Playing the saxophone STOP improvising?... so says Jamie...

If you've ever bothered to listen to what I play I think you'll find that it's not "Church table loop splomonge very and pickle doom jdhfi fixation whisk." Why are you prejudging? Do you actually know what and how much I've studied? No, you just throw epifits around like excreta.

If you bother to read the 99% of what's said you'd know that it's about what's taught and that it's not working to deliver players for the end of the first quarter of the 21st century. The creativity exhibited by those player of the 1950/60s I adored. If one is just copying what happened then, where is the creativity of today?

As individuals play whatever makes you happy. If you wish to be a pro today then you may wish to be playing something that's not just copying a single style or players of the past. If the goal is to truly improvise (play whatever you hear... which is NOT just idiotic rambling) then it's a process of developing a ear/head to hand pathway. If you don't know what that is or think it doesn't exist ask Pete or any other competent player who can creatively improvise
Please share some links and I'll have a listen: but I wasn't suggesting that was what you played. I was suggesting your approach, at least you preach it, would result in that.

You talk about as individuals people can play what they like, yet the moment something comes up where people are playing jazz and bebop in a prescribed manner, you jump on it deriding it.

But obviously I'm just blurting out again.....
 
Please share some links and I'll have a listen: but I wasn't suggesting that was what you played. I was suggesting your approach, at least you preach it, would result in that.

You talk about as individuals people can play what they like, yet the moment something comes up where people are playing jazz and bebop in a prescribed manner, you jump on it deriding it.

But obviously I'm just blurting out again.....

Please refresh my memory as I don't recall listening to anyone playing any type of music that I've "derided". My discussions have always been within the context of teaching and specifically about the academic jazz syllabus. I'd be happy to apologize if I've derided anyone's playing. It's one thing to discuss, it's another to be attacking anyone I heard playing.
 
Literally this thread, as an example?
Jazz teaching like Jamie's (and others) is almost like a religious cloister. Not in touch with the public and just perpetuating a creed based on continuing some romantic idea of past jazz glories.

If that's not derision to the approach of playing jazz, I think perhaps we're communicating in two different versions of the English language....
 
Literally this thread, as an example?
Whose playing have I derided? Please be specific as you've said "where people are playing jazz and bebop in a prescribed manner, you jump on it deriding it." Please point me to someone's recording/playing that I've heard and derided. If you can't then you're making either a false assumption or using innuendo to imply that I'm slamming someone's playing that I've heard. I can't recall ever doing that.
 
Whose playing have I derided? Please be specific as you've said "where people are playing jazz and bebop in a prescribed manner, you jump on it deriding it." Please point me to someone's recording/playing that I've heard and derided. If you can't then you're making either a false assumption or using innuendo to imply that I'm slamming someone's playing that I've heard. I can't recall ever doing that.
If you can't see, that's the half the problem. I'm not talking about you responding to someone's specific song or track, but your overall tone when talking about jazz and bebop:-
Jazz teaching like Jamie's (and others) is almost like a religious cloister. Not in touch with the public and just perpetuating a creed based on continuing some romantic idea of past jazz glories.
Wade Cornell:

The term vocabulary seems to always be used to describe a rather limited scope of playing.
Wade Corenell:

Copying licks and using "cut and paste" stye playing may be OK as an introduction
etc
 
Wow, what a discussion in this thread! My 2-5 cts:
- A lot (but not all) Youtube 'educational sax content' is indeed 'clickbait' for sign-up courses
- I've just watched just a couple of Jamie Anderson videos and I'm impressed by how some of his video's explain 'the basics' of saax playing in detail (breathing, embouchure, phrasing, articulation, etc.); So IMHO these videos are not just clickbait but are informative too. Of course, there are many other wonderful YouTube videos on learning to play sax too
- The same applies to one of my favourite YouTube channels: Jeff Antoniak. He's a saxophonist and educator and his videos are aimed at 'musicians' (not just sax players). Of course, there's also a link to the online school where he gives lessons. But somehow, his videos never feel or sound like 'clickbait' . But more of a genuine wish to educate musicians.
- From my foray into learning to play bass guitar, I've realized that I prefer a few 'YouTube educators' to others. I've signed up to a few online bass guitar lessons/forums by one 'educator'' and subscribed to a 'go fund me' page of another. They both publish on YouTube and their content and educational style (and forums and resources) convme that they were the 2 best people who could best help me learn.

Back in the day, I dabbled in 'learning styles'. At one extreme, some people wanted to know the 'theory' first before applying it in practice. At the other extreme, other people just wanted to get started and learn from experience.

My take-away: sax players will continually find the online-, offline-, tutoring- and band- content and -style that best helps them learn and progress. As long as they remain motivated to progress!
 
Yes, those are very early tracks with a guitarist I haven't played with for many decades. If you wish to have examples that are more relevant try the 300 tracks on this site that Pete Thomas is hosting as they are specifically examples of how one can improvise with novel backing tracks that are in a variety of genres. The exercises are specifically for members to have a go at improvising by ear. They can be found at the bottom of this page. If this site's method of counting is somewhat accurate they have been listened to over 200,000 times and hopefully provided members with an alternative way to approach improvisation.


If you can't see, that's the half the problem. I'm not talking about you responding to someone's specific song or track, but your overall tone when talking about jazz and bebop:-



etc
Thank you for recognizing that I have NOT specifically derided anyone's playing/recording. The quotes above are (of course) taken out of context and in most cases there is also a caveat saying something to the effect of: " As individuals play whatever makes you happy." I've attempted to convey what may work better for some players as a means of learning how to play what's in your head. If I've offended, that was not intended. There often needs to be a basis of comparison. That comparison is teaching that vocabulary = jazz from a specific period and a prescribed method of playing the changes and copying that specific style vs. developing one's ability to play a wide range of music as an improvisor by using your ear.

I have no trouble with anyone playing whatever they want and enjoying themselves. The discussion is, and always has been about methods of teaching that direct students on a single path that may not deliver results which enable them to play music that is relevant in contexts outside of a limited style of jazz. This is an opinion shared by others (like Pete Thomas), so not unique. He hosts the mentioned ear improvisation tracks here for that reason.

Making people aware of alternative ways to learn to improvise shouldn't be offensive, however it seems that my enthusiasm and basis of comparison has indeed rubbed some the wrong way and invited a defensive attitude instead of curiosity. That's a shame. Likely I'm the wrong person to advocate for those other methods as I lack the "diplomacy gene" in my makeup. However it doesn't negate that there are other ways in which one can develop their ability to improvise by ear or develop their innate ability to be creative.

Academia holds keys to knowledge of many things that have existed and can broaden one's horizons. However Academia isn't very good at teaching creativity. The attempt to codify teaching improvisation is in my opinion an oxymoron. Knowing academic techniques can be a start point, however it's (IMHO) not a place to stay if you wish to become a creative improvisor.
 
Last edited:
However it doesn't negate that there are other ways in which one can develop their ability to improvise by ear or develop their innate ability to be creative.
For me the ideal interpretation of improvisation includes no knowledge of harmony, or "prior art transcription." It is based on having very capable listening, supreme mastery of the instrument and a creative ability to play melodically with no sheet music, no harmonic structure - nothing. So that it is just an extension of your voice: think something and play it. The constraints of mainstream jazz and its harmony can get in the way of that, which isn't to say that the genre of traditional jazz reliant on chord structure is anything bad, irrelevant or obsolete.
However Academia isn't very good at teaching creativity.
Tell me about it. I did some academia for a couple of years, teaching composition, jazz & pop performance and impro (undergrad and post grad). It was impossible to do anything really creative because you needed to justify assessment based on criteria beyond the subjective. I had to justify it to the board of examiners and (worse) the parents who complained that after paying huge fees their son/daughter didn't get a good grade and were ready to sue the university.
 
Last edited:
Yes, those are very early tracks with a guitarist I haven't played with for many decades. If you wish to have examples that are more relevant try the 300 tracks on this site that Pete Thomas is hosting as they are specifically examples of how one can improvise with novel backing tracks that are in a variety of genres. The exercises are specifically for members to have a go at improvising by ear. They can be found at the bottom of this page. If this site's method of counting is somewhat accurate they have been listened to over 200,000 times and hopefully provided members with an alternative way to approach improvisation.



Thank you for recognizing that I have NOT specifically derided anyone's playing/recording. The quotes above are (of course) taken out of context and in most cases there is also a caveat saying something to the effect of: " As individuals play whatever makes you happy." I've attempted to convey what may work better for some players as a means of learning how to play what's in your head. If I've offended, that was not intended. There often needs to be a basis of comparison. That comparison is teaching that vocabulary = jazz from a specific period and a prescribed method of playing the changes and copying that specific style vs. developing one's ability to play a wide range of music as an improvisor by using your ear.

I have no trouble with anyone playing whatever they want and enjoying themselves. The discussion is, and always has been about methods of teaching that direct students on a single path that may not deliver results which enable them to play music that is relevant in contexts outside of a limited style of jazz. This is an opinion shared by others (like Pete Thomas), so not unique. He hosts the mentioned ear improvisation tracks here for that reason.

Making people aware of alternative ways to learn to improvise shouldn't be offensive, however it seems that my enthusiasm and basis of comparison has indeed rubbed some the wrong way and invited a defensive attitude instead of curiosity. That's a shame. Likely I'm the wrong person to advocate for those other methods as I lack the "diplomacy gene" in my makeup. However it doesn't negate that there are other ways in which one can develop their ability to improvise by ear or develop their innate ability to be creative.

Academia holds keys to knowledge of many things that have existed and can broaden one's horizons. However Academia isn't very good at teaching creativity. The attempt to codify teaching improvisation is in my opinion an oxymoron. Knowing academic techniques can be a start point, however it's (IMHO) not a place to stay if you wish to become a creative improvisor.
I never suggested you did deride anyone's specific playing in a recording: but I maintain that you deride anyone who follows an approach of learning jazz through transcription, learning functional harmony and wanting to sound like mainstream jazz. Of which there are many many people.

Yes, your style of posting about the topic is on the offensive side, frankly, and even after reading this same conversation a number of times you carry on; always trying to follow up with 'well you can play what you want' at the end. Yet, next time this sort of topic appears I know full well what will be your posts.

And I'm not the only one; Pete Effamy also asked the question as to whether you just copy and paste posts.

With regards to the tracks I linked to, well to me, they sound like someone who is just starting out learning a language and might haltingly get through a phrase or two. A lot of scalic playing mostly, with the odd repeated pattern (also usually diatonic). I think perhaps instead of deriding the approach of learning some jazz vocabulary, perhaps spend some time with it and it might open your ears to some more interesting sounds. Just my opinion of course; music is subjective.
 
For me the ideal interpretation of improvisation includes no knowledge of harmony, or "prior art transcription." It is based on having very capable listening, supreme mastery of the instrument and a creative ability to play melodically with no sheet music, no harmonic structure - nothing
I think unfortunately that's a pipe dream: in order to be able to be a master of an instrument, you will inevitably learn musical structure. Perhaps not necessarily sheet music, but an understanding of music structure, harmony, resolution and tension is all required to be a master: they're all needed to be able to craft a true melody.

It applies outside of Western music also; I recall, for example, that in India tabla players are required to fully vocalise the rhythms before even being allowed to touch a drum.
 
Nothing wrong with that though.
Nothing wrong with it, no. But at the same time when someone is criticising an approach to learning music without also being able to demonstrate any of the possibilities and sounds that bring, I fall back to the thinking that it's because they don't understand or can't play that music.

Given the reason for the share of Wade's music was a point about an analogy of talking gobbledegook to music, for me, when I listened back, I hwar the equivalent of monosyllabic talk, or perhaps my own halting phrases in Spanish: "Mas cerveza por favor"
 
You seem to wish me to be defensive. When those early tracks were done I'd just picked up my horn again after a long hiatus. I had been unhappy with my playing and was indeed searching for my ability to better play what was in my head. Playing safely/tentatively isn't the best.

if you wish to make suggestions about what I should study/play them maybe you should listen to things I've played in the last 10 years instead of from 30 years ago? Or are you just trying to be a bit snarky?
 
You seem to wish me to be defensive. When those early tracks were done I'd just picked up my horn again after a long hiatus. I had been unhappy with my playing and was indeed searching for my ability to better play what was in my head. Playing safely/tentatively isn't the best.

if you wish to make suggestions about what I should study/play them maybe you should listen to things I've played in the last 10 years instead of from 30 years ago? Or are you just trying to be a bit snarky?
Please send me the links and I'll happily listen. I've listened to the wikiloops stuff on the site plenty. The same opinion stands.
 
Perhaps not necessarily sheet music, but an understanding of music structure, harmony, resolution and tension is all required to be a master:

But at the same time when someone is criticising an approach to learning music without also being able to demonstrate any of the possibilities and sounds that bring, I fall back to the thinking that it's because they don't understand or can't play that music.
I sometimes think those things have got in my way of being a master so I think best to disagree harmoniously.
 
Nothing wrong with it, no. But at the same time when someone is criticising an approach to learning music without also being able to demonstrate any of the possibilities and sounds that bring, I fall back to the thinking that it's because they don't understand or can't play that music.

Given the reason for the share of Wade's music was a point about an analogy of talking gobbledegook to music, for me, when I listened back, I hwar the equivalent of monosyllabic talk, or perhaps my own halting phrases in Spanish: "Mas cerveza por favor"

So this discussion rest on finding the earliest recorded music of an individual (form 30 years ago) to rag on rather than hearing more recent stuff and using that as a basis of judgement?... PLEASE! We all have earlier times that aren't examples of where we wind up or wish to be. If you wish to critique that's fine, but shouldn't it be relevant? We all have made a journey to get to where we are. Some of us like to pass on where we have made mistakes and concentrate on those points where we have succeeded. Teaching is (or should be) about giving others clues that enable them to get to where they wish to be using techniques that could assist.

The topic is about various ways to achieve the goal of being able to improvise what's in your head. You're welcome to judge whether that's happened, but I don't think I was anywhere near that point 30 years ago. Were You?
 
I sometimes think those things have got in my way of being a master so I think best to disagree harmoniously.
I guess I revert back to my language and communication points earlier, then. For me, music is communication. If it's unintelligible to other people and musicians, would it still be music? If you can do that without having learnt anything from all of the preceding music then fair play to you, but you'd be few and far between. And I don't know of any musician, composer etc that I admire that hasn't studied and built on what went before.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,431
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom