Saxophones Recommendations for first Baritone

And that's the source of the 'different materials = wear" theory?
I think my first response would have been "So what about monel valves then?"
Weighing in as a mechanical engineer with several decades experience designing moving mechanisms:

At the microscopic level, surface wear is a combination of asperities bumping against each other and knocking each other off, and adhesion of the surfaces of two parts to each other that are experiencing relative motion and contact pressure.

The purpose of lubrication is to separate the two surfaces ever so slightly so there is reduced contact. At the speeds of motion in a saxophone (very very low) there's no way to generate the kind of dynamic lubricant film we see in journal bearings. Basically you're hoping to fill the valleys on each surface with a liquid that'll more or less stay there and hopefully provide some separation between most of the surfaces in question. But there's absolutely no way to avoid direct microscopic surface contact between the two parts in question.

So, if you've got parts in direct contact with each other, even though there is some lube there, what is the mechanism of wear? It has to do with adhesion at the top layer of molecules. And it turns out that this adhesion occurs most easily between materials of the same surface hardness and surface energy. For best wear resistance when lubrication is iffy and speeds too low to develop a boundary layer, DISSIMILAR materials should be used. This, for example, is why steel shafts almost always run in brass or bronze bushings. This is why you CANNOT use aluminum screws into aluminum parts.

Pivots on saxophones are, in fact, designed with a very good combination of materials - brass and plain carbon steel. If the pivots on point screw joints are properly designed, the axial positioning of the key rod should be done by the angled points of the pivot screws, not the faces of the key rod and post. For axle type keys, yes the axial position is governed by the ends of the tubes and post faces, but the axial forces on a saxophone are very very small. I suppose ideally each key tube should have an enlarged end with a little steel washer, but that's theoretical, not practical.
 
Todays options - what do people think?

Nearly new? G4M Rosedale Rosedale Baritone Saxophone | eBay

B&S keikworth

New Zetland now in stock at Headwinds £1400
Well, I'd sure take a Keilwerth over a new mystery Far Eastern, myself.
 
Todays options - what do people think?

Nearly new? G4M Rosedale Rosedale Baritone Saxophone | eBay

B&S keikworth

New Zetland now in stock at Headwinds £1400
Sorry, edited my post as after careful re-read of the ebay ad, my post was not helpful.
 
Last edited:
So, if you've got parts in direct contact with each other, even though there is some lube there, what is the mechanism of wear? It has to do with adhesion at the top layer of molecules. And it turns out that this adhesion occurs most easily between materials of the same surface hardness and surface energy. For best wear resistance when lubrication is iffy and speeds too low to develop a boundary layer, DISSIMILAR materials should be used. This, for example, is why steel shafts almost always run in brass or bronze bushings. This is why you CANNOT use aluminum screws into aluminum parts.

Pivots on saxophones are, in fact, designed with a very good combination of materials - brass and plain carbon steel. If the pivots on point screw joints are properly designed, the axial positioning of the key rod should be done by the angled points of the pivot screws, not the faces of the key rod and post. For axle type keys, yes the axial position is governed by the ends of the tubes and post faces, but the axial forces on a saxophone are very very small. I suppose ideally each key tube should have an enlarged end with a little steel washer, but that's theoretical, not practical.
Indeed - hence my pointed question about monel valves.
The practice of using dissimilar metals has been around for years - though the East German horn builders bucked the trend by using a nickel silver alloy for the rod screws.
Sure, they didn't suffer from rusting but they wore at a higher rate - and there were other problems associate with using a material that is weaker than steel.

I'm less worried about metal-to-metal contact at the key barrel end than I am about the ingress of dirt and grit.
Because a sax has an 'open' system of lubrication it's always going to be susceptible to particles getting into the mix. Plenty of machines use such systems but tend to rely on a 'lost oil' system of lubrication - which basically means flushing the mechanism with oil on a regular basis...and to hell with the mess. An old steam engine is a good example of this. Not really a practical proposition for a horn.
Sacrificial bushings (PTFE etc.) would work well, but in order to avoid the faff of dealing with dozens of tiny washers you'd have to build them in to the mechanism in some fashion.
 
Todays options - what do people think?

Nearly new? G4M Rosedale Rosedale Baritone Saxophone | eBay

B&S keikworth

New Zetland now in stock at Headwinds £1400
All worth trying, none worth buying blind. Headwind's service is brilliant and they have a huge selection of used and new mouthpieces to try if that's something you need also.
 
Well, I'd sure take a Keilwerth over a new mystery Far Eastern, myself.
I would if it was actually a Keilwerth. This one is not actually a Keilwerth. It's a Schenkelaars, which 'may' have some Keilwerth components. I wouldn't pay anything like the asking price. A new, warranted sax, from an established shop with a really good reputation, where you can try before you buy, is far more likely to be a better bet, whatever it's country of origin.
 
I would if it was actually a Keilwerth. This one is not actually a Keilwerth. It's a Schenkelaars, which 'may' have some Keilwerth components. I wouldn't pay anything like the asking price. A new, warranted sax, from an established shop with a really good reputation, where you can try before you buy, is far more likely to be a better bet, whatever it's country of origin.
Ahem...it 'IS' a B&S which 'does' have Keilwerth parts and was made for Schenkelaars, as per the description. As for price, I could have bought a brand new warranted Yamaha from an established shop for roughly the same price as the Silversonic in my avatar....
 
I think that brands/manufacturer cooperate when it came to baritone saxes. They share the same neck, body and bell to cut costs. Like the automotive industry. And maybe Keilwerth had a order for X baris and didn't have the capacity then they maybe outsourced some parts of the manufacturing. Amati and Keilwerth cooperate when it came to Keilwerth student models.
 
Ahem...it 'IS' a B&S which 'does' have Keilwerth parts and was made for Schenkelaars, as per the description. As for price, I could have bought a brand new warranted Yamaha from an established shop for roughly the same price as the Silversonic in my avatar....
I know it was made by B & S, I was responding to another poster who seemed to think it was a Keilwerth, which it isn't.

The seller says it has some cosmetic parts from Keilwerth. This can't really be verified, but if what Bassic Sax says is right, and it has some parts such as keyguards sourced from Keilwerth, well, that's fine.
 
Looks like a bari with a tenor neck????? Maybe it's the right neck? I've seen some bari necks in the same style as a tenor neck. Can be an Orsi.
Like you, I have seen baris with a tenor style neck. They are baritone necks though - what clearly makes them for a bari is the octave vent is much further back along the length of the neck than you get with a tenor.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,433
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom