Mouthpieces Material does matter..

Did I miss where he described what effects they put on the recording ? Possibly I was distracted by the teeth.

Rhys
Only listened on phone but pretty sure I can hear a bit of subtle reverb.
Other than this it’s just the colour of the mic and preamp, but will be the same for both.
Can’t believe he’d add anything else, his sound is great.
 
Talking of preamps, most of the time in mic shootouts, instrument and mouthpiece shootouts only the mics are ever mentioned.

A good preamp adds way more than a mic. And these can be v coloured too. Or not so much. Horses for courses. Depends on the mix, what it’s for, whether you want to beef up a small sound or warm up a harsh sound etc
 
I find the pricing of these two mouthpieces interesting.

The hard rubber mouthpiece is:
  • Made from bar stock
  • Shaped by CNC machining
  • Hand finished
  • Sells for $499
The plastic mouthpiece is:
  • Made of PLA plastic
  • 3-D printed to shape
  • Hand finished
  • Sells for $299
I can see no obvious reason why the hard rubber piece sells for $200 more, other than customer expectation and what the market will bear.

Rhys
 
Last edited:
Missed opportunity. If you have the CNC and want to interrogate the effects of material, then make a blank of plastic and use it to produce a CNC-machined mouthpiece.

P.S. Not all additive machining is the same: fused deposition (FDM) vs stereolithography (SLA). Different materials, different techniques, different fill, different density…. I hope you start to get the picture.
 
No two objects have exactly the same dimensions, no matter how carefully you try to make them so. I daresay you could find differences between any two examples of the HR mouthpieces or two of the 3D printed ones. To make a meaningful statement, you'd have to say something about the tolerances to which each one was manufactured.
 
Also keep in mind, the printed piece has a relatively rough surface, and a much lower density and is much softer. All these are going to affect the sound somewhat. When we say material doesn’t matter, the assumption is all are similarly rigid and smooth. In this case, they are not.
 
Last edited:
To make a meaningful statement, you'd have to say something about the tolerances to which each one was manufactured.
Which, in turn, are only meaningful if you know how variation in tolerance affects the sound in a perceptible way...

In a world where the Nobel prize is won by people who developed attosecond lasers and can see elections in their shells... All manufacturing tolerances are measurable!
 
I find the pricing of these two mouthpieces interesting.

The hard rubber mouthpiece is:
  • Made from bar stock
  • Shaped by CNC machining
  • Hand finished
  • Sells for $499
The plastic mouthpiece is:
  • Made of PLA plastic
  • 3-D printed to shape
  • Hand finished
  • Sells for $299
I can see no obvious reason why the hard rubber piece sells for $200 more, other than customer expectation and what the market will bear.
I find the pricing of these two mouthpieces interesting.

The hard rubber mouthpiece is:
  • Made from bar stock
  • Shaped by CNC machining
  • Hand finished
  • Sells for $499
The plastic mouthpiece is:
  • Made of PLA plastic
  • 3-D printed to shape
  • Hand finished
  • Sells for $299
I can see no obvious reason why the hard rubber piece sells for $200 more, other than customer expectation and what the market will bear.

Rhys
I would gladly pay 200usd extra for the hard rubber, it’s not because it’s hard rubber instead of plastic. It’s all about the sound where I find that the HR variant has a much more complex sound to it with high end sizzle and texture. The plastic (PLA) version is more dull and not to my taste.
 
Missed opportunity. If you have the CNC and want to interrogate the effects of material, then make a blank of plastic and use it to produce a CNC-machined mouthpiece.

P.S. Not all additive machining is the same: fused deposition (FDM) vs stereolithography (SLA). Different materials, different techniques, different fill, different density…. I hope you start to get the picture.
Yeah, you have a point.
 
No two objects have exactly the same dimensions, no matter how carefully you try to make them so. I daresay you could find differences between any two examples of the HR mouthpieces or two of the 3D printed ones. To make a meaningful statement, you'd have to say something about the tolerances to which each one was manufactured.
Yes I hear you but there are tendencies , I think a big part of what we hear are tendencies of each different materials more than different dimensions.
 
Also keep in mind, the printed piece has a relatively rough surface, and a much lower density and is much softer. All these are going to affect the sound somewhat. When we say material doesn’t matter, the assumption is all are similarly rigid and smooth. In this case, they are not.
When you 3d print a mouthpiece you can chose to have a infill of up to 100%, in this particular case we dont know what’s it at but I would assume 100% infill for the rigidity of the piece.
 
Which, in turn, are only meaningful if you know how variation in tolerance affects the sound in a perceptible way...

In a world where the Nobel prize is won by people who developed attosecond lasers and can see elections in their shells... All manufacturing tolerances are measurable!
'Elections' obviously a typo.
Of course my mind went to the one it isn't.
 
I would gladly pay 200usd extra for the hard rubber, it’s not because it’s hard rubber instead of plastic. It’s all about the sound where I find that the HR variant has a much more complex sound to it with high end sizzle and texture. The plastic (PLA) version is more dull and not to my taste.

I listened via a very good DAC and Hi-Fi headphones. The main difference I heard was the sizzle / frying noise which @Pete Effamy noted. Yes, I did hear other subtle differences between A and B mouthpieces, but nothing game changing.

From the audience's perspective I think they would be happy to hear either, helped no doubt by the player's ability in the video.

The player of the mouthpiece might notice more of a difference and have a stronger preference.

But my point is that the price difference is not justified by materials cost, machining cost or handwork cost differences. I guess your post supports my point about "what the market will bear".

Rhys
 
I listened via a very good DAC and Hi-Fi headphones. The main difference I heard was the sizzle / frying noise which @Pete Effamy noted. Yes, I did hear other subtle differences between A and B mouthpieces, but nothing game changing.

From the audience's perspective I think they would be happy to hear either, helped no doubt by the player's ability in the video.

The player of the mouthpiece might notice more of a difference and have a stronger preference.

But my point is that the price difference is not justified by materials cost, machining cost or handwork cost differences. I guess your post supports my point about "what the market will bear".

Rhys
Just depends. Most of any audience will barely hear differences between quite different mouthpieces, but if the player has a mental breakdown about that tiny percentage, $200 is pretty cheap.
 
Playing at a high level, the feel of comfort and the small nuances in sound and feel play a big role in chosing the equipment. For the audience it doesent matter as long as they hear a inspired and good player, right?

Why do pros and amateurs go through periods of gear testing? Refining their sound and searching for the mouthpiece and saxophone that suit your needs i guess.
 
When you 3d print a mouthpiece you can chose to have a infill of up to 100%, in this particular case we dont know what’s it at but I would assume 100% infill for the rigidity of the piece.
Even at 100% the 3D printer material itself is far less dense than hard rubber. I just put a SYOS and a hard rubber tenor piece on my postal scale, and the hard rubber was twice as heavy. I’ve always known this by how heavy they feel, but this is the first time I’ve weighed them.
 
I can see no obvious reason why the hard rubber piece sells for $200 more, other than customer expectation and what the market will bear.
Could it be the investment made in CNC machinery and software vs the investment in 3D printing machinery and software.

Both require scanning an original so I can't see why there should be much difference in software/programming costs as essentially both are making blanks that need hand facing.

I think it is down to charging what you think the market will pay. "Hard rubber bar stock" sounds so much better then "plastic."

Both are overpriced IMO when you consider what Ed Pillinger does (disclaimer: obviously I'm biased) but it all buys into the myth that the more you pay the better licks you play.

I'm also biased because any video that starts "Hey Guys!" means I turn it off. (Not quite as bad as "Hey Guys what's up?")
 
I'm also biased because any video that starts "Hey Guys!" means I turn it off. (Not quite as bad as "Hey Guys what's up?")
That’s a shame. Chad is a monster player and a great communicator. But since he sells and endorses 3D printed pieces, his “tests” should be taken with a huge grain of salt.

As you well know, a great player can make just about any piece of junk sound fantastic. That’s what makes the marketplace so difficult for a novice to navigate. They hear a great player making garbage sound great, so it’s logical to think I’m going to sound great on that piece of garbage. When that doesn’t happen, you go out and buy the next piece of garbage. Surely it will work this time…
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,562
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom