for learning something new. A good example is when teaching students to play the saxophone after one year on clarinet the teacher points out that for the most part, the fingerings of the saxophone are the same as the clarinet fingerings in the upper register.

This applies to learning scales as well. Once the finger pattern of the G scale is learned, the teacher can then use that as the foundation to teach the C scale by pointing out that the first 4 notes of the G scale are the same as the last four notes of the C scale, or that the last four notes of the G scale are the same as the first four notes of the D scale and so on. It helps to simplify things in the mind of the learner much like pointing out that going around the circle of 5ths only one note changes each time. I learned that 45 years ago, and I still think its cool. 😎
 
Last edited:
Melodic minor is dorian with raised 7th.

This is good for the jazz (academic) definition of melodic minor but based on its evolution as outlined by @aldevis, you should also (or instead) think of it as Aeolian (natural minor) with raised 6th and raised 7th

In a classical environment it is of course taught like this, with raised 6th and 7th ascending, but descending reverts to the original aeolian mode.

(Just had my Mr. Pedantic hat on for a minute there)
 
Last edited:
Based on its evolution as outlined by @aldevis, you should also (or instead) think of it as Aeolian (natural minor) with raised 6th and raised 7th

In a classical environment it is of course taught like this, with raised 6th and 7th ascending, but descending reverts to the original aeolian mode.

(Just had my Mr. Pedantic hat on for a minute there)
This is the way that I was thought.
First raise the 7th, then raise the 6th to avoid that exotic minor third.

BUT....

Theory is written after the music that it tries to describe... Until about 1700 minor keys were dorian (Am had F# in tje key signature) and Bach sometimes used the melodic minor up and down....
 
if going backwards round the circle the 7th flats and becomes the 4 of the next key

if going forwards the 4 sharps and becomes the leading tone of the next key

eg in C the B goes to Bb which is the 4 of F (backwards) In C the F sharps to become the leading tone for G
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,674
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom