Playing the saxophone STOP improvising?... so says Jamie...

Please send me the links and I'll happily listen. I've listened to the wikiloops stuff on the site plenty. The same opinion stands.

You are more than welcome to your opinion. Fortunately (for me) it's not shared by many as per the large number who have listened to and used the tracks here and the 1.7 + million listens I've had on the wikiloops site. Not your style OK, seems to suit other's ears! Come back and let us know when you have that many people you've entertained.
 
Last edited:
So this discussion rest on finding the earliest recorded music of an individual (form 30 years ago) to rag on rather than hearing more recent stuff and using that as a basis of judgement?... PLEASE! We all have earlier times that aren't examples of where we wind up or wish to be. If you wish to critique that's fine, but shouldn't it be relevant? We all have made a journey to get to where we are. Some of us like to pass on where we have made mistakes and concentrate on those points where we have succeeded. Teaching is (or should be) about giving others clues that enable them to get to where they wish to be using techniques that could assist.

The topic is about various ways to achieve the goal of being able to improvise what's in your head. You're welcome to judge whether that's happened, but I don't think I was anywhere near that point 30 years ago. Were You?
Wade: please share some new stuff and I'll listen. You pointed me at the wiki loops stuff a few posts ago. I listened and hold the same opinion.

My point is that learning from others will widen the sounds available in your head. Children sing nursery rhymes because that's what's in their head. Then they learn more and expand. It doesn't just magically appear in there without hearing sounds first.

You are more than welcome to your opinion. Fortunately (for me) it's not shared by many as per the large number who have listened to and used the tracks here and the 1.7 + million listens on the wikiloops site. Not your style OK, seems to suit other's ears! Come back and let us know when you have that many people you've entertained

We've talked about your tracks on here many times. The interaction on the site here at least is very low. And that doesn't actually besr any impact on your own playing etc.

There were plenty of people saying that they had a poor experience with them whe the topic came up when you tried to derail to SotW totm improvement thread with this stuff.

Anyway, I'm going to place you on ignore now as I don't see any redemption here, and nobody else needs to read arguments. All the best.
 
I guess I revert back to my language and communication points earlier, then. For me, music is communication. If it's unintelligible to other people and musicians, would it still be music? If you can do that without having learnt anything from all of the preceding music then fair play to you, but you'd be few and far between. And I don't know of any musician, composer etc that I admire that hasn't studied and built on what went before.
I think you've made an improper judgement regarding Pete's level of education and his ability to play or teach. You're now bordering on being offensive based on your presumptions. I still don't understand why you have difficulty in accepting that there are other ways to approach/teach becoming capable of playing what you hear. Or has this now deteriorated to where you're just punching wildly due to frustration? Please accept my apology if I've offended you in your choice of music you like to play... it was not the intention. I think you also owe an apology to Pete. If you don't admire what Pete has made here, his teaching, or playing (as you indicate in your presumption), then why be here?
 
Wade: please share some new stuff and I'll listen. You pointed me at the wiki loops stuff a few posts ago. I listened and hold the same opinion.

My point is that learning from others will widen the sounds available in your head. Children sing nursery rhymes because that's what's in their head. Then they learn more and expand. It doesn't just magically appear in there without hearing sounds first.



We've talked about your tracks on here many times. The interaction on the site here at least is very low. And that doesn't actually besr any impact on your own playing etc.

There were plenty of people saying that they had a poor experience with them whe the topic came up when you tried to derail to SotW totm improvement thread with this stuff.

Anyway, I'm going to place you on ignore now as I don't see any redemption here, and nobody else needs to read arguments. All the best.
Pretty difficult to listen if you've pushed the ignore button. Ha! However I'll dig out a few newer tunes for anyone still interested. Must go do some work now so will post later.

As to widening what one hears/listens to... what have I ever said that indicates that one should listen to a narrow selection? Quite the opposite! I grew up listening to 1950/60s jazz and was thoroughly immersed in it and have followed most all other progressions in jazz since. I also listen to a very wide range and play a lot of other styes of music. Do you? I'm the guy saying open your ears. You seem to be still defending a syllabus that defines and restrict improvisation to a very narrow field. Once again: For those of you who wish to just play standards and in a straight ahead jazz genre, have at it and enjoy! For others who are interested in a wider base for improvisation there are other methods.
 
Last edited:
Matt and Wade, please stop arguing in public like an old married couple with a long standing disagreement. It’s annoying and a little embarrassing.

There have been a few points raised in this discussion, though, that I think are interesting. The idea that improvising should be totally original, and that learning phrases and licks and using them in an improvisation subverts that. The idea that the best way to learn to play in a particular style is to imitate and copy that style. The idea that current jazz pedagogy is turning out clones and nothing original.

All of these ideas seem to me to have a germ of truth in them. And conversely, just like all truths that I have met so far, can be subverted to the point of becoming a religion, at which point the mind- and soul-opening qualities of that truth disappear.

One of my favorite mantras from a self help group I was a member of is “Take what you want and leave the rest”. This works well when composing music. And improvising. After all, life itself is a really just a series of improvisations…
 
As promised here's some of the tracks I enjoyed recording this past year. All are improvisations. No sheet music, no chart. Press record and play. If not perfect the first time try again. If it doesn't work by the third time I move on. There is some editing/mixing to try and match the backing. The object is to be "inside" the music contributing and not sitting on top of it. Where melodies are lacking that's played, otherwise backing, harmonies, counterpoint, etc. Note that like the 300 tracks posted on this site these are all originals (with influences?). They are considerably different to playing standards and in various genres. The format is seldom head and then play improvisations. The sax isn't always the lead instrument.
This track is embedded with the friendly permission by the creatives on wikiloops.com
View: https://www.wikiloops.com/backingtrack-jam-285549

This track is embedded with the friendly permission by the creatives on wikiloops.com
View: https://www.wikiloops.com/backingtrack-jam-293640

This track is embedded with the friendly permission by the creatives on wikiloops.com
View: https://www.wikiloops.com/backingtrack-jam-288615
 
Continued... if yo wish:
This track is embedded with the friendly permission by the creatives on wikiloops.com
View: https://www.wikiloops.com/backingtrack-jam-287931

This track is embedded with the friendly permission by the creatives on wikiloops.com
View: https://www.wikiloops.com/backingtrack-jam-294649

This track is embedded with the friendly permission by the creatives on wikiloops.com
View: https://www.wikiloops.com/backingtrack-jam-294207

This track is embedded with the friendly permission by the creatives on wikiloops.com
View: https://www.wikiloops.com/backingtrack-jam-298021

This track is embedded with the friendly permission by the creatives on wikiloops.com
View: https://www.wikiloops.com/backingtrack-jam-283208

Elysian Dreams
Gotcha Groove
Nyah and me
 
As a hobbyist, I only play for my wife and I (and select friends). Mainly slow ballads. The aim of my improv/composition is to complement the ballad, adding melodic lines in the same mood/story. I like to make up new lyrics, too, to match the new music. Compared to all of you I'm not an improviser at all, certainly not worthy of public performance. But I really enjoy sax playing.

The best benefit I have gained from learning sax is I now enjoy listening to music more and more. I believe I can hear much more in the music than before.

The journey for some of us is about enjoying life more, enjoying listening to music more. Maybe many of us forum lurkers have no desire to perform publicly.

The main resource I have used are Jay Metcalf's Better Sax online courses and Dr Wally's courses. I like them because they target adult learners. I can learn at my own pace with zero pressure.

I watch the occasional Jamie video. I find him inventive and non-traditional.
 
Last edited:
I've now been playing saxophone for 52 years. For most of that I've played music that I don't really like. I still do. Tableaux de Provence anyone? (To be fair, it has some nice bits). I still like playing though but I like improvising best. Preferably without those nasty chord changes that one is supposed to adhere to. I've always found it inhibiting and you spend more time worrying about what is "correct" than constructing a decent melodic line. And yes, I know, practice makes it easier. But how much time do you want to put in practising stuff you don't really want to do? Of course, having taught sax for 30 odd years I've had to put some time in doing this stuff for the benefit of the less than 5% of students that actually want to play jazz.

Fortunately, improvisation doesn't just mean jazz. You can improvise in any style you want: folk, classical, baroque, serial, rap, dance, pop, rock, world, free, whatever. They don't all rely on a rigid chord structure that you have navigate your way round.

What you have to play depends on the group of musicians around you and point of the band's existence. You can only be totally free when you're on your own but you can always try to make the best of your situation.

I'm only rambling like this cos "Strictly" is on the tele.

I've given up the mainstream stuff these days and currently play in an improvising orchestra (Free Range Orchestra), a small group offshoot from that, a free improv duo with a drummer (Nutters Corner), a blues band that gigs very infrequently and a ritual humiliation of attempting the classical repertoire with a very good accompanist. It's a long way away from when I started.

Strictly's still going. Pet Shop Boys?! Good grief!
 
I think it boils down to expectation of conformity: if you want to play Bebop then you will be expected to play those lines, using the b9 -#9 - b9 - 1 etc.

Dixieland is very prescriptive too. As is Rock n Roll - there are stock things that are played and in certain ways in many forms or styles of music. Very much so in Baroque music, to use one of Nick’s examples from above.

Other styles of music are less restrictive, possibly.

I’m not sure without looking when the first edition of The C Parker Omnibook came out, but to endorse Wade’s pet peeve, it certainly facilitated lazy teaching when I (and @Pete Thomas) was at college in the ‘80’s.

Having been critical of my former college of music, the fact was that there was a great education there if you sought it out yourself - something I found to be common of most of my peers who attended other conservatoire's at that time.

As a working musician, I’ve come across few that solo in a purely “churned out” way. Let’s not forget that unless you’re playing in a jazz combo (and the equivalent in another style) improvisation is by far not the larger part of what you do on the bandstand.
 
I’m not sure without looking when the first edition of The C Parker Omnibook came out, but to endorse Wade’s pet peeve, it certainly facilitated lazy teaching when I (and @Pete Thomas) was at college in the ‘80’s.
What I wonder, though, is whether the lazy teacher was a result of a typical desire in people to have short cuts.

E.g. - Now with the Omnibook, one can learn all Charlie's solos without even needing to listen to the records!

It's similar thinking that allows products like the Klangbogen, heavy mass screw, airbridge, necks with built in weight sliders etc to have a place in the market. And I see the same with a lot of the online courses, videos and so on. I'm a member of a couple of them, and there are a small number of people who put in the work and a whole lot of people that think purely by signing up and parting with some cash, they will become great players; but haven't progressed an awful lot in the time they are there.... because they aren't putting in the hard hours.

Personally, I had an epiphany with transcription this year - in that it's about playing, not writing stuff down; and the process of drilling in those lines, from listening, working it out, playing it, over and again, is actually FUN and I can feel the effects on my playing hugely.
 
What I wonder, though, is whether the lazy teacher was a result of a typical desire in people to have short cuts.

E.g. - Now with the Omnibook, one can learn all Charlie's solos without even needing to listen to the records!
Yeah absolutely, but I think there was a fair tendency to go in the direction of “there you go, practice that and I’ll see you next year”.
 
Personally, I had an epiphany with transcription this year - in that it's about playing, not writing stuff down; and the process of drilling in those lines, from listening, working it out, playing it, over and again, is actually FUN and I can feel the effects on my playing hugely.
That’s great if it, or anything sees quantifiable gain. It is about every part of the transcription process, the writing down too - as it places a graphic of what you are playing in your memory, which aids sight reading of course.
 
Let’s not forget that people haven’t changed. Times have either facilitated learning or hindered.

In Mozart’s day you could hear the best composers or musicians if you traveled to where they lived - probably in another country.

With the advent of recordings you could listen over and over again. Had the Omnibook been available in 1955 I’m sure it would have sold as many copies if not more than it did when it came out. Why wouldn’t you buy it if you wanted to know what Parker was doing?
 
I was always dismayed at how few of my (classical clarinet) peers listened to the great clarinet soloists playing the repertoire that they were having to learn. Most couldn’t even name any. Lazy? No. Much worse!
 
In Mozart’s day you could hear the best composers or musicians if you traveled to where they lived - probably in another country
... and you'd have to be a member of the aristocracy. I guess most people, at that time, heard music in Church or troubadours or local folk. Teaching for church musicians was, as I understand it, very regimented; and minstrel / folk purely aural.

Than, as now, it depends on who's learning and what they want to achieve. And that's the weirdness in some of these discussions...
... Jamie and the other YouTubers aren't teaching professionals. They're for relatively early stage hobbyists, late beginners and, possibly, weekend warriors. Who cares if the audiences are small; any more than folk, klezmer, etc. That style of jazz playing is, now, a folk tradition; and, seems to me, good for playing alone or with mates doing rock or blues or such.
 
I think all saxophone players should be applauded no matter what style of music they play, and there should be tolerance to other players choices.
I am not a fan of the Kenny G style but what he has done for the saxophone is remarkable, and I would love his bank balance.
Whether you like it or not YouTube learning is here to stay and there is a place for it, there are pros and cons to Jamie's approach but the main thing is you can not watch it if it's not for you.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,431
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom