Playing the saxophone Reed strength and playing in tune

Am I alone in finding that some synthetic reeds (Legere for instance) seem to have different tuning characteristics to cane reeds, even if they have similar resistance ?

Rhys
Yes, but it's not as if all cane reeds were alike in that regard either. And then things vary further with mouthpiece selection and the horn itself. There seem (to me) to be too many variables just to pin it all on reeds.
 
Am I alone in finding that some synthetic reeds (Legere for instance) seem to have different tuning characteristics to cane reeds, even if they have similar resistance ?

Rhys
You are not alone. Especially apparent on clarinet, Legere tends to go flat up high. Also needs coaxing on sax. Just one of many reasons I play cane on most things.
 
You are not alone. Especially apparent on clarinet, Legere tends to go flat up high. Also needs coaxing on sax. Just one of many reasons I play cane on most things.

I have noticed it most on soprano and high up going flat as you say. Not nearly so much on A, T or B, although I have moved back to cane on all saxes now that I have found a really good brand.

Rhys
 
I had to push the MP way hard onto the neck. I thought that I was going to have to sand but it finally went on far enough to be in tune.
Why would you choose not to sand the cork? FWIW, the cork should be a cylinder, not a cone, such that it is not hard to twist it to the proper location.

Don’t tell anyone, but the secret to a long-lived cork that is easy to adjust and good to seal is to impregnate it with paraffin wax. You can still use cork grease periodically, but won’t need it as much.
 
How much does reed strength have to do with playing higher notes in tune?
I think it's a matter of embouchure and the way you play (style, attitude.....).
Don’t tell anyone, but the secret to a long-lived cork that is easy to adjust and good to seal is to impregnate it with paraffin wax. You can still use cork grease periodically, but won’t need it as much.
I use tube corks instead of sheet cork. It's easier to adjust the the mouthpiece with tube corks. You have the same O.D. on the tube cork. A neck cork made out of sheet cork use to follow the taper of the neck instead of the bore of the mouthpiece. With tube corks you have less freedom to change mouthpieces unless you don't change mouthpieces with the same bore diameter. Tube corks should be installed with shellack. I use paraffin as well. But what the cork needs most of all is water. Place the neck cork in water (I use distilled water, living on the country side, my water is good for me but not for brass) over the night.
 
I tried the L&H last evening. It is a Buescher True Tone stencil and by its serial number should be a 1917. I repadded it myself and have had an awful time just getting it to seal. It is also stuffy on some notes, at least compared to the Indiana. I tried it with the long tone exercise and Tuner Ninja. It was worse than I imagined. I have been bringing the Indiana with me on the weekend because I have such difficulty starting low notes on the L&H. I used a vintage Geo M Bundy MP and a Legere American Cut reed. I tuned to middle G and tried it out. It was all over the place some notes dead on other sharp or flat. I did manage to get middle C on by adjusting B but that made both a bit stuffy. I had hoped that it would be good enough to use as my away sax but I am resigned to carrying the Indiana until I finish the other Indiana that I have been working on.

I also tried an Orsi alto stencil that I have here and found that I can't play it anymore. I tried because Hawaii Five 0 is played so much lower on the alto than the tenor and I don't know my really high notes very well or much at all yet. I will bring my Otto Link for it next weekend and try again. I had no trouble with the Indiana alto at home.
 
I think it's a matter of embouchure and the way you play (style, attitude.....).

I use tube corks instead of sheet cork. It's easier to adjust the the mouthpiece with tube corks. You have the same O.D. on the tube cork. A neck cork made out of sheet cork use to follow the taper of the neck instead of the bore of the mouthpiece. With tube corks you have less freedom to change mouthpieces unless you don't change mouthpieces with the same bore diameter. Tube corks should be installed with shellack. I use paraffin as well. But what the cork needs most of all is water. Place the neck cork in water (I use distilled water, living on the country side, my water is good for me but not for brass) over the night.

I use sheet cork and sand it to a cylinder. That ensures a tight fit between cork and neck tube. As long as you have a good result and a cylindrical cork, you’re golden.
 
I use sheet cork and sand it to a cylinder. That ensures a tight fit between cork and neck tube. As long as you have a good result and a cylindrical cork, you’re golden.
Yes, I tried to re-cork with sheet cork as well. Hard. If the O.D. on the neck is 15-17 mm (45-50 mm in on the neck) and the I.D. of a mouthpiece bore is 17 mm a 2,4 mm/3/32" sheet cork is not enough. a 3,2 mm/1/8" cork was too stiff, even if I hammered it slightly and kept I warm. Many times it crackled. But to work with sheet cork when re-corking necks is easier.
 
Not related to corks but last night I managed to hit a high F# twice. Albeit for maybe a second or two and then I would go a little flat. My old Indiana doesn't have a high F# key so I have to use the front F, C F, F# and Eb. I believe that is the combination that ended up working for me. I am hopeful that the stiffer reed that I ordered will make this easier.

In a side note (pun intended), while trying to hit the high F# I made some squeals well above F#. I had no idea that a tenor sax could challenge a pre-teen girl for shrillness. If my dad was still alive he would banish my sax and me to the garage, maybe the pole barn even.
 
Using a 2.5 rico royal, I'm able to go to low B and up to high D and I'm struggling to become comfortable with high E. Low Bb is a little iffy so far. The only way I can get close to high F is when I use a 3 strength. With no F# key on either of my horns, I'm just not there yet.
Along these lines, what about the relationship of the mouthpiece to the reed? Should that play into one's decision? Seems I am always trying the mix and match approach without much consistency.
 
Using a 2.5 rico royal, I'm able to go to low B and up to high D and I'm struggling to become comfortable with high E. Low Bb is a little iffy so far. The only way I can get close to high F is when I use a 3 strength. With no F# key on either of my horns, I'm just not there yet.
Along these lines, what about the relationship of the mouthpiece to the reed? Should that play into one's decision? Seems I am always trying the mix and match approach without much consistency.

β€œAlways playing mix and match”…. Why β€œalways”?

Pick ONE mouthpiece, then mix and match to find what works. Stop there rather than getting another mouthpiece.

It is sad and frustrating to see so many beginners suffering with the same challenges. Pick one mouthpiece that has an acceptable sound, then dial in response and tone with your reed selection. Stop dinking there. Refine your sound through practice rather than gear.

If there exists any doubt about your horn, take it to a tech for a leak check. If you refuse to do that, then simmer in the pot of juices that you created.
 
Got to agree with Dr G. However it's hard to blame newbies as sites like this and others seem to be continually going on about gear. Without advice to the contrary they'll figure that different gear is the panacea.

As Dr G hinted it's possible, and a good idea for beginners to get their act together which any gear that's OK, as there is so much to get under control. After a few years (or more?) when basics are under control and the player has a better idea of what and how they wish to play, then they can look for gear that will slightly assist.
 
If an experienced player can sound great on beginners gear, then what's missing for a beginner isn't gear, it's experience. ie practice.
You can't buy experience. You can sell gear though and make a great living.
Btw I'm selling cork grease that makes you sound great. It looks like ordinary cork grease but has a little magic dust added.
Formerly known as oofle dust. Izzy whizzy let's get busy.
A leak light will show you, it's not you, it's the horn. Experience will show you which screw to turn.
Practice will let you blow through the leak.
 
Good points are being made. In the end there are no magic bullets that will solve all problems. Provided your equipment has no technical problems (an experienced player's help can be useful here to check whether problems are "it" or "you"), I would suggest getting what seems to be your best combination of horn, mouthpiece and reed, and practice. Then more practice, and so on. Unfortunately I have found no shortcut for this. Sadly I have found (despite the old saying), that practice does not make me perfect, but it makes me better than I was before.
 
I got to try out the Legere 2.75 this evening. It was more difficult to start the low notes than with the 2.0 and many of my notes sounded, well the MP sounded like air escaping sometimes instead of a good tone. I could readjust my embrasure and air stream to correct but that would only last so long. I also noticed my mouth muscles getting tired which doesn't happen anymore. I figure to use it for the rest of the week and see if I improve on it. Probably need to build up and let my brain relearn to the new reed.
I tested it with the Ninja Tuner and found that I had more issues hitting several notes either a bit sharp or flat. Palm D without the octave key was no different. I did play high F# multiple times but it will be awhile before I will be able to do it in a song.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway πŸ˜€

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,296
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom