Playing the saxophone Reed strength and playing in tune

Holding a bottom Bb and seeing what you can get is both fun and informative. Batters the reed though.

Some years ago when I was trying some Rascher overtone exercises I seemed to go through reeds much faster.
This is only my finding, but I do overtones quite regularly, I've wondered if it might corrupt the reed, but the Légère I use don't seem to be affected
 
I just wanted to add that since I started using the LAC 2.75 part of the time, my time on it has increased steadily per day. I also was able to play using the Venn 2.0 which I had not been before and this in spite of the crack I caused when I dropped it. I am hoping that using it is making my embrasure stronger. I know that after having a harder reed on and switching back to the LAC 2.0 the low notes are super easy.
 
I am hoping that using it is making my embrasure stronger.
I don’t believe it works like that, I still think it is better to build strength by working on air support with soft reeds rather than struggling to increase reed hardness and pushing yourself (like weight training). Doing that can result in bad habits such as biting too hard.
 
I don’t believe it works like that, I still think it is better to build strength by working on air support with soft reeds rather than struggling to increase reed hardness and pushing yourself (like weight training). Doing that can result in bad habits such as biting too hard.
I don't believe I agree with you. Just from personal experience. Of course I began this experiment to see if a harder reed aided with playing high notes in tune. As a byproduct I now find my embrasure being strengthened. Also from personal experience, I have found that my biting starts from attempting to keep practicing something too long, I assume that is because my embrasure and air support are fatigued.

I am glad that you brought up weight training because it probably does work like that. If you simply keep performing the same routine they same way you will find that you stop making gains. You have to challenge your body a different way like using heavy weights and low reps, continuing to failure, and partial reps. I also hear a lot about bad habits but nobody really explains these in detail, are they actually a 'bad habit' or a way of accomplishing something that produces sub optimal results? It would appear to me that someone who begins to skip practice or reduce practice times because they are no longer receiving the reinforcer of 'improvement' would be a much more deleterious to their playing.

In fact I think that you just helped me come to a realization about scales. I have been practicing them in the same order pretty much every day, start with low Bb and work my way up. I had probably better randomize them to help cement them into my long term memory. Like maybe alternate high and low or start with F or E and alternate like F, low C, G#, A, D, for just a more random pattern.
 
I have been practicing them in the same order pretty much every day, start with low Bb and work my way up. I had probably better randomize them to help cement them into my long term memory. Like maybe alternate high and low or start with F or E and alternate like F, low C, G#, A, D, for just a more random pattern
It is indeed a good idea to add variety to your practice. Starting in the opposite direction, i.e. down rather than up a scale or arpeggio is one approach. Another is to change your next run in the sequence by a fourth or fifth

Quite what that has to do with playing an uncomfortably hard reed is anyone's guess. But as long as you feel you are making progress, perhaps it's all to the good
 
Also from personal experience, I have found that my biting starts from attempting to keep practicing something too long, I assume that is because my embrasure and air support are fatigued.

I also hear a lot about bad habits but nobody really explains these in detail, are they actually a 'bad habit' or a way of accomplishing something that produces sub optimal results?

That’s one good example of a bad habit that occurs when you overpractice.

Please look up β€œembrasure” and determine if that’s what you intend.
 
It is indeed a good idea to add variety to your practice. Starting in the opposite direction, i.e. down rather than up a scale or arpeggio is one approach. Another is to change your next run in the sequence by a fourth or fifth

Quite what that has to do with playing an uncomfortably hard reed is anyone's guess. But as long as you feel you are making progress, perhaps it's all to the good
I don't stick with the stiffer reed that long. As I tire I swap it to the 2.0.
 
170px-200707_Fort_La_Latte_38.JPG

A distinction was made between horizontal and vertical embrasures or loopholes, depending on the orientation of the opening formed in the outside wall.

Maybe this has been my problem all along.
 
I'll have you all know that I made it about 40 minutes on that LAC 2.75 reed tonight. All through chords and then some II-V-I progression in every key that I still don't understand. Then I started to play Autumn Leaves with Yasuhiro Fujii and that is when I realized that I still had the 2.75 reed on. I switched to the 2.0, went though Autumn Leaves and then started on You Are My Sunshine, had to stop and slow it down. Then answered a wrong number, tried playing Marshmallow World with Johnny Ferreira from memory and failed miserably. Tried working on the Bill Baily version of When the Saints Go Marching in with Johnny and was struggling to get the timing right and realized that I was biting and unable to control my Embouchure. At that point I cleaned up my sax, neck, MP, and reed and put them away for the night and got myself a beer. Like Walter Cronkite use to say, "and that's the way it is".
 
Well I found out an interesting thing yesterday. I usually play a number 2 reed on my Tenor ( I can do a 2.5 but it tires me so following advice on here I reverted to 2 ) However, I looked out my Alto as I felt like a change and lo and behold I noticed that I managed quite well with a 2.5 Vandoren Blue on it! Googling has informed me this harder reed on Alto thing is usual.) I also found that a no 2 Legere I had kicking around felt good on the Alto. I believe the Legeres are a little harder than cane so I'm considering getting a no 2 for the Tenor. I can't afford to experiement with Legere but I know they will exchange it for a 1.75 if the 2 is too hard on Tenor.

My only reservation is that I found the Legeres to be really quite an odd slippy feel on my mouth. Is this something that everyone feels but gets used to or should I treat the reed in some way to overcome this feeling? EDIT NB I meant slippy on my lip and not that it was moving around the mouthpiece
 
Well I found out an interesting thing yesterday. I usually play a number 2 reed on my Tenor ( I can do a 2.5 but it tires me so following advice on here I reverted to 2 ) However, I looked out my Alto as I felt like a change and lo and behold I noticed that I managed quite well with a 2.5 Vandoren Blue on it! Googling has informed me this harder reed on Alto thing is usual.)
Reed strength depends on the mouthpiece and the player. It’s not a β€œusual” thing regarding alto vs tenor.

Be aware that a 2 in one brand is not the same stiffness as another brand. There is no industry standard.
 
I tried a Vandoren blue 2.5 strength on my tenor yesterday and it was playing a lot easier than the Rico Orange Box 2 I was using? It felt like I didn't need to blow so hard. This seems counterintuitive. I can play quietly with it and also can still play a full range. Does this make sense at all or am I just making a mistake somewhere?

My other thought is that maybe the manufacturing process for Vandoren branded reeds somehow "suits" me better?

I'm making a time to see my teacher when I get back but it won't be for a little while. I will keep plodding along in meantime but this is really puzzling me.
 
Try more 2s from that box, as well as other 2.5s
Read post #74 out loud.
I always have four Sax/Clarinet reeds ready to play, in a reed holder.

The Vandoren V21 3.5s are stiff, compared to LaVoz MH, Clarinet reeds.

Note to Mrs Quartermaster, please buy masking tape. πŸŽΆπŸ΄β€β˜ οΈπŸŽΆ 🧐

IMG_4865.webp
 
@PiccoloPirate Oops! My mistake and sorry but I'm clearly more confused that usual these days.

To clarify:

I had another look and although I was using a 2.5 on my Tenor it was a Rico Orange one. ( I did use a Vandoren Blue on my Alto ) I guess my experience of the 2.5 in post 74 was with a Vandoren which as you say is stiffer.

But, on the tenor the Ricoh 2.5 still did feel much easier than the Ricoh 2 which I still don't understand.
 
@PiccoloPirate Oops! My mistake and sorry but I'm clearly more confused that usual these days.

To clarify:

I had another look and although I was using a 2.5 on my Tenor it was a Rico Orange one. ( I did use a Vandoren Blue on my Alto ) I guess my experience of the 2.5 in post 74 was with a Vandoren which as you say is stiffer.

But, on the tenor the Ricoh 2.5 still did feel much easier than the Ricoh 2 which I still don't understand.
Let’s please stick to one horn for the discussion so you, and everyone trying to help you, can sort something/anything out. In fact, if you are in the stages of sorting out a setup, it’s best to stick to one horn so you can dial in your embouchure and airstream.

Tenor.

Are your Rico 2 and 2.5 the same age? It is not uncommon for a used/worn 2.5 to be softer than a fresh 2.
 
French cut/filed and American/regular cut reeds can feel and play quite differently.

Back in the day there were American and French facing curves. Then compound curves arrived and now anything goes.

I've never got along with American cut reeds on saxophone or Link mouthpieces either. Maybe the two are related.

All the different reeds from one manufacturer are cut slightly differently to accommodate different facings and embouchures.

It can be a little bewildering. Simplify things by finding something you like and sticking to it. There's enough to learn without continually switching gear.

Remember that it's about the music not the gear. Be musical.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway πŸ˜€

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,300
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom