I fail to see a problem.
That is your prerogative.
I fail to see a problem.
How does that work - the scale describing the note.Like this... Minor modes were originally "Dorian" (Scarlatti Senior) then "Natural" (Scarlatti Junior, Vivaldi, Bach....).
The Harmonic and Melodic scales were a formalized way to describe the leading note occurring on the dominant chord.
How does that work - the scale describing the note.
Melodic minor is dorian with raised 7th.
This is the way that I was thought.Based on its evolution as outlined by @aldevis, you should also (or instead) think of it as Aeolian (natural minor) with raised 6th and raised 7th
In a classical environment it is of course taught like this, with raised 6th and 7th ascending, but descending reverts to the original aeolian mode.
(Just had my Mr. Pedantic hat on for a minute there)
First raise the 7th, then raise the 6th to avoid that exotic minor third.
That's how I've been taught.In other words it was an adaptation of the harmonic minor I presume, as opposed to either aeolian or dorian.
Which one?This week I have mostly been playing a mode of the Neapolitan major scale, sometimes known as the Arabian scale.
So there.
The one that goes WWHHWWW.Which one?
So what chord would that scale be used over?The one that goes WWHHWWW.
We are outside traditional harmony.So what chord would that scale be used over?
We are outside traditional harmony.
It actually would work on any aug7 chord, but it would be offtopic.
I've no idea. I've been playing around with it because it crops up in Villa Lobos' Fantasia for sop sax and orch which I've been working on for the last few weeks. It sounded interesting.So what chord would that scale be used over?
Knew that but didn't think til now that that note is the 7th. Makes it easy to play scales going round the circle of fifths.er much like pointing out that going around the circle of 5ths only one note changes each time
