Fair points @Dr G. I'm afraid my enthusiasm got the better of me and it has proved detrimental. I am going to stick to Tenor Sax and use Ricoh orange box reeds.Let’s please stick to one horn for the discussion so you, and everyone trying to help you, can sort something/anything out. In fact, if you are in the stages of sorting out a setup, it’s best to stick to one horn so you can dial in your embouchure and airstream.
Tenor.
Are your Rico 2 and 2.5 the same age? It is not uncommon for a used/worn 2.5 to be softer than a fresh 2.
I do have a number of older reeds which I got in a couple of sample packs but as I stopped playing for a couple of years I'm not sure how old they are. They are of different makes and include La Voz, Rico, Vandoren Blue ZZ and some others. I also have some 2 strength Plasticovers and I'm not too sure how old they are. They did not perform well for me and so I tried the ordinary Rico ones.
Both the Rico 2.5 and 2 are new and in good condition as far as I can tell. Initially I decided to go with the strength 2 but then found the 2.5 seemed so much easier to play. I felt that I needed less effort to blow them, they sounded fuller, intonation was much better and I felt my mouth was also more relaxed.This was my experience on two occasions yesterday and also today.
I'm puzzled as to why this has been my experience but wonder if the 2 was actually too soft for me and I was expounding a lot of useless effort trying to get them to make a reasonable sound. Could this be the case? I'm not especially fit but I'm not a particularly small man either at just under 6ft with a 46" chest and I suppose I could blow a good deal more air than for example, a beginning child. Whatever, unless there are any good reasons for not doing so, I plan to stick with the Rico 2.5 for the time being.

