Playing the saxophone Reed strength and playing in tune

Let’s please stick to one horn for the discussion so you, and everyone trying to help you, can sort something/anything out. In fact, if you are in the stages of sorting out a setup, it’s best to stick to one horn so you can dial in your embouchure and airstream.

Tenor.

Are your Rico 2 and 2.5 the same age? It is not uncommon for a used/worn 2.5 to be softer than a fresh 2.
Fair points @Dr G. I'm afraid my enthusiasm got the better of me and it has proved detrimental. I am going to stick to Tenor Sax and use Ricoh orange box reeds.

I do have a number of older reeds which I got in a couple of sample packs but as I stopped playing for a couple of years I'm not sure how old they are. They are of different makes and include La Voz, Rico, Vandoren Blue ZZ and some others. I also have some 2 strength Plasticovers and I'm not too sure how old they are. They did not perform well for me and so I tried the ordinary Rico ones.

Both the Rico 2.5 and 2 are new and in good condition as far as I can tell. Initially I decided to go with the strength 2 but then found the 2.5 seemed so much easier to play. I felt that I needed less effort to blow them, they sounded fuller, intonation was much better and I felt my mouth was also more relaxed.This was my experience on two occasions yesterday and also today.

I'm puzzled as to why this has been my experience but wonder if the 2 was actually too soft for me and I was expounding a lot of useless effort trying to get them to make a reasonable sound. Could this be the case? I'm not especially fit but I'm not a particularly small man either at just under 6ft with a 46" chest and I suppose I could blow a good deal more air than for example, a beginning child. Whatever, unless there are any good reasons for not doing so, I plan to stick with the Rico 2.5 for the time being.
 
Fair points @Dr G. I'm afraid my enthusiasm got the better of me and it has proved detrimental. I am going to stick to Tenor Sax and use Ricoh orange box reeds.

I do have a number of older reeds which I got in a couple of sample packs but as I stopped playing for a couple of years I'm not sure how old they are. They are of different makes and include La Voz, Rico, Vandoren Blue ZZ and some others. I also have some 2 strength Plasticovers and I'm not too sure how old they are. They did not perform well for me and so I tried the ordinary Rico ones.

Both the Rico 2.5 and 2 are new and in good condition as far as I can tell. Initially I decided to go with the strength 2 but then found the 2.5 seemed so much easier to play. I felt that I needed less effort to blow them, they sounded fuller, intonation was much better and I felt my mouth was also more relaxed.This was my experience on two occasions yesterday and also today.

I'm puzzled as to why this has been my experience but wonder if the 2 was actually too soft for me and I was expounding a lot of useless effort trying to get them to make a reasonable sound. Could this be the case? I'm not especially fit but I'm not a particularly small man either at just under 6ft with a 46" chest and I suppose I could blow a good deal more air than for example, a beginning child. Whatever, unless there are any good reasons for not doing so, I plan to stick with the Rico 2.5 for the time being.
Sounds good. Don't overthink it. Seriously. If a Rico 2.5 is your favorite reed, then go with it. Commit to something and wring everything you can out of the experience. If/when you hit a wall where you can go no further, check back in.

I know small women that play bari in big bands as well as LARGE men that sound like they are afraid of birthday candles. Air support comes from the abdominal muscles - not the size of your lungs.

Tenor - It's all that matters. Enjoy the path.
 
I’ve since concentrated on my air support more and it is already making a big difference to the sound and intonation of my notes. I’m starting to increase the number of scales I can play in one breath. This seems to have progressed quite quickly so far. I assume this is a perception due to me having largely ignored air supply until now and the change in my approach has made a big difference. I guess I will develop much more slowly from now.

This abdominal breathing makes my big belly more apparent though!
 
Both the Rico 2.5 and 2 are new and in good condition as far as I can tell. Initially I decided to go with the strength 2 but then found the 2.5 seemed so much easier to play. I felt that I needed less effort to blow them, they sounded fuller, intonation was much better and I felt my mouth was also more relaxed.This was my experience on two occasions yesterday and also today.
A decent reed clipper can easily bring that 2.0 up to a 2.5. I bought several new orange box Rico's for my various saxes. Seems the reed quality of my old NOS (new but old stock) Rico's were of better cane material. These new reeds would play fine for about a half hour, then go "soggy" on me.

Next go around, I will seek another brand.
 
A decent reed clipper can easily bring that 2.0 up to a 2.5. I bought several new orange box Rico's for my various saxes. Seems the reed quality of my old NOS (new but old stock) Rico's were of better cane material. These new reeds would play fine for about a half hour, then go "soggy" on me.

Next go around, I will seek another brand.
That's a thought I've never really had. I'd like to have one "just in case" but I doubt that would be very often. I guess not really worth it for me, unless I could pick up a really cheap one that worked well. Do such ones exist?
 
That's a thought I've never really had. I'd like to have one "just in case" but I doubt that would be very often. I guess not really worth it for me, unless I could pick up a really cheap one that worked well. Do such ones exist?
A good one may seem pricey, but think of it as a life long investment. I still have my clarinet reed clipper from the 1970's.
 
I’m sure you’re right but maybe I will look at that later. I feel I need to concentrate on the basics like getting my intonation ( which to be honest, is not the best - I seem to have developed a "sharp" tendency ) sorted first 😀
 
I lost my old tenor reed clipper that I had back in the day, but it was a pretty useful thing tbh. you can of course do the old trick burning a bit off the end of a reed using a coin as a stencil/mask and a cig lighter
 
I don't really have too big a problem with my reeds yet. I can't tell much about them. I do have a batch of Rico 2s that I would probably clip to make them a bit harder but other than that Im not at the stage where I would appreciate enough about nuances to know what I wanted from a reed.

Fun thing though. As I'm currently trying to learn to hear when I am playing eye-wateringly sharp, ( shamefully, at the moment I can tell it's wrong but not whether it's sharp or flat ) I thought I'd ask an AI about it it explained was told I should lower my pitch - which was handy advice 😛 :rofl:
 
In fairness to Chatgpt it went on to suggest a few things I could do with my air supply and my embouchure but honestly I feel it is my ear training I need to work on
 
Fun thing though. As I'm currently trying to learn to hear when I am playing eye-wateringly sharp, ( shamefully, at the moment I can tell it's wrong but not whether it's sharp or flat ) I thought I'd ask an AI about it it explained was told I should lower my pitch - which was handy advice 😛 :rofl:
Until your ears are trained to recognise sharp versus flat, an electronic tuner that indicates such can help you. Recognising where one is tuning wise is an acquired skill. Once you catch on, it will make a huge difference in your sound, indicating you are maturing as a player.

Also, no instrument plays in perfect pitch throughout its range although some come close. Knowing which notes are sharp or flat will help you to make adjustments during play to bring them into tune. This is why an advanced player or pro will be able to make a beginner model sax sound really good.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,296
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom