Playing the saxophone Relaxing for Palm Key Notes

cjR

Sax via Horn, Trumpet, Guitar, Bass, Music Tech
Messages
91
Location
London, UK
I'm looking for tips, exercises, or just ideas/notions folks have used in the past in their own playing or with their students to get the feel of a very relaxed embouchure.

I'm a returning Alto player, it's taken a while to get my palm key notes sounding good/ok with a full enough sound. I was making my embouchure too tight for a while (I could see it in a mirror and feel it) - through some combo of full range long tones focussing on the same embouchure all the way from low Bb, overtones and whatever else that's gotten a lot better. The problem is my intonation is off and soon as a get into the high register things get very sharp. From something like +/- 10 cents to + 40/50 cents.

I'm looking for ways to get the feel of playing with a looser/more relaxed embouchure even if it's exaggerated, thinking that might help. Appreciate any advice.
 
The mention of cents and numbers means to me a guitar tuner is being used. Put it away. It'll drive you mad.

It's very easy to get into the habit of squeezing the high notes out. Pushing and straining. Instead think low, while playing high. Use the same embouchure shape you use for subtoning and let them happen. No push. No squeeze. Play them a little quieter too. Blow long tones and see how far you can bend each palm note down.

If your top end, short tube, notes are still sharp, pull out a little.

There's lots of threads on here about tuning the horn. A slight correction at the top may have little effect lower down.

Overblow your long tube notes to match the natural fingering for that note.

Use C1 fingering and overblow to C2 G2 and C3.
 
Palm key pitch bends.
Play a palm key note, let's say Eb, then play palm D (with regular fingerings). Then play palm Eb again, but see if you can bend it down to D and up again. Repeat on the other palmkey tones.
If that works, try a wholetone or even a minor third 🙂
This will do miracles on the fullness of the higher notes.

Forget about tuners, and IMHO forget everything about "loose embouchure", as this is relative.
You can sound great and in tune with a firmer embouchure, and bad with a loose embouchure.
Having said that it of course depends on a good horn that plays in tune and a decent pitch center you are playing on.

Good luck, Guenne
 
Last edited:
I recommend the overtone pitch-matching exercises that (AFAIK) originate with Sigurd Rascher in his 'Top Tones for Saxophones' book (which is really the seminal manual for learning to play in the altissimo).
Other players have re-worked those ideas: David Liebman has written about it, and more recently Ben Wendell who is an extremely good younger player.

I suggest you look here and buy Ben's the 'Path to Altissimo'. Although your question is about palm key intonation, not about altissimo, the technique is one and the same thing. Practising these exercises will help to educate your vocal cavity and embouchure to form the correct environment to allow the sax to play better in tune and with a good focused sound.
I've been playing professionally since 1976 and I still find these exercises invaluable.
 
'Top Tones for Saxophones'
Although he talks about the thesis of changing air speed by voicing which is obviously wrong (see Dr. Mark Watkins' "From the inside out"), there are some very helpful exercises in Ben Britton's pdf "A complete approach to overtones", which can be bought here and is worth much more than 10 Dollars.
 
Wanted to swing by here, there was tons of great advice and I think when I posed the question I hadn't realised how deep the rabbit hole went or how fundamental all this really was. The specific improvement I was seeking actually took a while to come (quite a few months/maybe a year?) but there were some other benefits along the way that kept me on the path.

The main things I adopted or increased my work on:
* Mouthpiece alone work - I do something with the mouthpiece alone every time I practice now, whether it's siren sounds, a few notes, bends, or sat at a piano matching pitches. It's not pretty and it took a while to break my aversion to it but early on I noticed this was a great warmup for other things like pitch bends that I struggled to get going if I didn't do this.
* Pitch Bending - I added some intentional exercises to my routine focussed on keeping my embouchure still and leveraging my throat
* Overtones - I was already doing work on these but I got more focussed, I'm a big fan of the books by Ben Britton and Donald Sinta, mainly because they provide a decent onramp and methodical exercises
* Drones - my previous work with drones had been a lot more like testing myself, play against a drone hear if it's on or off, not really be able to make adjustments, feel bad, move on. Carving out dedicated chunks of time to just playing with a drone, doing scales, intervals, long tones or just trying to make something sound beautiful, has unlocked this in a big way for me now.
 
The specific improvement I was seeking actually took a while to come (quite a few months/maybe a year?) but there were some other benefits along the way that kept me on the path.
Have the improvements been significant?

One thing I should have mentioned earlier is that although we should never blame the gear, before any kind of troubleshooting for intonation it's worth making sure there isn't some very simple technical issue such as key heights or (harder to diagnose) mouthpiece mismatch.
 
Have the improvements been significant?
I guess it's all a bit relative but I feel like I was able to move up a notch in terms of flexibility and control and was able to improve on those problematic notes. There was improvement throughout my whole range too that my teacher noticed and remarked on, a lot of that came before I felt I was able to make real progress on the upper register. If nothing else I've convinced myself of the importance and value of these methods and underlying ideas and will keep them as part of my regular routine.
 
If nothing else I've convinced myself of the importance and value of these methods and underlying ideas and will keep them as part of my regular routine.
That's really good. Bit also, even if there was some less than ideal situation with the horn itself, that's all part of playing and learning the saxophone so you new found flexibility and control is something we all have to strive for anyway.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,315
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom