Playing the saxophone STOP improvising?... so says Jamie...

It’s not about copying Wade, it’s about understanding what is going on.

Just because you study something doesn’t mean that you’re stuck with those notes in that order for the rest of your playing life. If that were the case then a writer could never read a book by someone else for fear of losing their own identity.

Ask any pro past or present, any absolute recognised great, and they will advocate the study of others.

Otherwise, you end up going to the extreme which is - listen to nobody, study no books, and you’ll be terrific.
Pete, I'd love to have a one to one session with you sometime as I don't think our ideas are that far apart. One doesn't ultimately need to understand or translate the chords/intervals one hears in order to play. I hear an interval and can play it. This to me is being one with your instrument. A singer doesn't need to be visualizing an A Maj7 arpeggio in order to sing it. They only need to hear it in their heads and so do some players. I'm certainly not alone in this and players who have had some years going through conventional playing sometimes get there too. You ultimately don't need to analyze something in order to play what you hear. Learning theory, hearing a wide variety of music, and understanding all aspects of music is beneficial. Playing in various styles gives one an unlimited vocabulary and I certainly advocate ALL types of study and exposure.

However if one wishes to be one with their horn and able to play what's in their head, they need to establish a direct ear/head to hands connection. If unable then playing cut and paste or trying to continually "analyze and translate" in order to find their way may be as good as it gets. I don't think either of us advocate a strict diet of "playing the changes" and just developing fast technique to "show off". That certainly was never where Bill Evans and Miles were coming from.
 
Last edited:
No, it can be used in the same way as you would in a literature degree course - improve your vocabulary. Widen it. Learn more.

Certain use of musical vocabulary is very useful, because it works. Players that have gaps in their learning/listening/vocabularly usually sound rather un-directional in their improvisation. “Odd” notes over a chord/harmony are hit at certain points and also within their own structure.

Compositions can be naive, or bad if you like and can be improved. Improvisation is instant composition. It can be bad and can be improved.
The term vocabulary (to continue this unfortunate comparison) is for A Language, not all languages. A Carnatic sax player has a different "vocabulary". A blues player uses his blues vocabulary, same for early jazz, somewhat different for fusion jazz and very different if you're playing with a DJ and need to spin melodies over dance music. I've always advocated for players to have a wide exposure and not be stuck in "A Vocabulary" . There is no one single sax vocabulary unless you're using the term as it's most often used... which is what I've referred to. Argue the point if you must but that is just one of those semantic bogs one gets stuck in.

I do apologize if it seems that I'm ragging on about 1950/60s stuff, but unfortunately that's part of the problem as it's generally what's taught and termed "vocabulary". That "vocabulary" doesn't give you the ability to play what you hear and neither does any other vocabulary. It's pushing yourself in that direction and becoming one with your instrument. How long it takes, or whether any one individual can get there is up to that individual according to their ability and what they practice and strive for. Surprisingly, I don't think there is any one single way to get to that point and have mentioned some alternative practice ideas, which may work for some people. Those practices do not contradict the need for study and to develop oneself as a musician. We have never disagreed about that. Why does the idea of a few ear to hands practices seem so threatening? Would taking classes in African drumming be as threatening, or learning how to play the duduk?
 
Last edited:
If unable then playing cut and paste or trying to continually "analyze and translate" in order to find their way may be as good as it gets. I don't think either of us advocate a strict diet of "playing the changes" and just developing fast technique to "show off"
No, but for many, getting to where you advocate Wade is by studying in the manner we’re talking about.
I too am guided by my ear, having grown up being a Dixie style clarinet player. I learned to improvise by playing with my mate on piano - playing many wrong notes on the way of course, getting to understand what worked and what didn’t.

I also learned a lot about style by transcribing the clarinet part to Kenny Ball’s recording of Midnight in Moscow. This taught me language, inflections, tone, articulation, when and how to play over/around the melody.

I got very entrenched in Dixie and it took a lot of listening and studying to become anything other than this. These days I love playing different music and having to play what is correct for the music rather than impose something upon it that doesn’t fit. The BBC radio show was great for that, 3 guests per week who were usually completely different. That’s my heaven.

I also was most active at college as a classical clarinet player, and almost became an orchestral player.
 
And we’ve bumped into your own mantra again, without anyone advocating it - no one advocates copying and using licks from transcriptions. But seeing how something is constructed is very valuable.

As for all your study not informing your improvisation - that’s impossible.
This whole topic of copying licks is the core of Jamie's video. That's exactly what it's about and that's what I'm referring to.

As for the second part I completely agree. That's also why I disagree with the concept of a single sax vocabulary when there is a whole world of music to include in one's mental library. having lots of music one has been exposed to means that one can think in various moods/modes genres, etc. and spin melodies, harmonies, counterpoint, etc. Hear it...play it. Are we really disagreeing? I don't think so.
 
Well, we struck a nerve again. I've never advocated NOT studying music and have a classical background and read. I've studied theory and composition, yet none of that has assisted me in being able to improvise effectively. Singing and then being able to play what I'd otherwise sing is composition on the fly... Improvisation. My approach has always been to have as broad an exposure to music as possible. Copying licks and using "cut and paste" stye playing may be OK as an introduction, but if one doesn't move beyond that or develop the ability to play what they hear in their heads, then their single mode of playing will always be "cut and paste". We are what we play and practice.

The term vocabulary seems to always be used to describe a rather limited scope of playing, and it's generally referred to in the context of jazz and knowing the academic reverse engineered styles of the 1950/60s. If that's all one wants to play that's OK... your choice. If the topic is about being able to play what one hears, then I certainly disagree that a singular vocabulary and copying is the "one and only true way". And that's all that I've advocated.

It's very sad that people who are involved in music find the need to pick out and twist what one says or are unable to have open minds that conceive of other means of achieving musical expression. There is no "one way" that suits everyone and expressing ideas that could benefit some should be welcomed. Very unfortunate.
The thing you miss, Wade, is to develop ideas and learn to create new ones, you have to learn to hear and "copy paste" first.

It's why nursery rhymes are the entry point to learning music: they have very easy to understand building blocks to create music.

If you take the analogy of language, you learn tyour first one by copying. It's a fundamental part of how humans learn.

Your advocated approach is to eschew all that and just make it up yourself, here's an example of that approqch when applied to language:

"Church table loop splomonge very and pickle doom jdhfi fixation whisk."

Now you may want to write something esoteric, but if you don't understand the language in the first place, you can't go outside the box effectively. It's just nonsense.

But more so than that, and why it's dull conversing with you, is that this has all been said before. But your agenda for anti bebop/anti jazz means you say the same thing every time without taking anything on board. It's akin to listening to Nicola Sturgeon interview, no matter the topic it would end, rightly or wrongly with "and that's why an independent Scotland is needed!"
 
Last edited:
However if one wishes to be one with their horn and able to play what's in their head, they need to establish a direct ear/head to hands connection. If unable then playing cut and paste or trying to continually "analyze and translate" in order to find their way may be as good as it gets. I don't think either of us advocate a strict diet of "playing the changes" and just developing fast technique to "show off". That certainly was never where Bill Evans and Miles were coming from.
So I think this is where you're misunderstanding what's being advocated for. Transcription isn't the process of writing down: it's the process of connecting your ears to your horn, in the way that humans learn: copying. It's how we learn to walk (and why second kids in a family learn that faster), play, talk, eat, dress.

Once you know how to do that, you can then expand.

As for "showing off" which is a constant theme of yours in these discussions, I don't ever see that. I see people who want to play better, and play what's in their head but lacking the technical facility to do so. Learning theory, learning scales and arpeggios and patterns, copying a great player: these are the things that enable that and enable that connection.

But the frequency that mention this aspect always strikes more of bitterness: a common human response to being unable to do something is to deride it.

Furthermore, regarding Miles, he actively went and copied (using that language" Parker. Literally says that in various interviews for biographies. And Rollins, Coltrane et al all did the same. Copying from the records.
 
Last edited:
The thing you miss, Wade, is to develop ideas and learn to create new ones, you have to learn to hear and "copy paste" first.

It's why nursery rhymes are the entry point to learning music: they have very easy to understand building blocks to create music.

If you take the analogy of language, you learn tyour first one by copying. It's a fundamental part of how humans learn.

Your advocated approach is to eschew all that and just make it up yourself, here's an example of that approqch when applied to language:

"Church table loop splomonge very and pickle doom jdhfi fixation whisk."

Now you may want to write something esoteric, but if you don't understand the language in the first place, you can't go outside the box effectively. It's just nonsense.

But more so than that, and why it's dull conversing with you, is that this has all been said before. But your agenda for anti bebop/anti jazz means you say the same thing every time without taking anything on board. It's akin to listening to Nicola Sturgeon interview, no matter the topic it would end, rightly or wrongly with "and that's why an independent Scotland is needed!"

If you've ever bothered to listen to what I play I think you'll find that it's not "Church table loop splomonge very and pickle doom jdhfi fixation whisk." Why are you prejudging? Do you actually know what and how much I've studied? No, you just throw epifits around like excreta.

If you bother to read the 99% of what's said you'd know that it's about what's taught and that it's not working to deliver players for the end of the first quarter of the 21st century. The creativity exhibited by those player of the 1950/60s I adored. If one is just copying what happened then, where is the creativity of today?

