I think the best tests are done by (blindfold) playing a long note or a scale with (as far as possible) identical articulation and dynamics.But since he sells and endorses 3D printed pieces, his “tests” should be taken with a huge grain of salt.
Or “S’up guys”(Not quite as bad as "Hey Guys what's up?")
Or as P.Mauriat (Horrible company name by the way, especially for a professional saxophone brand )states "Go for for the sound" no matter the cost! Personally I prefer the sound and feel of metal mouthpieces by the way.
Metallic obviously 🙂What is the sound of a metal piece?
Metal pieces tend to have overtones different compared to hard rubber pieces. Hard to describe but often, simplified, more compact and brighter.What is the sound of a metal piece?
What is different about the overtones?Metal pieces tend to have overtones different compared to hard rubber pieces.
They’re alt chord extensionsWhat is different about the overtones?
No I did some comparisons, but Morgan wasn't involved in experiments, apart from making the mouthpieces.
So yes I did some comparisons between the HR and brass PPT.
They’re alt chord extensions

I dont know but to me, as a player there are differences between how metal pieces sound compared to hard rubber, dont you think?What is different about the overtones?
In a world where the Nobel prize is won by people who developed attosecond lasers and can see elections in their shells... All manufacturing tolerances are measurable!
Maybe, but there seemed to be a claim here that this was some kind of objective test.Yes I hear you but there are tendencies , I think a big part of what we hear are tendencies of each different materials more than different dimensions.
Probably not by anyone. That was a throwaway remark, the question wasBut probably not by mouthpice manufacturers.
Which, in turn, are only meaningful if you know how variation in tolerance affects the sound in a perceptible way...
Probably not by anyone. That was a throwaway remark, the question was...
Which, in turn, are only meaningful if you know how variation in tolerance affects the sound in a perceptible way...
No. 🙂I dont know but to me, as a player there are differences between how metal pieces sound compared to hard rubber, dont you think?
Ok, each to his own I suppose!No. 🙂
