Playing the saxophone The Harmonic Minor scale without sharps and flats

This has been a very interesting thread, but if one thinks about the title literally you can't write a harmonic minor scale without using at least 1 sharp (A harmonic minor) or 1 sharp and 1 flat (D harmonic minor).
Agreed. My point was that there is an easy way to get
"harmonic minor W H W W H WH H"
into the brain even if sharps and flats had never been heard of.
You can get a simple beginning eartraining excercise too from the scale. Do something on the 3 notes D E F say then repeat by ear on G A Bb finally add a C# D riff to get the whole scale.
 
Agreed. My point was that there is an easy way to get
"harmonic minor W H W W H WH H"
into the brain even if sharps and flats had never been heard of.
You can get a simple beginning eartraining excercise too from the scale. Do something on the 3 notes D E F say then repeat by ear on G A Bb finally add a C# D riff to get the whole scale.
I know. Just being a "smart a**". Everything I know about that I learned from @Targa
 
Agreed. My point was that there is an easy way to get
"harmonic minor W H W W H WH H"
into the brain even if sharps and flats had never been heard of.
You can get a simple beginning eartraining excercise too from the scale. Do something on the 3 notes D E F say then repeat by ear on G A Bb finally add a C# D riff to get the whole scale.
But how do you know what note is a semitone above A if you've never heard of sharps or flats? Or how to finger that note that's in between C and D whose name we're forbidden to mention?
 
First you find the chromatic scale on your instrument by ear or other means. Then you learn to play two notes a tone apart and then you are good to go.
So I'm not allowed to use a fingering chart? Sounds like a lot of trouble compared with learning the conventional way. And I don't think I'd ever have found the recorder fingerings that way, they're a bit too weird.
 
@BigMartin you're a mathematician how many combinations of keys are there to find the scale 'by other means? Is it n!/(n-r)!r! ?
Since you asked, we don't know what r is here so we have to sum them over all r, which amounts to 2^n. Including half-holeing the two right hand fingers and thumb on the recorder, that's 2^11 or 2048 combinations. But the left hand thumb half-holeing is a bit tricky, so you'd have to have a few goes at each combination. And there are even more keys on a sax. Enjoy!

Edit: Actually if you use the half-holes correctly there are 3 possibilities for each (rather than 4) so thats only 3^3 x 2^5 or 864 combinations. A lot more on the sax though.
 
Last edited:
Since you asked, we don't know what r is here so we have to sum them over all r, which amounts to 2^n. Including half-holeing the two right hand fingers and thumb on the recorder, that's 2^11 or 2048 combinations. But the left hand thumb half-holeing is a bit tricky, so you'd have to have a few goes at each combination. And there are even more keys on a sax. Enjoy!

Edit: Actually if you use the half-holes correctly there are 3 possibilities for each (rather than 4) so thats only 3^3 x 2^5 or 864 combinations. A lot more on the sax though.
I was close, it is 50 years since I last had to do it.
 
@BigMartin you're a mathematician how many combinations of keys are there to find the scale 'by other means? Is it n!/(n-r)!r! ?

You wouldn't need to try all the combinations. If you look at what the keys do and apply a bit of common sense you can soon find most of the fingerings for any woodwind instrument. Altissimo excluded - I'm still trying to find anything above altissimo F on my tarogato.
 
Ok but certainly full of Eastern Promise.

The thread is certainly an interesting one and I have noticed in my own improvisation while in this scale, mood/mode my ascending and descending thoughts are different. I am not however a chord reading improviser my thought processes to fingers are too slow therefore my own impro is by ear so I feel it rather than think about it,
I totally relate to this. I have never really been able to play based on Chord Changes & theory which is why I quickly gravitated to the blues, soul, R&B and R&R because all I needed to know was the key of the song. The blues scale was plenty enough with some chromatic passing notes to play at those jams. However at home 6 years ago after I was sidelined by a heart attack and triple bypass and then arthritis in my knees I could no longer hack standing on a tiny riser with cables all around my feet in order to play, let alone dragging myself and my horn there to the clubs to do it. So I started just free improvising at home by ear and inner feelings that my fingers take me too.

Then along came Mary....err, Covid, and there were no gigs for 2 years. I kept up playing at home but got bored by myself and started gardening on our terrace fulltime. Plants and flowers gave me peace of mind, kept my hands busy and beautified our home. However, I suddenly discovered I was getting arthritis in my fingers as well as throwing out my back and neck. Two 3 month periods of PT later I slowed down the gardening and got back into sax although it required relearning a lot of theory that had somehow disappeared into the smoke rings of my aging mind. A mind is a terrible thing to lose so don't age as you get old.
,
Anyway, all the prior years of practice with scales, thirds, chromatic shifts, progessions, repetition pays off by educating your fingers with a mind of their own and like you I find I both follow and direct them as I hear what they feel like doing. I was big into free jazz beginning back in the late 60s but I've never played free so much as freely -- following and directing the stream where it wants to go or where it wants me to lead it. Many times it sounds merely like playing etudes with various runs, repetitions, octave jumps, chromatic shifts, key shifts etc although I don't actually play in a set key or even know what Key i'm playing in a lot of the time because I don't think about that as nobody is playing with me and if any scale or key favors me, it's the chromatic scale. I also like the harmonic minor and this phrygian dominant mixed in with the minor blues because variation adds interest and new ideas.

Now however I'm more attuned to trying to make what I play freely sound like a song or theme with sections that follow lines of thought to create a comprehensive whole, although often I suppose people would say I'm just noodling.

I don't know because I don't have the guts to record myself and listen, out of fear that I'll hate it and give up. I hate the sound of my own voice when talking and I can't sing for **** so IDK....although people at jams used to applaud my solos and even come up to say something afterwards....(too often a hot woman who would say the usual "Oh that was so great. I just love the saxophone" and so you'd go to get a drink and chat her up at the bar and then her husband or b.f. would come back from the can and dash your hopes into broken dreams on the barroom floor...yet again. And probably for the best since I'm very married.

Anyway, all this is to say that while I play freely from my finger memory and ears my mind does react and determine often enough what they are playing to give it form, shape, and direction that is more cohesive as a piece of aural sculpture or painting much like the physical sculptures and silkscreens I created when I was an art major back at the University 65 years ago.

I don't know if any of this makes any sense but it's the only way I have been able to create musical forms with an instrument simply because I lack the mathematical mind to understand, remember, and use formal musical and jazz theory as a basis for playing the sax. I was terrible at math and chemistry and couldn't care less how many protons electrons neutrons and Elons are circling the Teslon if a Zuckerberg atom and the only miles I can fathom are the blind ones that destroyed our lawn when I was 13 and had to mow it. The only periodic table I can remember is the dining table order if meals so all those musical trifecta racing charts are worse than heroglyphics to me.

So whether anyone else would like what I play at home I don't know, but it pleases me enough to keep at it and work towards improving it whatever the hell it is. I wasn't born to be great anyway....and frankly I'm glad because judging by the tragic life stories and early deaths of a greater number of musicians than is actuarially logical it isn't so desirable anyway.
 
Last edited:
Sure seems like an awful lot of complexity and discussion just to avoid learning your scales. Why not just do that? I also see people introducing non-standard terminology and notations - why not just use the ones everyone's been using for generations now?

Honestly, the amount of time some people will spend to avoid doing stuff the regular ordinary way would have gotten them to proficiency by now.

(And yes, I did note that the thread is 6+ years old. Wonder if the OP's learned his scales yet?)
 
Wonder if the OP's learned his scales yet?
Probably not.

I have to admit, when I first started playing, I thought, why do a bunch of rote memorization and playing if I know the formula? I mean, Whole, Whole, Half, etc., which I could apply to any key in real time, and I wouldn't have to memorize anything. Well, I learned very quickly that doesn't work in practice. You have to be able to recall every note in every scale instantly, without any thinking in order to play at any reasonable speed. It has to be in muscle memory. There is no time for mental calculations when you're executing one bebop line after another at 300 BPM. Same goes for chords, circle of 5th, key signatures, even rhythms. They have to be ingrained so no conscious thought is involved.

It's very similar to learning your multiplication tables. Yes, you could do addition to get every answer. But you don't truly know them until you memorize them, no mental math involved.

As an aside, when I saw this thread, I read the OP - no flats or sharps, yet he immediately talks about b3, b7, b9, etc. So he throws his whole premise out the window at the start. What's wrong with flats and sharps? I find that the easiest way to construct scales/chords. Using the major scale as the basis, just flat the 7th for dominant, the 3rd (and possibly 6th) for minor (depending on the type), the 5th for diminished, etc. Applying alterations to major seems like the most direct way to conceptualize, then from that basis, practice until you know them without thinking.
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,662
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom