Playing the saxophone The Harmonic Minor scale without sharps and flats

Egyptian, possibly Moroccan. 😉

Ok but certainly full of Eastern Promise.

The thread is certainly an interesting one and I have noticed in my own improvisation while in this scale, mood/mode my ascending and descending thoughts are different. I am not however a chord reading improviser my thought processes to fingers are too slow therefore my own impro is by ear so I feel it rather than think about it,
 
Egyptian, possibly Moroccan. 😉
Ok but certainly full of Eastern Promise.

This is the reason of my criticism to the way we learn it in schools.
In the appropriate harmonic context, it is not exotic at all.
The first three bars of the bridge of "a night in tunisia" (in particular the second bar, on concert D7b9) is the less Tunisian phrase of the whole tune.

(same goes for Vivaldi, Bach, Mozart...)
 
Taken from Wikipedia quote

"The harmonic minor is also occasionally referred to as the Mohammedan scale[3] as its upper tetrachord corresponds to the Hijaz jins, commonly found in Middle Eastern music. The harmonic minor scale as a whole is called Nahawand-Hijaz[4] in Arabic nomenclature, and as Bûselik Hicaz[5] in Turkish nomenclature. And as an Indian raga it is called Kirwani."

Perhaps @aldevis could throw further light on this, asharmonic minor has always sounded Eastern, exotic oriental to my ear.
 
Perhaps @aldevis could throw further light on this, asharmonic minor has always sounded Eastern, exotic oriental to my ear.

To me it sounds exotic mostly if concentrate on the upper four notes, or if you change the tonic, so it's based around the 5th: A Bb C# D E F G A

However to me this is then a different scale as I don't hold with the idea of modes of a minor.
 
Perhaps @aldevis could throw further light on this, asharmonic minor has always sounded Eastern, exotic oriental to my ear.

Oh dear....
IOTM May 2014: ražnjiči & čevapčiči
I use the harmonic minor with an "oriental" effect. A sound that comes to my ears through my childhood on the border with the Balkans.
In this case we are talking modes, and we can call modes according tho the ethic origin.
Please note that also the "jazz modes" were supposed to be originate in places like Crete (dorian) or Apulia/Calabria (Ionian, the west colonies)
As you can notice, the D Spanish Dominant sounds exotic in my introductory performance. It has the same notes as G harmonic minor. Believe it or not I was fully aware that it sounded exotic oriental.

But in this context I was thinking modes

Since the thread is about the classical use of the harmonic minor, I like to stress:
1- that HM it is not a mode, but the adaptation of the natural scale to the dominant function
2- that is not supposed to be a "free standing" unless you want to use it with exotic effect and turn it into a mode (Giuseppe Verdi used it like this)
3- that when used in the "classical" context, it often has no exotic sound.
I really don't feel like recording an example.

While that Wiki is pretty wrong, since it compares a scale in a tempered system with Middle eastern music where they have different semitones and quarter tones, there is a "Neapolitan" 6th that was used, in a harmonic context that has an exotic sound and has that "arabic" sound (by the way, we tend to call "arabic" scales with a minor third interval or flat 9).
"Neapolitan 6th" indeed adds a b9 to the minor scale, when in the subdominant harmonic function, giving the oriental flavour.
Here is a cadence using it (voicings for RH on the keyboard) triads
|Am (EAC) |Dmb6, omit5 (FBbD)|Am/E(EAC)E(EG#B)| Am
 
Thanks to both @Pete Thomas & @aldevis for their replies.
Back in the days when I thought there might be a magic theoretical basis for improvising over chords I bought Mark Levine's book Jazz Theory, if you have that book p477 to quote just one sentence:-
"One reason the harmonic minor scale is seldom played in its entirety is that it fits no one particular chord." His italics not mine.
Just goes to prove the old axiom there are no wrong notes just poor choices.
 
Just dumped all my impro theory books. Huge bonfire later!
Actually in some specific contexts, they are useful. In particular post 60s jazz.
I felt guilty yesterday while improvising on a Mintzer chart: the chord writing requires exactly the approach that Levine has, because it has been written in that language.

My criticism to that approach (Aebersold, for example) is that while it is pragmatically useful to fill a solo with notes, misleads from the musical function of those notes.

I like both the modal and the "traditional" approach, for different contexts.
Most pre-1959 jazz is very little modal.
 
didn't Bird say something about learning all the theory then forgetting it

ooops but this is about classical and he was a jazzer....ackkkkkk back to the sidelines
He actually had strong Bach-like lines...

I totally subscribe ignoring/forgetting/subverting music theory.
 
What a great discussion. As I am still a novice learning all of this information it is interesting to get the viewpoints of professional players/composers. Working with the information Aebersold provides, I consider the scale/mode that he lists for a given chord type as containing the "building blocks" available to construct an improvised melodic idea over that particular chord. It is left up to my ear and musicianship to make good choices. Without knowledge of those "building blocks", I am just noodling on my instrument.

When I practice those scales and modes along with patterns using those notes, I get those sounds in my "ear" and patterns under my fingers so that when improvising I can "pull up" some of those note choices my ear tells me will work melodically and harmonically.
 
Working with the information Aebersold provides, I consider the scale/mode that he lists for a given chord type as containing the "building blocks" available to construct an improvised melodic idea over that particular chord

He's wrong as well.

(Only aldevis and I are right it seems 🙂 )
 
Thanks to both @Pete Thomas & @aldevis for their replies.
Back in the days when I thought there might be a magic theoretical basis for improvising over chords I bought Mark Levine's book Jazz Theory, if you have that book p477 to quote just one sentence:-
"One reason the harmonic minor scale is seldom played in its entirety is that it fits no one particular chord." His italics not mine.
Just goes to prove the old axiom there are no wrong notes just poor choices.
He recommends 3 different melodic minor scales over minor ii V I. I still need to understand/absorb that one.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,674
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom