Playing the saxophone Taking a break from lessons?

Thread resuscitation........I'm also having this dilemma at the moment.

Got my sax in December 24 and started lesson in January 25. Weekly for about the first 3 months then fortnightly for three months and now monthly.

My teacher is very good and we get on well and he has really helped me progress but I'm getting frustrated now. Since joining an amateur jazz band in June I have weekly two hour rehearsals plus daily 1-2 hour home practice and really feel that I am developing. The band leader plays also plays sax and gives me help and advice as does the other experienced tenor player. The B/L has offered me coaching too. My reading, timing and musicality has really progressed and I have played five gigs now, soloing in two of them.

Even though I am practicing and learning standards my teacher still wants to work through the 'Abracadabra' book, learning simple songs in a step-by-step approach. We are near the end of it but I don't see the point in learning to play tunes I don't care for; I 'd rather spend the time practicing songs that are in the band's repertoire, and receive general tips and guidance.

Tone work, scales, arpeggios, chords etc I can do myself, and I study music theory every day, being retired gives me plenty of time to indulge in my passion. I am still a novice but I feel more confident and more of a 'player' than a 'learner' now. I turn up to rehearsals and gigs, pick up the horn and play, maybe not that well but I can keep up and feel part of it rather than an outsider trying to play along. I seem to learn best when under pressure and being somewhat of an autodidact and obsessive find just getting on with it works best for me, sink or swim!

I guess its similar to that the stage in learning to drive when you realise that you just driven without thinking, changing gear, speed management, observation, driving smoothness have become natural. Not a Formula One driver but competent enough to be let on the roads with minimal supervision.

I see my teacher in a fortnight, the first time since July so he can asses my 'progress' to date. However I am thinking of suggesting we go to check up lessons, maybe every couple of months just to ensure I'm not developing bad habits and to iron out any issues.

I hope this doesn't sound arrogant after less than a year of learning but I don't feel any benefit from regular lessons anymore and think it's time to fly solo.

Any thoughts most appreciated.
 
It's possible with all that you've been doing that you've progressed more quickly than your teacher had anticipated. There will be a lot of technical detail that you won't have touched yet. You might want say monthly/bi-monthly but with a technical/technique based direction. There is advantage to being 'forced' to play other styles/genres - have you tried the Bach Sonata in Gmin BWV 1020 which is available for sax? The Universal Edition has parts for both tenor and alto.
 
Thread resuscitation........I'm also having this dilemma at the moment.

Got my sax in December 24 and started lesson in January 25. Weekly for about the first 3 months then fortnightly for three months and now monthly.

My teacher is very good and we get on well and he has really helped me progress but I'm getting frustrated now. Since joining an amateur jazz band in June I have weekly two hour rehearsals plus daily 1-2 hour home practice and really feel that I am developing. The band leader plays also plays sax and gives me help and advice as does the other experienced tenor player. The B/L has offered me coaching too. My reading, timing and musicality has really progressed and I have played five gigs now, soloing in two of them.

Even though I am practicing and learning standards my teacher still wants to work through the 'Abracadabra' book, learning simple songs in a step-by-step approach. We are near the end of it but I don't see the point in learning to play tunes I don't care for; I 'd rather spend the time practicing songs that are in the band's repertoire, and receive general tips and guidance.

Tone work, scales, arpeggios, chords etc I can do myself, and I study music theory every day, being retired gives me plenty of time to indulge in my passion. I am still a novice but I feel more confident and more of a 'player' than a 'learner' now. I turn up to rehearsals and gigs, pick up the horn and play, maybe not that well but I can keep up and feel part of it rather than an outsider trying to play along. I seem to learn best when under pressure and being somewhat of an autodidact and obsessive find just getting on with it works best for me, sink or swim!

I guess its similar to that the stage in learning to drive when you realise that you just driven without thinking, changing gear, speed management, observation, driving smoothness have become natural. Not a Formula One driver but competent enough to be let on the roads with minimal supervision.

I see my teacher in a fortnight, the first time since July so he can asses my 'progress' to date. However I am thinking of suggesting we got to check up lessons, maybe every couple of months just to ensure I'm not developing bad habits and to iron out any issues.

I hope this doesn't sound arrogant after less than a year of learning but I don't feel any benefit from regular lessons anymore and think it's time to fly solo.

Any thoughts most appreciated.
Abracadabra, if I remember correctly, is a book with a load of well-known tunes - hence not really reading practice. I think you’d have cleared that standard pretty much anyway.

Bearing in mind that students at music conservatoire’s have weekly lessons I don’t see how you would have outgrown this regular guidance, more that it isn’t focused or tailored well enough To you, or you don’t yet see the significance of what is being said to you now, but can come into focus sometime later.

It’s also possible that the core of your interest / progression is better served by the
β€œCoach whilst you play” approach which you have been doing at band rehearsals.
 
A fair few members of the Cafe are β€œanti” teacher. All I can say is that both my mate and I both nearly became symphony clarinettists, having had lessons for a decade or so. We both ended up swerving at the last minute to sax and both of us have been β€œsell-taught”. Yes, a fair bit translates, but not all. We have taken decades to realise the odd thing that would have made a big difference to our playing and could have been info served by a specialist teacher early on.
 
It’s also possible that the core of your interest / progression is better served by the
β€œCoach whilst you play” approach which you have been doing at band rehearsals.
I seem to do best 'learning on the job' as it were.
I know there's loads more to learn and understand and always will be, but I feel my lessons aren't really benefiting me as much now, particularly since joining the band.
I'll have a chat with my teacher about the next steps. I'm not saying I don't need guidance and input but I think we need to reassess what to concentrate on and frequency.
Thank you.
 
I seem to do best 'learning on the job' as it were.
I know there's loads more to learn and understand and always will be, but I feel my lessons aren't really benefiting me as much now, particularly since joining the band.
I'll have a chat with my teacher about the next steps. I'm not saying I don't need guidance and input but I think we need to reassess what to concentrate on and frequency.
Thank you.
Yes. Also, most teachers have probably come through β€œthe system β€œ of school weekly lessons, then music college etc. It prepares you for β€œeverything β€œ. You probably aren’t interested in a lot of those things, so why not concentrate on the things that you are.
 
First, pedagogically, if what your teacher is doing isn't both challenging and achievable - let alone enjoyable - it's not good.
Then, for now, you have your objectives and if you need coaching, tips & tricks or whatever you should get that...
... Nothing to stop you deciding in the future, you want to change direction, need more structure or whatever. It may well be slower or more work; but no doors are closing.
After all, like me, you are an old hobbyist not a young, up and coming, journeyman or professional. Courses for horses.
 
I've stopped and started lessons over the years and tried different tutors. Only my first tutor didn't impress me. The other 4 were all very different and two were particularly good.

I am currently on a break from lessons but will return in the future.

A discussion with your current tutor will be worthwhile.

Jx
 
The band leader is an interesting chap. South Londoner with a cheeky chappy air, takes the p*** a lot (teases the drummer no end!), banter and so on. An ex pro, older than me, thin as a rake (I thought I was slim!) and plays a mean blues and jazz guitar and alto sax. Rigorous about timing, rhythm and musicality but very friendly and approachable.

He's given me lots of advice, admired my new mpc and told me to do lots of mpc practice to master it and has said he's open to give me coaching where needed. As we know each other now and get on, and tuition would be directly relevant to the music we're playing and that he lives a few miles from me rather than an hour away I may take up this offer.

There's a part of me that feels 'guilty' not continuing with my first teacher as he's has been so helpful and got me going but I think I need a new approach.
 
The band leader is an interesting chap. South Londoner with a cheeky chappy air, takes the p*** a lot (teases the drummer no end!), banter and so on. An ex pro, older than me, thin as a rake (I thought I was slim!) and plays a mean blues and jazz guitar and alto sax. Rigorous about timing, rhythm and musicality but very friendly and approachable.

He's given me lots of advice, admired my new mpc and told me to do lots of mpc practice to master it and has said he's open to give me coaching where needed. As we know each other now and get on, and tuition would be directly relevant to the music we're playing and that he lives a few miles from me rather than an hour away I may take up this offer.

There's a part of me that feels 'guilty' not continuing with my first teacher as he's has been so helpful and got me going but I think I need a new approach.
Your band leader sounds a top bloke, you've definately fallen on your feet with that band by the sound of it, I'd certainly persue some coaching with him rather than flogging on with the other one tbh
 
There's a part of me that feels 'guilty' not continuing with my first teacher as he's has been so helpful and got me going but I think I need a new approach.

I had this same feeling about my first teacher, but it's only natural as you develop your priorities will as well.

I've also moved on from my first teacher (I now take lessons every few weeks and weekly classes at a local community school). Still I try to be mindful and remember "I don't know what I don't know".
 
I have been having fortnightly lessons for a few years with the same teacher.

Yes I'm back working on timing a rhythm. It's better than it was, but needs improving.

As well as teaching me 'stuff' he teaches me how to learn, so it's fun, and that it has a practical use. Playing up down scales like I'm still at school serves little benefit in my real world playing.

My tutor doesn't teach 'by the book', he has his own ideas on what is wrong with music education, and the longer I have had lessons, the more times he appears to be correct.
 
Sometimes teachers, need some time off from students, who do not practice as required, to make it enjoyable, to spend an hour with them.

It might be said, that until you can play, a dozen or more tunes, without having people walk away, covering their ears, as opposed to enjoying your music, you are not yet a player, but hopefully, an eager, diligent beginner/learner.

Some are fortunate, to have only studied with symphony/studio level players.
Set your goals, and they'll help to get there.

As far as scale work, etudes, without rests, and with a metronome, might be fun.
I'll post a few books, soon.
 
Sometimes teachers, need some time off from students, who do not practice as required, to make it enjoyable, to spend an hour with them.
Yes that reminds me of when I did a few private lessons.

I had one student I gave the task of learning to play In The Mood. She went away and came back a week later for the lesson. I said have you learned it then?, and she said no, sorry.

OK I said I'll see you next week instead then as there's nothing to do this week. She was a bit disgruntled.
 
It might be said, that until you can play, a dozen or more tunes, without having people walk away, covering their ears, as opposed to enjoying your music, you are not yet a player, but hopefully, an eager, diligent beginner/learner.
:rofl: Well, I've played that at five gigs now and not had anything thrown at me or provoked a mass exodus, even with my solos :rolleyes:

Seriously, I do feel more like a player rather than beginner now, still very green and a novice but managing, hopefully improving and eager to progress further.

My wife has heard more of my playing than anyone and she said it sounds like I'm playing music now rather than a beginner trying to. Fluid and nuanced were her words, and much quieter!
 
I don't see the point in learning to play tunes I don't care for; I 'd rather spend the time practicing songs that are in the band's repertoire, and receive general tips and guidance.
I don't blame you at all, on that point. Have you mentioned this to your instructor? Perhaps you could bring in the tunes from your band's repertoire, or any other tunes you really like and want to learn, and have him help you work on those? I'd also second the suggestion to learn all you can from that 'right bloke' (forgive me for practicing my British lingo) who is your band leader and willing to help you out. Working with him and that band sounds like a great opportunity.

I say this due to the fact that I think I've learned more on the bandstand than anywhere else. Aside from technical stuff that I practice and work on at home. I did have a few lessons early on and took a couple of jazz improvisation classes (one from John Handy way back when I attended SF State). Otherwise, I'm largely self-taught, for better or worse.
 
I know I'm an outlier here but I've tried a regular teacher twice, once when I was just a beginner and once much later when I'd done a lot of playing. Neither gave me what I wanted, at least the first guy had a rookie and not much to work with so has an excuse, the second one knew my playing and still wasn't able to give me anything useful.

I've learned more by just playing with people. If I'd had one of those, to me mythical, teachers who could have improved my technique while advancing my own approach then maybe I would feel differently but I'm skeptical about finding one who teaches the average Joe and takes them seriously. You are likely to get the standard method and you can get that from a book. Advanced students and advanced teachers are in a different place. I've learned more in open workshops than from an, expensive, hour of one to one.
 
I agree with Jimmymack, I've tried lessons a few times in the (distant) past, and never found them very useful either in a similar vein.
I guess one problem was that I was off in bands very soon after I started, and kind of learned what I needed to know 'in the wild' so to speak. obviously I missed out on a lot of technical stuff and my reading's pretty rubbish ( though I'm having a go at that currently πŸ™‚ )
 
Have you mentioned this to your instructor? Perhaps you could bring in the tunes from your band's repertoire, or any other tunes you really like and want to learn, and have him help you work on those?
He's on holiday so I haven't seen him since the beginning of July (hence all my questions on here :rolleyes:). I mentioned it to him then and he said ok but let's finish Abracadabra (beginners' book) to ensure the foundations are solid.

He's a good responsive teacher and we get on so I'm sure when we next meet in a couple of weeks he'll see my progress and agree to a new approach. Personally I feel with my daily practice, the weekly practice I get with the band and some coaching from the leader, having a check up lesson once a month should do for now.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,289
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom