Egyptian, possibly Moroccan. 😉
Egyptian, possibly Moroccan. 😉
Egyptian, possibly Moroccan. 😉
Ok but certainly full of Eastern Promise.
Perhaps @aldevis could throw further light on this, asharmonic minor has always sounded Eastern, exotic oriental to my ear.
Perhaps @aldevis could throw further light on this, asharmonic minor has always sounded Eastern, exotic oriental to my ear.



🙁
😱😵
..I am all of these,theres a lot to this sax playing!!!!if you have that book p477 to quote just one sentence:-
"One reason the harmonic minor scale is seldom played in its entirety is that it fits no one particular chord."
Well he's wrong. No scale "fits one particular chord"
But at least there's some Neapolitan mentioned... That's ice-cream right? Let's have an ice-cream and go and play space invaders on the pier.I don't know which thread I understand less, this or 'Will they have any'.
Actually in some specific contexts, they are useful. In particular post 60s jazz.Just dumped all my impro theory books. Huge bonfire later!
He actually had strong Bach-like lines...didn't Bird say something about learning all the theory then forgetting it
ooops but this is about classical and he was a jazzer....ackkkkkk back to the sidelines
Me too (FWIW) but I feel like you have to learn the stuff on quite a deep level before you can forget it in a useful way. There's a big difference between breaking the "rules" and being incapable of applying them. I hope to reach that point some day.I totally subscribe ignoring/forgetting/subverting music theory.
Working with the information Aebersold provides, I consider the scale/mode that he lists for a given chord type as containing the "building blocks" available to construct an improvised melodic idea over that particular chord
He recommends 3 different melodic minor scales over minor ii V I. I still need to understand/absorb that one.Thanks to both @Pete Thomas & @aldevis for their replies.
Back in the days when I thought there might be a magic theoretical basis for improvising over chords I bought Mark Levine's book Jazz Theory, if you have that book p477 to quote just one sentence:-
"One reason the harmonic minor scale is seldom played in its entirety is that it fits no one particular chord." His italics not mine.
Just goes to prove the old axiom there are no wrong notes just poor choices.
