Saxophones My Search for a Mark VI

We should add that no other manufacturer has been as far as Yamaha both in design and manufacturing. They really push the limits in terms of how a horn meets the expected specs and how far this is consistent across the production.
Yanagisawa and even Selmer are still far less industrialized.
Let alone the MkVI which actually spanned from early post-war very handmade to semi-industrialized in the 70s. They just cannot be consistent.
And I too find it interesting to follow a quest with pretty clear ideas in mind.
 
The final consistency in the instrument performance was not directly because of the percentage of hand work (on the whole manufactoring process) but it is directly from the techniques they used.
In every saxophone (even on the cheapest Vietnamese horn) there is a certain percentage of hand work in the manufactoring process.

It's generally hard to separate when the source of incostency is, precisely... on vintage horns.

So it's a worth to check how the horns we'll go testing are setted, which kind of repairs/maintenance have had... etc etc...
Because there are many factors they can have effect on the performance of the instrument. And remember that some things can be "fixed", some things not.


R&C is one of the manufacturers which uses the the highest percentage of hand work for making saxophones (as well as Inderbinen and few others).

----
I still think one of manufacturers which has the highest consistancy is "Sequioia", the horns Aldevis endorses.
These horns are maniacally well manufactured, maniacally well assembled and checked.
 
Yeah, I think there are a lot of horn hunters that end up on a Mark Vi just because of their reputation.

I actually remember my dad bringing home a mark vi to try when I was in high school. It had been recommended by our family friend and woodwind repair tech. I distinctly remember playing the horn and thinking it was way too wild and hard to control. I didn't even give its chance. It was just a couple years later in college that I played a mark vi and loved it and purchased my first one. After that first VI I switched horns a few times, most notably to an SBA and then back to a Vi always with a single model of horn clearly in mind. This recent search has been with my most open mind trying as many horns as I possibly could, and in fact I was hoping to end up on a less expensive horn. Every time I played a different horn model I was hoping it would be awesome. More often than not the horns didn't even live up to my horn which didn't live up itself to some of the other Mark VIs I was playing. So, I'm kinda stuck and I'm just glad my dear wife puts up with it.
 
Although initiated 12 years ago, the OP @Benbrittonjazz 's website article is still available, is well written and informative. Regarding the Selmer Mark VI's, today I watched this informative critical 14 minute review of this classic horn through its years.

Better Sax on 5 Sept 2018 said:
Jay Metcalf talks with legendary saxophone player Bob Rockwell, and tries a bunch of Selmer Mark VI tenor saxophones in Copenhagen, Denmark.

 
I tried really hard not to post this time on a worn out subject but you got me...
Any well set up horn with a low trauma history that isn't too quirky intuition wise, is a great horn if you like the feel of it under your fingers and blows the way you like it and its reliable.
Everything else is individual preference. I mean, whether you like the feedback you get from it will depend on you, the mouthpiece choice will depend on you, is it spread, is it focused? all affected by you and your choices until it's stripped back to the nitty gritty of the horns natural tendency and then, once you are stripped back to that inherent tendency it becomes personal preference all over again.
Everyone seems to have an angle (and I'm not digging at this particular video) but especially when they are maximising YouTube revenue. I generally get irritated by the fact there is an angle. Or at least I get irritated by the fact that what maybe a valid 'opinion' leaves an impression that starts to feel like propaganda.
I recently searched for wireless speakers on the internet and I thought there was only one hands down winner. I was sucked in. Until I tried them in a shop against other speakers including some that didn't even show up in a google search of 'best wireless speaker uk'.
You learn so much more from first hand experience.

I always find myself leaping to the defence of a MKVI due to the haters but not because I think everyone should like them.
There is a fond place in my heart for MKVI's and many other older horns for what they have contributed to everything saxophone.
The one thing that surely can't be denied is that, starting with the SBA's off set keys, the ergonomics of a MKVI became the bench mark for just about everything else thereafter.
The sound and build quality of the brand at the time was class leading at that time and it was a tough act to follow so we are still emulating it today.
Yet they did continue to evolve subtly themselves throughout their production periods so a 59' 66' & 73 horn for example have a reasonable amount of difference including those ergonomics.
The ones I've played all differ but you know what?
I remember trying 6 brand new Yamaha's back to back in the same shop and the same thing happened.
But it's a well established opinion that Yamahas straight out the box will be the same.
That was not my experience.

I know the that the MKVI bashers will never go away but you can find a MKVI today that will live up to anything else.
You may prefer your Eastman, your Yanagisawa or 10M, a cannonball or a radio improved. Great news a horn that is surely helping you be a happy player.
But take the MKVI for what it is, fundamentally a bench mark of today's saxophone design, there is a reason for that and it must take credit for it.
For perspective, my Martin Com III alto and King Super 20 Tenor are my favourites.
It's OK to love something else.
 
Last edited:
The one thing that surely can't be denied about the MKVI is that starting with the SBA's off set keys, the ergonomics of a MKVI became the bench mark for just about everything else thereafter.
But still a lot of people prefer inline keys, not offset:
 
But still a lot of people prefer inline keys, not offset:
Maybe, which is of course great.
But that doesn't alter my point, does anyone make in line keys now?
 
My takeaway from the original article was "wow, this guy really can hear/feel the variation in lacquer on the neck??"

Which just reinforces my thinking that the whole conversation on horns is really confounded (in the second meaning of the word) by the experience of the player. So you have amateurs and pros in the same conversation but they're not speaking the same language.
 
I have had 3 Mark VIs and all are more about nostalgia and playing a piece of history .People forget that they were new saxes in 1960’s when Stan Getz and Coltrane were on them…!
They are still great classic designs though just like an E-Type Jaguar but modern cars are way more refined and better in tune even Benny Golson was on a Selmer Ref 36 and the new Selmer is phenomenal as well as phenomenally expensive !
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,384
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom