- Messages
- 1,514
- Location
- Sussex, UK
Thread resuscitation........I'm also having this dilemma at the moment.
Got my sax in December 24 and started lesson in January 25. Weekly for about the first 3 months then fortnightly for three months and now monthly.
My teacher is very good and we get on well and he has really helped me progress but I'm getting frustrated now. Since joining an amateur jazz band in June I have weekly two hour rehearsals plus daily 1-2 hour home practice and really feel that I am developing. The band leader plays also plays sax and gives me help and advice as does the other experienced tenor player. The B/L has offered me coaching too. My reading, timing and musicality has really progressed and I have played five gigs now, soloing in two of them.
Even though I am practicing and learning standards my teacher still wants to work through the 'Abracadabra' book, learning simple songs in a step-by-step approach. We are near the end of it but I don't see the point in learning to play tunes I don't care for; I 'd rather spend the time practicing songs that are in the band's repertoire, and receive general tips and guidance.
Tone work, scales, arpeggios, chords etc I can do myself, and I study music theory every day, being retired gives me plenty of time to indulge in my passion. I am still a novice but I feel more confident and more of a 'player' than a 'learner' now. I turn up to rehearsals and gigs, pick up the horn and play, maybe not that well but I can keep up and feel part of it rather than an outsider trying to play along. I seem to learn best when under pressure and being somewhat of an autodidact and obsessive find just getting on with it works best for me, sink or swim!
I guess its similar to that the stage in learning to drive when you realise that you just driven without thinking, changing gear, speed management, observation, driving smoothness have become natural. Not a Formula One driver but competent enough to be let on the roads with minimal supervision.
I see my teacher in a fortnight, the first time since July so he can asses my 'progress' to date. However I am thinking of suggesting we go to check up lessons, maybe every couple of months just to ensure I'm not developing bad habits and to iron out any issues.
I hope this doesn't sound arrogant after less than a year of learning but I don't feel any benefit from regular lessons anymore and think it's time to fly solo.
Any thoughts most appreciated.
Got my sax in December 24 and started lesson in January 25. Weekly for about the first 3 months then fortnightly for three months and now monthly.
My teacher is very good and we get on well and he has really helped me progress but I'm getting frustrated now. Since joining an amateur jazz band in June I have weekly two hour rehearsals plus daily 1-2 hour home practice and really feel that I am developing. The band leader plays also plays sax and gives me help and advice as does the other experienced tenor player. The B/L has offered me coaching too. My reading, timing and musicality has really progressed and I have played five gigs now, soloing in two of them.
Even though I am practicing and learning standards my teacher still wants to work through the 'Abracadabra' book, learning simple songs in a step-by-step approach. We are near the end of it but I don't see the point in learning to play tunes I don't care for; I 'd rather spend the time practicing songs that are in the band's repertoire, and receive general tips and guidance.
Tone work, scales, arpeggios, chords etc I can do myself, and I study music theory every day, being retired gives me plenty of time to indulge in my passion. I am still a novice but I feel more confident and more of a 'player' than a 'learner' now. I turn up to rehearsals and gigs, pick up the horn and play, maybe not that well but I can keep up and feel part of it rather than an outsider trying to play along. I seem to learn best when under pressure and being somewhat of an autodidact and obsessive find just getting on with it works best for me, sink or swim!
I guess its similar to that the stage in learning to drive when you realise that you just driven without thinking, changing gear, speed management, observation, driving smoothness have become natural. Not a Formula One driver but competent enough to be let on the roads with minimal supervision.
I see my teacher in a fortnight, the first time since July so he can asses my 'progress' to date. However I am thinking of suggesting we go to check up lessons, maybe every couple of months just to ensure I'm not developing bad habits and to iron out any issues.
I hope this doesn't sound arrogant after less than a year of learning but I don't feel any benefit from regular lessons anymore and think it's time to fly solo.
Any thoughts most appreciated.

Well, I've played that at five gigs now and not had anything thrown at me or provoked a mass exodus, even with my solos 