Accessories Mouthpiece Silencer

Any update on whether the jazzlab silencer is worthwhile? I have one in my car but the confines of being in a small metal box mean it is still unpleasantly piercing - but much better than not using one! It certainly makes you think about how you lower the note using internal mouth shape etc. Can't seem to raise the note yet though.
 
I have also thought along the lines that if you can't have the Sax to play, mouthpiece practice would be of some use, similar to a brass player buzzing on the mouthpiece. The thing I thought of when I read they cost Β£40. I'm sure you could make something that would do the job, for a lot less. Some people can make a silencer for a gun for a lot less money.
 
I trust you're not associated with such criminals

No not me, but it's the same principal. 2 different sizes of PVC pipe the inner perforated and surrounded with small balls of styrofoam. An end cap with a small hole. And the other end the same size as the mouthpiece inner diameter.
 
I have used the silencer - it is in fact one of the best things you can buy!! It will really work your chops and develop your ability to voice overtones and altissimo. And if you can do scales and intervals it develops you ears too.

When you first use it, it is not easy, and that puts people off.

So Prof - stick with it and give it time. !!
 
Pianists play dumb pianos for practice, it helps with the physical work out, and can help rhythmic issues, and they practice this way, because it's not as tiring . It's the constant sound coming from the real piano that is tiring. I don't think playing on a mouthpiece will help much in that dept. with or without a bit of plastic at one end. Also they must cost about Β£2.50 to produce, so Β£40 is a bit steep.
 
I have used the silencer - it is in fact one of the best things you can buy!! It will really work your chops and develop your ability to voice overtones and altissimo. And if you can do scales and intervals it develops you ears too.

When you first use it, it is not easy, and that puts people off.

So Prof - stick with it and give it time. !!
I shall resurrect the damn thing and give it another go but I would much rather agree with Jamesmac!
 
+1 for the Silencer. I've owned a tenor and bari one for six or seven years and they're great. Never mind how useful they are when travelling and for not disturbing others, it actually makes mouthpiece practice more effective. Not only does it mimic, up to a point, the resistance of having a sax on the end of the mouthpiece, but it is also more musical than bare mouthpiece practice. I can't even stand the sound of my own mouthpiece practice!
 
OK it's a bit pricey, considering it just a plastic thingy - but since we pay Β£100 a pop for mpc and Β£1k to Β£2k for one sax, and Β£20 for just 10 reeds, then Β£40 seems fair?

Of course, you do can do all the exercises and gain ALL the benefits, by not using the silencer - on the mpc alone. But the added resistance of the silencer helps develop you chops.
 
I think they probably suit some guys, if you can't get at your Sax for whatever reason. I can see a benefit if you want to focus in on what your embouchure does without the distraction of the Sax on the end of it. But I think of that similar to a Lerner driver who is waiting in his car at the test centre, waiting to take his test. He will go through the motions of pressing the clutch, changing gear, looking in the rear view mirror etc. if you drive and have driven all day for the last 40 yrs your not going to need to go thru the motions. In an ideal situation your embouchure will adapt to whatever you want to play with the Sax on the end of the mouthpiece. I can think of lots of exercises with an instrument that playing scales on a mouthpiece won't help at all. But as I said for the guy who works all day with something not related to playing the Sax then to have a buzz on the mouthpiece at lunchtime is probably beneficial. Take it one step further. Do you think Charlie Parker would benefit playing scales on his mouthpiece. Remember he used to practice 12 hrs a day with his Sax.
 
I think you're missing the point of the mpc exercises, for the beginner to non advanced players.
If you can play top F and bend it down a 5th or more you don't need to do them. If you can't do it, then the exercises will really help. It's an aid to help develop these things, as well as overtones etc.
 
Most proficient players that I know and have worked with over the years have developed their technique from playing with the instrument at the end of the mouthpiece. But if it floats your boat that's OK.
 
Ok!......let me just say this little piece of two dollar plastic was the absolute best 44 euros i have ever spent to improve my playing!! ........Way more important than reed or mouthpiece!Twice i decided not to buy it because of the price but, after only one week of using it while the shooshie exercises i was blown away when i heard a recording i made at practice jam! My sound was more colorful, powerful and better intonation!.....no doubt this is the secret to doing the shooshie exercise without disturbing neighbors. Honestly, i personally think this is THE exercise!
 
I think you're missing the point of the mpc exercises, for the beginner to non advanced players.
If you can play top F and bend it down a 5th or more you don't need to do them. If you can't do it, then the exercises will really help. It's an aid to help develop these things, as well as overtones etc.

Totally agree on all but one point, my particular problem was finially understanding the critical roll the tongue has in voicing. Just doing the allard F trick did not get me to what the shooshie exercises did......i think the key is the coordination of the air stream, and tongue. The difference is Now i notice that my tongue isnt really flacid but firm and flexable......sorry for my rambling!
 
Ok!......let me just say this little piece of two dollar plastic was the absolute best 44 euros i have ever spent to improve my playing!! ........Way more important than reed or mouthpiece!Twice i decided not to buy it because of the price but, after only one week of using it while the shooshie exercises i was blown away when i heard a recording i made at practice jam! My sound was more colorful, powerful and better intonation!.....no doubt this is the secret to doing the shooshie exercise without disturbing neighbors. Honestly, i personally think this is THE exercise!
IS that the Jazzlabs practice/silencer thing?
 
I guess the next natural progression of questioning on this line then is .......

Since I have Soprano, Alto and Tenor, and will only purchase one silencer at this price level - which one should I choose to enable me to get the best muscle strengthening out of it, or will it really not matter?

The one advertised on Amazon includes adaptors for sop, alto, tenor, bari?????
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,290
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom