Saxophones Recommendations for first Baritone

It says BS-Y on it
OK, same as the one I linked to earlier (pic below) which is BS-P for Phosphor Bronze whereas your is Y for "yellow" (gold) finish. The PD or YD "Deluxe" versions had proper pivot screws amongst other improvements.

photo_20316_4.webp
 
Whatever you decide on, please be aware that there are two basic layouts for the keywork Selmer type vs Japanese. Check pics on the web and you will see what I mean. Very often the more affordable ones are copying Selmer. I played a Trevor James with Selmer layout for some time and it was quite a strech with my short pinky for low Eb/C. My Yanagisawa BW01 is way more comfortable. Japanese all the time for me.
 
Whatever you decide on, please be aware that there are two basic layouts for the keywork Selmer type vs Japanese. Check pics on the web and you will see what I mean. Very often the more affordable ones are copying Selmer. I played a Trevor James with Selmer layout for some time and it was quite a strech with my short pinky for low Eb/C. My Yanagisawa BW01 is way more comfortable. Japanese all the time for me.
I am no expert, but I have never heard of such a division in keywork.
As far as I understand, there are far more types of layouts for the keywork. If I remember corectly, the Selmer Mark VI introduced what is now known as a "modern" layout, most (if not all) saxophones since then have copied this layout. The older saxophones often have an alternative layout. As far as I know, there was no (real) standard for keywork back then.
......
You might be talking about a (minor) difference between 2 types of modern keywork. But that would be zooming in on a small detail and ignoring the bigger picture.
 
You might be talking about a (minor) difference between 2 types of modern keywork. But that would be zooming in on a small detail and ignoring the bigger picture.


Admittedly I am not into vintage horns. I have deliberately ignored them in my post. It might be a minor point to you but it is a major one for me. I just wanted to point out this is something to consider if you are looking for a modern bari. For me the key touches are to low down with Selmer style. Check the position relatice to the bell key cups. Selmer E pearl on E cup. Japanese E pearl higher up on a lever. I owned said TJ and play tested a Buffet and a System54. They all felt bigger and were a stretch with my arm and finger length.

Selmer SAII
B56A6F8D-53AD-4F38-9F9A-F9283E2D0B90.webp


Yamaha YBS480

FBABA971-B956-449E-AAC5-875EB9BE9BEA.webp


Buffet 400
BFFAA2F1-F2F9-4EDD-BA73-64B67ECF7651.webp
 
What I have found is that the various low A mechanisms (both on older and modern baris) make a huge difference for me.

For instance, I tried a Yamaha YBS-62, and it would take me quite some time to adapt.
 
I think 901 Vs YBS32 is a mechanical preference thing. I don't like the Yani horn I'm loaning, but have a new mpc coming that might change things
It may well be. When I got the B900 I use now (blimey, 20 years ago), there was a Yamaha going at the same time (both secondhand). I didn't have to play them for long to decide there was no competition. I suspect the sound was the deciding factor though, rather than the mechanicals. I'd owned a B900 before so I was probably conditioned to the sound of it. At that earlier time I had the set - satb all Yanags. Then I discovered Keilwerth tenors...
 
........so I was probably conditioned to the sound of it. At that earlier time I had the set - satb all Yanags. Then I discovered Keilwerth tenors...
This makes me curious....
What was it about the Keilwerth tenors that you liked? (I am assuming that you liked them)
And is that only in tenors? Ik see that they produce bari's too, have you tried their bari?
 
It may well be. When I got the B900 I use now (blimey, 20 years ago), there was a Yamaha going at the same time (both secondhand). I didn't have to play them for long to decide there was no competition. I suspect the sound was the deciding factor though, rather than the mechanicals. I'd owned a B900 before so I was probably conditioned to the sound of it. At that earlier time I had the set - satb all Yanags. Then I discovered Keilwerth tenors...
For me the B900 sounds a bit dull.. Especially with a 4C! Is a lot better with a SYOS mpc but I don't really like the yanigasawa actions, the octave key is weird for me somehow
 
This makes me curious....
What was it about the Keilwerth tenors that you liked? (I am assuming that you liked them)
And is that only in tenors? Ik see that they produce bari's too, have you tried their bari?
The sound. Big, powerful, etc. Tried their bari - didn’t like it. Sop not as nice as Yanag - I play a 991. I like their alto - I have an SX90R.
For me the B900 sounds a bit dull.. Especially with a 4C! Is a lot better with a SYOS mpc but I don't really like the yanigasawa actions, the octave key is weird for me somehow
I’ve never found it at all dull. For anything other than classical I use a Jody Jazz DV9 or a PPT 8*.
 
I only tried the vintage Keilwerth Tone-King and similar baris, not the modern EX and SX ones. They have a bit darker sound than the Yamaha and Taiwanese ones I played (no Yanagisawa yet), especially in the low end. But some might call them boomy.
 
So have you found a Bari yet?
from time to time I go window shopping here: Saxophones For Sale Second hand, Used.
There's a walstein bari for sale on that site for a very reasonable price, plus a YBS32 and Yani B901 at a price which has me wishing it was me shopping for one right now! good luck. Look forward to hearing you post a bari solo on a future SOTM!
I’ve contacted the seller of the Yamaha actually, that site just feels so out of date though - feels like it should have post dates as some people i’ve contacted through the site have said they’ve already sold their instrument🙁
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,433
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom