BigMartin
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 3,814
- Location
- Manchester, UK
Melodic minor (I think)What are D mm and A mm?
Melodic minor (I think)What are D mm and A mm?
That's what I mean by context. Playing and thinking D dorian over Dm does not necessarily put you in D minor.
but this is a bad way to learn modes
Even more offtopic, I find useful practising modes starting from the same root, like:Actually this is the way I learned modes, D dorian is C "starting on" D It's a shortcut and can be useful initially, but as soon as possible I recommend learning the actual musical shape of the scale, ie WHW WWHW and its tonality.
He would recommend D melodic minor over the Bm7b5 and F melodic minor over E7 which is the Ealt scale (like locrian being a mode of major).If the "melodic minor scale" occurs on the V...
Say we are in Am
Bm7b5 E7 Am
- On E7 you can use A melodic minor. It implies E9, though.
- On E7 you can use the scale containing b9 b10(AKA #9) #11 #5. In this case E7 becomes E7alt.
Incidentally it contains the same notes as F minor melodic, but it has no relation with Fminor whatsoever
I don't know at the moment which other Melodic minor he can be referring to, unless it is on ii or on i
I would agree that in a modal song it is.Yes it does if you believe a mode is a scale in its own right, which it is.
This is where you lose me. I have always thought that D dorian was the 2nd mode of C, E phrygian was the 3rd mode of C, F lydian was the 4th mode of C and so on.D Dorian is a mode of D and its tonality is D minor. Yes, you can say the notes are the same as C, but this is a bad way to learn modes because you always refer back to a different key and tonality.
This means when you are actually playing in a mode (as in something like Oye Como Va) you are thinking about C when really you are in D minor (Dorian)
So I teach that as a major scale is WWH WWWH therefore a Dorian is WHW WWHW.
This grounds you in the tonality you are in, not having to refer to some other totally different scale in a different key.
This is the most musical way to think about it.
This is where I get confused. You seem to be saying that the Dm chord in C is not in D minor, but the D dorian mode that fits that chord by adding tones that connect its 1, 3, 5, and 7 is in D minor. That sounds like a contradiction to me. Certainly the Dm chord has a minor sound even when in the key of C major.I don't see that.
It is not a Dm chord in the key of D minor with a D minor tonality. It is functioning in the key of C with a C tonality.
If, every time you have a IIm7 V7 I progression, you have to think in three separate keys, then you are making your life very difficult.
That may be true, but to teach the dorian mode/scale as the major scale from re to re to me is far simpler than to provide the first tone and have the student build it using WHW WWHW.
This is where I get confused. You seem to be saying that the Dm chord in C is not in D minor, but the D dorian mode that fits that chord by adding tones that connect its 1, 3, 5, and 7 is in D minor. That sounds like a contradiction to me. Certainly the Dm chord has a minor sound even when in the key of C major.
You seem to be saying that the Dm chord in C is not in D minor

and here is me trying to get stuck into it 🙂I was heartily sick of theory, particularly chord scale theory.
by the time I got my diploma in jazz sax performance I was heartily sick of theory, particularly chord scale theory.
I am following Bird's counsel and trying to forget it as best I can.
But you've got to know it to forget it 😉and here is me trying to get stuck into it 🙂
Jx
That may be true, but to teach the dorian mode/scale as the major scale from re to re to me is far simpler than to provide the first tone and have the student build it using WHW WWHW.
But, in my opinion, less solid in building a modal concept.
I often use an even more pragmatic way, that somehow keeps the concept of mode: if the mode is A dorian, I state "F is sharp, home is A" and they work it out in a more instinctive way.
The only time I have to remember theory is when I am arranging. Then it becomes very useful.He only said to forget it all when you're on the bandstand.
Quote has been edited. Sharpen the 5th is correct.Another way to get the exotic Ahava Raba/Arabic/Spanish scale. Take a major scale sharpen the 5th and then it's the third mode. Works well on a tin whistle. D major. Start on f# and sharpen the a. I don't say flatten the 6th cos the 6th stays in.