As individuals play whatever makes you happy. If you wish to be a pro today then you may wish to be playing something that's not just copying a single style or players of the past. If the goal is to truly improvise (play whatever you hear... which is NOT just idiotic rambling) then it's a process of developing a ear/head to hand pathway. If you don't know what that is or think it doesn't exist ask Pete or any other competent player who can creatively improvise
 
Last edited:
This whole topic of copying licks is the core of Jamie's video. That's exactly what it's about and that's what I'm referring to.

As for the second part I completely agree. That's also why I disagree with the concept of a single sax vocabulary when there is a whole world of music to include in one's mental library. having lots of music one has been exposed to means that one can think in various moods/modes genres, etc. and spin melodies, harmonies, counterpoint, etc. Hear it...play it. Are we really disagreeing? I don't think so.
Confession: not looked at the video.

Have seen him play though and he’s an accomplished player. It’s just one take.
 
So I think this is where you're misunderstanding what's being advocated for. Transcription isn't the process of writing down: it's the process of connecting your ears to your horn, in the way that humans learn: copying. It's how we learn to walk (and why second kids in a family learn that faster), play, talk, eat, dress.

Once you know how to do that, you can then expand.

As for "showing off" which is a constant theme of yours in these discussions, I don't ever see that. I see people who want to play better, and play what's in their head but lacking the technical facility to do so. Learning theory, learning scales and arpeggios and patterns, copying a great player: these are the things that enable that and enable that connection.

But the frequency that mention this aspect always strikes more of bitterness: a common human response to being unable to do something is to deride it.

Once again not reading and just blurting out. From post #30 I quote myself which you somehow (accidentally?) missed:
"If you're copying by listening where you're developing an ear to hand relationship then that's OK/fast. If just developing finger memory for that passage/riff, then it's not likely to contribute much to developing the ability to play what you hear in your head in the short term."

The discussion is about ways to learn to play what's in your head, and I certainly advocate transcribing by being able to play what you hear without any intermediate means (writing or analysis). Analysis is OK for learning constructs, but doesn't assist in developing ear to hand pathways.
 
Stop being a pedant. Just widen your language, develop your own vocabulary- it’s semantics.

I’m advocating that good knowledge is just that, and it’s not a chain around your neck unless you make it so.
I'm once again agreeing with you here and also in a previous (missed?) post of mine that mentioned that Vocabulary can be a matter of semantics. I'm also of the opinion that some teaching has produced players who have put chains on themselves. Go to any bar/club's open night jam session (usually playing "standards") and you'll hear players who sound amazingly similar and distinguish themselves in pecking order by how impressive their technique is. Hopefully they are enjoying themselves, yet it's a cloister and not really reaching out to an audience. Is it valid? Well I guess if one wishes to play in any particular style for their enjoyment then that's OK. Does attempt to communicate emotions, stories, or anything other than technique to an audience? My comments are always about those who wish to become pros. That job is about entertainment and giving something to your listeners regardless of the genre.
 
That job is about entertainment and giving something to your listeners regardless of the genre.
It is. But, perhaps selfishly, I’m in it for me and to “serve” the music. The entertainment part of me (Suzi Quatro) rather than jazz club is just sheer showbiz
 
Regarding vocabulary, I'd like to relate a story. Many years ago I played lead alto in a big band that mostly consisted of jazz players - not great readers, some of them, but all excellent improvisers. One day I was showing off a new diminished lick to my fellow altoist, a fairly well-known jazz player. It consisted of a pattern on major triads, descending by minor thirds - all notes from the diminished scale, but a fairly unique pattern, at least for the diminished scale, that I was kind of proud of. The guy dug it.

Next week at the gig here comes one of his solos, and out comes my lick, properly arranged on a dominant 7th chord. Followed by the same major triad pattern on the major I chord, plus the same pattern a whole step higher (Lydian flavor). He then took his solo out, freely playing this triad pattern in multiple keys in multiple ways.

Two things - a) I got my ass well kicked and b) the same word doesn't mean the same thing to everyone. I hadn't had the idea of using that small pattern in that way, to me it was always part of a diminished pattern. To my friend (RIP Norman) it was a key to a small spaceship.

It NEVER hurts to learn and study what other musicians do, even to the point of slavish imitation. It just shows how diligent you are in your studies, and you will never ever sound like the person you imitate. Mostly because words don't mean exactly the same thing to everyone. Nor do licks or phrases.
 
Ha! typo. should have been "ask" Pete... you, or could be Pete Thomas. You're both very competent players.
Thanks. I’m competent enough to “get away with it”. I’ve always thought/hoped that if someone great like Sanborn had seen me play he’d say - “that was nice, I enjoyed it”.

It’s never gonna be superlatives, but I can cover a lot of ground and hopefully, musically.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,432
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom