Pete, I'd love to have a one to one session with you sometime as I don't think our ideas are that far apart. One doesn't ultimately need to understand or translate the chords/intervals one hears in order to play. I hear an interval and can play it. This to me is being one with your instrument. A singer doesn't need to be visualizing an A Maj7 arpeggio in order to sing it. They only need to hear it in their heads and so do some players. I'm certainly not alone in this and players who have had some years going through conventional playing sometimes get there too. You ultimately don't need to analyze something in order to play what you hear. Learning theory, hearing a wide variety of music, and understanding all aspects of music is beneficial. Playing in various styles gives one an unlimited vocabulary and I certainly advocate ALL types of study and exposure.It’s not about copying Wade, it’s about understanding what is going on.
Just because you study something doesn’t mean that you’re stuck with those notes in that order for the rest of your playing life. If that were the case then a writer could never read a book by someone else for fear of losing their own identity.
Ask any pro past or present, any absolute recognised great, and they will advocate the study of others.
Otherwise, you end up going to the extreme which is - listen to nobody, study no books, and you’ll be terrific.
However if one wishes to be one with their horn and able to play what's in their head, they need to establish a direct ear/head to hands connection. If unable then playing cut and paste or trying to continually "analyze and translate" in order to find their way may be as good as it gets. I don't think either of us advocate a strict diet of "playing the changes" and just developing fast technique to "show off". That certainly was never where Bill Evans and Miles were coming from.
Last edited:
