Saxophones Switching from alto to tenor

Well back to Tenors.. having recently got a tenor after a long time without one, I notice picking up the alto again (briefly) how rubbish I sound on the alto after a period of 'doing' tenor !
It's a very long time since I did a 'side by side' comparison with A and T, for me there's no contest as to which one would go in the metal crusher given a one or other final choice 😉
 
Moved the off topic posts about the afterlife and changed thread title to be more specific to the topic of switching from alto to tenor.

Note that we have a poll here (which is still) open I believe):

 
Well back to Tenors.. having recently got a tenor after a long time without one, I notice picking up the alto again (briefly) how rubbish I sound on the alto after a period of 'doing' tenor !
It's a very long time since I did a 'side by side' comparison with A and T, for me there's no contest as to which one would go in the metal crusher given a one or other final choice 😉
I started on alto but got a tenor after three months and haven't really touched the alto since.
I love the alto but once I blew into the tenor I knew that was the one for me.

I'm not good enough to swap between them, and as @Dr George might say I'd end up a dabbler not a doubler. I know they are both saxes and in many ways similar but IMHO they feel quite different and require different approaches. I would rather spend my time becoming competent on the tenor rather than being poor on both.

I was thinking of selling the alto as it's just sitting there unplayed. It's an all gold YAS-25, 1988 model made in Japan, in lovely condition and plays easily but I can't seem to part with it :rolleyes: I thought now I'm in a band it might be useful to be able to play both but we have six altos already and just two, sometimes three, tenors. Maybe one day I'll pick it up again.
 
Well back to Tenors.. having recently got a tenor after a long time without one, I notice picking up the alto again (briefly) how rubbish I sound on the alto after a period of 'doing' tenor !
It's a very long time since I did a 'side by side' comparison with A and T, for me there's no contest as to which one would go in the metal crusher given a one or other final choice 😉
Some people sound better when they go back to alto because they have developed better air support as demanded by tenor - similarly for people trying bari for a while then sounding better when they return to tenor. Of course, if you prefer playing tenor and learn to play it well, then you are golden.

And yes, differences in embouchure can be profound.

And, if a person never sounded good on alto in the first place, then going from tenor to alto may make the unpleasant sound even more apparent.

I just like tenor.
 
One day, you will hear that alto crying out from its case for attention. You call out, "Come to Papa!" It will again feel so good in your hands. The notes ring out so inviting, so sweet, and you'll find it hasn't messed with your tenor chops at all. 😉
If you hear voices crying out from the case, do NOT open the case. I’ve seen those movies - they seldom end well.

Blow it up, incinerate it, drive over it with a tank, drive a stake through it…. but do NOT open the case.
 
Alto being my main, I can't understand why anyone would restrict themselves to alto and tenor.

Baritone is such a fun beast. Soprano is always a challenge but occasionally spot on. If I had the funds I'd be looking for a Bbbass, Eb contra bass and Bbsub contra bass. Two octaves below tenor. Man, that sounds fun.

After the struggle and frustration of soprano, the smaller ones don't appeal. Sopranino and soprillo are not for me.
 
This ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

It was a revelation for me to realize this.
I think it definitely helps to really focus on one. I picked up the alto the other day, all my altissimo was all over the place, intonation a bit wobbly, and I kinda don't really have the repertoire on it. It is a great horn, but I don't sound as much like an alto player on it as the really great alto players. Whereas I think my tenor sound stands up (just need to add the soloing content to match hah).
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,296
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom