AdamBradley
Member
- Messages
- 109
Hi all!
Brief background - I've played Oboe and Piano for coming on 10 years now, so picking up alto has been relatively straight forward in that I have breath control, can read music, understand harmony etc.
My current experience turns out to be sorely lacking when it comes to just very basic things, as I have quite a few things I'd like to cover I'm going to number them and if anyone has an answer for just one question (as I'm not expecting people to have time to answer the lot!) I'd be very grateful.
This started out intending to be really short obvious questions but some seemed quite ambiguous so I've included a further description of what/why I'm asking below each question, should anyone want to give a more indepth answer!
Thanks in advance 🙂
Here goes:
1. Where should I be holding the sax, when not playing it?
On the oboe I know where I can grip it to put it together/pull apart, safe in the knowledge I'm not going to bend keys. On the sax I have no idea where's best to hold it. I'm playing Alto.
2. What's the deal with reeds?
Is it generally accepted that the higher the number the 'better'? I'm guessing the higher numbers are harder to blow, but does it 'improve' the sound as much as just provide a different tone? On the oboe the harder reeds tend to thicken and round the sound out, but that's not necessarily what all sax players would want?
I'm renting a sax at the moment, and the shopkeep threw in some Vandoren 2s and 2.5s, but being perfectly honest I can't tell any difference, difficulty or sound produced. I've taken advantage of that shop selling reeds at a quid each, ordered one of each type, ranging in strength just to have a play around, though I'd like to know how most go about picking a suitable reed.
3. The Bb key between B and A, do you use that regularly?
One of the sites with fingering charts I found suggested that was the 'regular' fingering, the other 2 only being used when runs call for it. However I find that diddy Bb key somewhat pointless as just about every other note you're likely to come from requires your fingers down on the A key, it doesn't seem feasible. Do you folk use that and just slide your fingers over a lot or is the fingering with first finger on each hand more common?
4. Are there any books that 'every learning sax player should have'?
Currently I have no sax music. As I'm trying to get used to the fingering and general feel of the instrument I'm mostly playing scales and exercises, then 'playing along' to some Brubeck records and trying to pick out some of Desmonds licks. I've got a bunch of Real books for Piano, I'm pondering transposing a few tunes, but for just plain reading I'm playing oboe music as it has the same range on paper. It's just that Mozart concertos weren't what I had in mind and the 'learn sax' books I've seen so far in shops are mostly geared at complete musical beginners, so would outgrow them quickly.
I've seen Pete Thomas' book linked on this site, I was wondering whether anyone could suggest whether that's right up my street or not, having the brief knowledge of my background I've provided here? I know I might be in for a bit of home-turf bias on that ;}
5. What range is actually possible, officially (and unofficially)?
The fingering chart site I'm currently using is a generic one that covers all saxes and just uses little sidenotes to explain sax specific things. It has notes in what it calls the 'upper altissimo', while another alto-only fingering chart site simply calls it a day at top F. I've been trying the suggested notes for G and above, but I'm not currently consistent enough with anything over Eb to know whether it's me or I'm actually just trying to hit notes that don't exist on Alto.
((6. I have a Buffet Crampon -something- alto. Howarth's of London simply refer to it as an Intermediate sax, I believe it retails for about £750 if that helps anyone identify the model - does anyone have / experience with one of these?
A few things seem really odd so wanted to check if they're normal (f.ex the rod that activates the octave pad on the crook is at an angle, trying to determine if it's designed like that or whether it's received a bash by a previous renter (sax tenant?)))
Thanks again 🙂
Brief background - I've played Oboe and Piano for coming on 10 years now, so picking up alto has been relatively straight forward in that I have breath control, can read music, understand harmony etc.
My current experience turns out to be sorely lacking when it comes to just very basic things, as I have quite a few things I'd like to cover I'm going to number them and if anyone has an answer for just one question (as I'm not expecting people to have time to answer the lot!) I'd be very grateful.
This started out intending to be really short obvious questions but some seemed quite ambiguous so I've included a further description of what/why I'm asking below each question, should anyone want to give a more indepth answer!
Thanks in advance 🙂
Here goes:
1. Where should I be holding the sax, when not playing it?
On the oboe I know where I can grip it to put it together/pull apart, safe in the knowledge I'm not going to bend keys. On the sax I have no idea where's best to hold it. I'm playing Alto.
2. What's the deal with reeds?
Is it generally accepted that the higher the number the 'better'? I'm guessing the higher numbers are harder to blow, but does it 'improve' the sound as much as just provide a different tone? On the oboe the harder reeds tend to thicken and round the sound out, but that's not necessarily what all sax players would want?
I'm renting a sax at the moment, and the shopkeep threw in some Vandoren 2s and 2.5s, but being perfectly honest I can't tell any difference, difficulty or sound produced. I've taken advantage of that shop selling reeds at a quid each, ordered one of each type, ranging in strength just to have a play around, though I'd like to know how most go about picking a suitable reed.
3. The Bb key between B and A, do you use that regularly?
One of the sites with fingering charts I found suggested that was the 'regular' fingering, the other 2 only being used when runs call for it. However I find that diddy Bb key somewhat pointless as just about every other note you're likely to come from requires your fingers down on the A key, it doesn't seem feasible. Do you folk use that and just slide your fingers over a lot or is the fingering with first finger on each hand more common?
4. Are there any books that 'every learning sax player should have'?
Currently I have no sax music. As I'm trying to get used to the fingering and general feel of the instrument I'm mostly playing scales and exercises, then 'playing along' to some Brubeck records and trying to pick out some of Desmonds licks. I've got a bunch of Real books for Piano, I'm pondering transposing a few tunes, but for just plain reading I'm playing oboe music as it has the same range on paper. It's just that Mozart concertos weren't what I had in mind and the 'learn sax' books I've seen so far in shops are mostly geared at complete musical beginners, so would outgrow them quickly.
I've seen Pete Thomas' book linked on this site, I was wondering whether anyone could suggest whether that's right up my street or not, having the brief knowledge of my background I've provided here? I know I might be in for a bit of home-turf bias on that ;}
5. What range is actually possible, officially (and unofficially)?
The fingering chart site I'm currently using is a generic one that covers all saxes and just uses little sidenotes to explain sax specific things. It has notes in what it calls the 'upper altissimo', while another alto-only fingering chart site simply calls it a day at top F. I've been trying the suggested notes for G and above, but I'm not currently consistent enough with anything over Eb to know whether it's me or I'm actually just trying to hit notes that don't exist on Alto.
((6. I have a Buffet Crampon -something- alto. Howarth's of London simply refer to it as an Intermediate sax, I believe it retails for about £750 if that helps anyone identify the model - does anyone have / experience with one of these?
A few things seem really odd so wanted to check if they're normal (f.ex the rod that activates the octave pad on the crook is at an angle, trying to determine if it's designed like that or whether it's received a bash by a previous renter (sax tenant?)))
Thanks again 🙂

