Playing the saxophone Reed strength and playing in tune

The only way I can get close to high F is when I use a 3 strength
I think getting to the high notes is less about reed strength and more about practice and embouchure development

An exercise that helped me find what is needed in the embouchure is to play Bb3, keep that note running and finger Bb1, all the while keeping the note up at B3*. I find myself tightening some things and loosening others in my gob, but none of that involves biting or looking for a harder reed. You simply believe it's possible and you adjust your embouchure until it is

I don't have trouble hitting altissimo notes on a Legere 2.0, American or Signature, on alto and tenor. When I don't hit an altissimo note, it's because I've lost concentration, not because of hardware



* Other overtone exercises are available, but this is a good one because you already have the overtone in hand. You can then do the same for B, C and C#
 
I got to try out the Legere 2.75 this evening. It was more difficult to start the low notes than with the 2.0 and many of my notes sounded,
This would be a huge step up from a 2

I use a 2.25 Legere, I cannot use a 2.75 it's way too hard for me.

NB: that's from a very experienced player !
 
Last edited:
I got to try out the Legere 2.75 this evening. It was more difficult to start the low notes than with the 2.0 and many of my notes sounded, well the MP sounded like air escaping sometimes instead of a good tone. I could readjust my embrasure and air stream to correct but that would only last so long. I also noticed my mouth muscles getting tired which doesn't happen anymore. I figure to use it for the rest of the week and see if I improve on it.
This is the usual outcome when a reed is too hard. It is a miserable experience and the blood vessel bursting concentration needed to make a reasonable sound detracts from all of the other things you should concentrate on (rhythm, volume, posture, breathing, etc.), which you need to do to play well

I wouldn't keep flogging that horse and I would send the 2.75 back to Legere in exchange for a 2.25
 
Last edited:
I got to try out the Legere 2.75 this evening. It was more difficult to start the low notes than with the 2.0 and many of my notes sounded, well the MP sounded like air escaping sometimes instead of a good tone. I could readjust my embrasure and air stream to correct but that would only last so long. I also noticed my mouth muscles getting tired which doesn't happen anymore. I figure to use it for the rest of the week and see if I improve on it. Probably need to build up and let my brain relearn to the new reed.
I tested it with the Ninja Tuner and found that I had more issues hitting several notes either a bit sharp or flat. Palm D without the octave key was no different. I did play high F# multiple times but it will be awhile before I will be able to do it in a song.
If you find the Legere 2.75 too hard for you try dipping in boiling water for 1second at a time until you get the strength that works best for you
 
If you find the Legere 2.75 too hard for you try dipping in boiling water for 1second at a time until you get the strength that works best for you

And when it gets too soft, write down that number and be sure to stop before then next time.

P.S. and OBTW, you will have just voided any opportunity to exchange that reed for the one you need.

Cane sounds better, but if that doesn’t matter then carry on.
 
P.S. and OBTW, you will have just voided any opportunity to exchange that reed for the one you need.
Absolutely right under normal circumstances. But because of Covid, Legere doesn’t want the old reed back. So you keep the old one in the exchange and can boil it all you want.

I’ve personally found boiling to be barely effective, temporary and random. Only a worthwhile strategy as a last resort, but still very unlikely to result in a significant difference.

Just exchange for a 2.25 or switch to cane.

PS, Hoosier, you put a lot of importance on high F#. It’s the least important note on the horn. Concentrate on getting all the other notes sounding good and in tune. Forget about high F#.
 
And when it gets too soft, write down that number and be sure to stop before then next time.

P.S. and OBTW, you will have just voided any opportunity to exchange that reed for the one you need.

Cane sounds better, but if that doesn’t matter then carry on.
Putting the reeds in boiling water to get it right FOR ME works and it serves little point to denegrate those who proffer advice or helpful suggestions to others
 
I am gonna give the 2.75 a few days for a fair chance. Otherwise how will I know if a stiffer reed is right for me. If that fails I will try the boiling water to see if there is an improvement. I still have two 2.0 LAC reeds so I am not going to miss any practice. Next week is training in Atlanta and I am not taking a sax, only a ukulele, my harmonicas and maybe try learning to sing a little using solfege. Perhaps 5 days away from the sax will do me good.
 
PS, Hoosier, you put a lot of importance on high F#. It’s the least important note on the horn. Concentrate on getting all the other notes sounding good and in tune. Forget about high F#.
I try to play with Johnny Ferreira and he uses high F# sometimes. I tend to stay an octave below but I do want to get up there with ease someday. Since I am a pretty slow learner I figure that I should probably start sooner rather than later. That's how I learned to play other notes that were hard for me like anything using a pinky key or just getting the low notes like D, C#, C, B, and Bb to start (with the LAC 2.0 I can start them every time now). I remember not being able to play D with any constancy and it wasn't that long ago.
 
Putting the reeds in boiling water to get it right FOR ME works and it serves little point to denegrate those who proffer advice or helpful suggestions to others
No denigration, B’boy. It is a caveat to others that may follow your advice. If it works for you, then celebrate. Face it, tho’, it’s a crapshoot to get it β€œjust right”. My profession is structural materials, so I get twitchy when I see such types of advice tossed loosely about. I’ve been playing saxophones for 50+ years, so I can appreciate a good sound that cane delivers. For me, IMNSHO.
 
I try to play with Johnny Ferreira and he uses high F# sometimes. I tend to stay an octave below but I do want to get up there with ease someday. Since I am a pretty slow learner I figure that I should probably start sooner rather than later. That's how I learned to play other notes that were hard for me like anything using a pinky key or just getting the low notes like D, C#, C, B, and Bb to start (with the LAC 2.0 I can start them every time now). I remember not being able to play D with any constancy and it wasn't that long ago.
I find that students have more success gradually extending range. Rather than attempting the extremes before you have a solid foundation, learn the middle range really well, then extend your range gradually. That way it's effortIess. A beginning mountain climber wouldn't attempt Everest. They would work up to it gradually. So I totally disagree with the start sooner than later approach. You're only setting yourself up to fail. I think most teachers feel the same.

Using extremely soft reeds for the low register is the perfect example. That just tells me you extended your range prematurely.
 
I've often wondered how Junior Walker generated his high notes. Is there a resource out there about him, or is your information word of mouth @thomsax?
Junior was a brave man. It needs lots of guts to finger low Bb and just " busted" out in the high altissimo. Tim Price (rip) did an interview with Jr Walker. Just before Walker passed away. Andrew Clark did several depth look in the Junior Walker style. Andrew is very good at playing in the altissimo range. He started to take classes in classical saxophone at Berkeley but graduated as Rock & Roll musician and music teacher.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway πŸ˜€

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,300
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom