Mouthpieces Material does matter..

Or as P.Mauriat (Horrible company name by the way, especially for a professional saxophone brand )states "Go for for the sound" no matter the cost! Personally I prefer the sound and feel of metal mouthpieces by the way.
 
But since he sells and endorses 3D printed pieces, his “tests” should be taken with a huge grain of salt.
I think the best tests are done by (blindfold) playing a long note or a scale with (as far as possible) identical articulation and dynamics.

Just playing some licks is a very flawed test. But if it sells (possibly overpriced) mouthpieces go for it. It is where we are these days.
 
Or as P.Mauriat (Horrible company name by the way, especially for a professional saxophone brand states "Go for for the sound" no matter the cost!
What is the sound of a metal piece?
Metal pieces tend to have overtones different compared to hard rubber pieces. Hard to describe but often, simplified, more compact and brighter.
 
Probably not by anyone. That was a throwaway remark, the question was...

Which, in turn, are only meaningful if you know how variation in tolerance affects the sound in a perceptible way...

Quite. My point was that it's not a very objective test of whether the material is significant. Too many variables. TBH, I'm not sure now if we're agreeing with each other or not 🙂.
 
Listening on decent headphones on an iPad, there is a noticeable tonal difference between the two mouthpieces. I think the frying sizzle sound is a tiny drop of spit on the reed, but the tone of the plastic piece seems duller to me, kind of tubby compared to the other. It’s a very minor difference, but noticeable.

I also notice that Chad’s posture is different for the two mouthpieces. He seems to be putting a bit more English (pardon the expression) onto the hard rubber piece.

All that said, there was a very lengthy thread on the other forum about this topic, and this video is in no way a scientific proof or even a quasi-scientific indication of whether material matters in the sound of a mouthpiece. It’s quite clear that these two mouthpieces are different, but it’s not at all clear why. I outlined a possible experiment in that other thread that might shed light on the subject, but I also said I didn’t really care. I know a good mouthpiece when I play it. Don’t much care what it is made of.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,562
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom