Playing the saxophone STOP improvising?... so says Jamie...

It seems that my Private Messages bank is full. I was trying to send the following to Pete Thomas. I also intended to send an apology to mrblackbat (hope I got it right this time).


"Hi Pete,

Many thanks for offering your opinions on the Jamie video.

Two problems I've always had: Lack of diplomacy and dyslexia. Without spellcheck I can't write. I also read words mixed up the way they look to me. I've always read his name as Mrbrickbat... for real! I wasn't trying to be disparaging and thought it was a "cute" name/avatar. Spell check has never helped with words that aren't in the dictionary, and it doesn't help me with reading.

I'm also informed that I'm on "the spectrum". That (supposedly) has something to do with lack of diplomacy. This has never served me well as I lack compassion and the ability to communicate ideas that to me seem reasonable and worthy of consideration.

I have no agenda to sell anything and just express thoughts in a straight forward manner. Unfortunately they have come across as negative challenges, especially since they conflict with the plethora of prescriptive quick fix videos and online teaching that echo a lot of the academic teaching. Your ability to gently give opinions and exert a positive influence is most admirable.

Once again my thanks for stepping in.

Best regards,

Wade"
 
I think it's one of those attention grabbing titles.

What he says is really "stop noodling about aimlessly waiting for inspiration to strike and learn the "musical language" of whatever genre you want to play, so that you have some building blocks to build solos that will grab the audience."

Rhys

There are many improvisers who play solo after solo, lengthy, thoroughly and harmoncially correct, but leave no memorable lines or phrases whatsoever once thery are done. Then there are those who seem to find the exact right lines from being able to make melodic relevance in the spur of the moment, and they really make the improvised parts meaningful and possible to remember. So maybe the difference between "aimless noodling" and really "playing" is the mental ability to form coherent musical lines in relevant combinations? To me - and I assume to most - there is a huge difference between playing f.ex. an arpeggio as just a run back and forth, or making a melody from an arpeggio.

I think its just an extreme version of what he was saying? If you go into an improvised solo just noodling and playing whatever it wont be as good as if you do it more methodically? Like putting a phrase similar to the song your playing or having a little less "on the spot playing" and more "playing the solo as an extension of the song, not a way to show off"

Given what I percieve from many improvisers, my opinion is that there is too much focus on technical and harmonic training and expertise in the education, and too little on melodic and line-coherency ditto. Too many improvisers can line up notes, too few create lines and logical melodies. I'm not always keen on jazz improvising in that aspect.
 
There's a lot of pressure on a solo improviser. The temptation is to show off musical knowledge and technical ability.
The point of an improvised solo imo is to serve the piece and entertain the listener.

We all get lost for ideas and inspiration and end up whizzing up and down occasionally.
On one gig I was completely stumped while playing a very familiar blues. The usual format is to take two choruses. On the second chorus, my mind went blank and I ended up expressing one note for the whole 12 bars. It was positively received by band and audience.
I won't be making a habit of it but it makes the point that something simple and surprising can be as effective as anything else.
We are lucky to play such an expressive instrument. It is able to moan, groan, sigh, sing, bellow and growl.
Don't limit yourself to notes. Shut your brain off and set your imagination free. Bare your soul and tell your story.
 
Given what I percieve from many improvisers, my opinion is that there is too much focus on technical and harmonic training and expertise in the education, and too little on melodic and line-coherency ditto. Too many improvisers can line up notes, too few create lines and logical melodies. I'm not always keen on jazz improvising in that aspect.
Many want to play fast because it’s seen as a pinnacle. Often, they miss the fact that to sound good it’s just the slow stuff but faster - ie it has all the detail still: articulation, ghosting, vibrato, form etc.
It will sound great if you play fast in that way. But the same is true of everything we play. One long note, or a series of repeated notes. The use of all the nuances available to us is the biggest key to making our playing/soloing sound the best it can. Not range or speed.

Harmonic awareness doesn’t mean that you try and get every 3rd and 7th, #9,b9 etc or outline every chord change - it can give you the knowledge that your tasty 3-note figure that you’ve been developing will still fit over the next 3 bars without modifying it, or with nominal change.

It’s a vast subject, and all knowledge is good - but what we choose to say and how we use it is still up to us.
 
I like Jamie Anderson and he is 100 %.

I was brought up with lots of jazz on TV. Many good players, but soo predictable and boring. When it was just too much we tried to see if there was something more entertaining on DDR television. The DDR news was also entertaining. 😉
 
I think it's one of those attention grabbing titles.

What he says is really "stop noodling about aimlessly waiting for inspiration to strike and learn the "musical language" of whatever genre you want to play, so that you have some building blocks to build solos that will grab the audience."

Rhys
I have never had luck transcribing solos as a way to learn how to improvise. First off, it's boring, not creative, and at best I'll memorize some licks from another player, but how is that going to help me sound like me?
 
It’s a pretty time-honoured way of learning the craft, and you’ll hear many many great players advocating it. You learn the language.

When we use spoken or written languages we learn by study. It doesn’t mean that you always have to use (for example) all of Shakespeare’s words in the order he used them. It’s just information. The creativity comes from you.
 
I'm not "exactly" disagreeing as many players who have put in the time eventually make the connection between what they wish to hear and what comes out of their instrument. However if one is spending less time on copying and more on directly trying to play what they wish to hear, then IMHO it's a more direct route. If you're copying by listening where you're developing an ear to hand relationship then that's OK/fast. If just developing finger memory for that passage/riff, then it's not likely to contribute much to developing the ability to play what you hear in your head in the short term.

Two exercises I advocate to try and develop the ear to hands pathway are: 1. playing by ear simple tunes without reference to written music and giving yourself a random start note. 2. a more advanced exercise is to put on the radio to random stations that are NOT likely play music you know and try to play along. This has several benefits:
1. You're intensely listening instead of thinking about the cords, key, or any other structural constructs.
2. In trying to "fit" you must be playing notes directly from your head/ears to your hands without naming notes, visualizing dots or translating. Ears to hands pathway!
3. You're not playing in your comfort zone of a known tune or genre, which broadens your ability to hear other ways/modes of composition.
4. If hearing the logic of the music you'll be able to anticipate where it's going and play along in real time.
5. It's open slather so all aspects of improvisation can come into play e.g. melody (playing along), harmony, counterpoint, rhythmic accents, fills, etc.

I'm also going to disagree with the "vocabulary" argument since playing music can be like being able to speak all languages. If you're limiting yourself to 1950s/60s "vocabulary" then you are indeed limited, even in terms of jazz. The more people we can reach with musical ideas the better... up to a point of hopefully not just pandering to the lowest common denominator. Having a broad knowledge of music in all respects should be a benefit to any aspiring musician.
 
It’s not about copying Wade, it’s about understanding what is going on.

Just because you study something doesn’t mean that you’re stuck with those notes in that order for the rest of your playing life. If that were the case then a writer could never read a book by someone else for fear of losing their own identity.

Ask any pro past or present, any absolute recognised great, and they will advocate the study of others.

Otherwise, you end up going to the extreme which is - listen to nobody, study no books, and you’ll be terrific.
 
then it's not likely to contribute much to developing the ability to play what you hear in your head
It does actually. It helps you hear and understand intervals etc.

And in a proper practice regime, looking at transcriptions would be a relatively small amount of your practice, so you aren’t spending loads of time or in fact wasting it.

You know that Bill Evans and Miles (And many more) discussed the European classical composers. You know that any player from L Armstrong to today studied their peers and players a generation before them.

This is what happens and it will continue to happen. Because it works.

Playing along with the radio - yep, great exercise. But if you don’t study harmony you’ll likely get caught out continually until you study properly.

Study has many facets.
 
I'm not "exactly" disagreeing as many players who have put in the time eventually make the connection between what they wish to hear and what comes out of their instrument. However if one is spending less time on copying and more on directly trying to play what they wish to hear, then IMHO it's a more direct route. If you're copying by listening where you're developing an ear to hand relationship then that's OK/fast. If just developing finger memory for that passage/riff, then it's not likely to contribute much to developing the ability to play what you hear in your head in the short term.

Two exercises I advocate to try and develop the ear to hands pathway are: 1. playing by ear simple tunes without reference to written music and giving yourself a random start note. 2. a more advanced exercise is to put on the radio to random stations that are NOT likely play music you know and try to play along. This has several benefits:
1. You're intensely listening instead of thinking about the cords, key, or any other structural constructs.
2. In trying to "fit" you must be playing notes directly from your head/ears to your hands without naming notes, visualizing dots or translating. Ears to hands pathway!
3. You're not playing in your comfort zone of a known tune or genre, which broadens your ability to hear other ways/modes of composition.
4. If hearing the logic of the music you'll be able to anticipate where it's going and play along in real time.
5. It's open slather so all aspects of improvisation can come into play e.g. melody (playing along), harmony, counterpoint, rhythmic accents, fills, etc.

I'm also going to disagree with the "vocabulary" argument since playing music can be like being able to speak all languages. If you're limiting yourself to 1950s/60s "vocabulary" then you are indeed limited, even in terms of jazz. The more people we can reach with musical ideas the better... up to a point of hopefully not just pandering to the lowest common denominator. Having a broad knowledge of music in all respects should be a benefit to any aspiring musician.
Do you just cut and paste all your posts?

Nobody mentioned Bebop. Studying transcriptions isn’t limited to people who want to play Bebop. If looking at a transcription of another player is detrimental to your “own sound”, then listening to any other player is too - and no one advocates that.
 
I have never had luck transcribing solos as a way to learn how to improvise. First off, it's boring, not creative, and at best I'll memorize some licks from another player, but how is that going to help me sound like me?
I really don't find transcribing boring at all. What's your process? Epiphany with it for me was to stop writing anything down: just leabr everything from the recording, playing with it. Then start to think about where the changes are being outlined and go from there.
 
Do you just cut and paste all your posts?

Nobody mentioned Bebop. Studying transcriptions isn’t limited to people who want to play Bebop. If looking at a transcription of another player is detrimental to your “own sound”, then listening to any other player is too - and no one advocates that.
It's the anti bebop agenda again. Any opportunity to rant on about it, however tenuous, draws the same response. It's boring.
 
I really don't find transcribing boring at all. What's your process? Epiphany with it for me was to stop writing anything down: just leabr everything from the recording, playing with it. Then start to think about where the changes are being outlined and go from there.
Yes, and creativity comes during practice too right, which is what you’re talking about here.

This is along the lines of above:

A mate of mine teaches music at a music college. One student says “I don’t see the point of being taught theory or harmony, I want the excitement of finding out for myself “.

Thoughts on a postcard to someone else please…
 
I have never had luck transcribing solos as a way to learn how to improvise. First off, it's boring, not creative, and at best I'll memorize some licks from another player, but how is that going to help me sound like me?
Boring? You mean hard work. What’s the old adage - 99% perspiration 1% inspiration.

And a muso joke:

Fan to virtuoso: “oh you’re so talented, how come you’re so talented?”

“Practice “

“But you’re really talented “

“No, practice “

… anyway, you get the gist. If you want to improve and continue to do so, it’s hard yards and diligence. If you enjoy the whole lot you’re onto a winner. If you find the slog a bit boring then you’ve probably argued for your limitations.
 
Well, we struck a nerve again. I've never advocated NOT studying music and have a classical background and read. I've studied theory and composition, yet none of that has assisted me in being able to improvise effectively. Singing and then being able to play what I'd otherwise sing is composition on the fly... Improvisation. My approach has always been to have as broad an exposure to music as possible. Copying licks and using "cut and paste" stye playing may be OK as an introduction, but if one doesn't move beyond that or develop the ability to play what they hear in their heads, then their single mode of playing will always be "cut and paste". We are what we play and practice.

The term vocabulary seems to always be used to describe a rather limited scope of playing, and it's generally referred to in the context of jazz and knowing the academic reverse engineered styles of the 1950/60s. If that's all one wants to play that's OK... your choice. If the topic is about being able to play what one hears, then I certainly disagree that a singular vocabulary and copying is the "one and only true way". And that's all that I've advocated.

It's very sad that people who are involved in music find the need to pick out and twist what one says or are unable to have open minds that conceive of other means of achieving musical expression. There is no "one way" that suits everyone and expressing ideas that could benefit some should be welcomed. Very unfortunate.
 
Well, we struck a nerve again. I've never advocated NOT studying music and have a classical background and read. I've studied theory and composition, yet none of that has assisted me in being able to improvise effectively. Singing and then being able to play what I'd otherwise sing is composition on the fly... Improvisation. My approach has always been to have as broad an exposure to music as possible. Copying licks and using "cut and paste" stye playing may be OK as an introduction, but if one doesn't move beyond that or develop the ability to play what they hear in their heads, then their single mode of playing will always be "cut and paste". We are what we play and practice.

The term vocabulary seems to always be used to describe a rather limited scope of playing, and it's generally referred to in the context of jazz and knowing the academic reverse engineered styles of the 1950/60s. If that's all one wants to play that's OK... your choice. If the topic is about being able to play what one hears, then I certainly disagree that a singular vocabulary and copying is the "one and only true way". And that's all that I've advocated.

It's very sad that people who are involved in music find the need to pick out and twist what one says or are unable to have open minds that conceive of other means of achieving musical expression. There is no "one way" that suits everyone and expressing ideas that could benefit some should be welcomed. Very unfortunate.
And we’ve bumped into your own mantra again, without anyone advocating it - no one advocates copying and using licks from transcriptions. But seeing how something is constructed is very valuable.

As for all your study not informing your improvisation - that’s impossible.
 
The term vocabulary seems to always be used to describe a rather limited scope of playing
No, it can be used in the same way as you would in a literature degree course - improve your vocabulary. Widen it. Learn more.

Certain use of musical vocabulary is very useful, because it works. Players that have gaps in their learning/listening/vocabularly usually sound rather un-directional in their improvisation. “Odd” notes over a chord/harmony are hit at certain points and also within their own structure.

Compositions can be naive, or bad if you like and can be improved. Improvisation is instant composition. It can be bad and can be improved.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,432
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom