Tech/maintenance Low B not completely closing with Bb

mizmar

Eternal early intermediat
Messages
6,137
Location
Trondheim, Norway
Level
Eternal early intermediat
Hi,
so, I was giving the shabbysax (an old Vito / YTS23 type thing) a once over, having just got a leak light (yay) - all mostly good.
Then I found the Low B tone hole isn't closing completely with the Bb key. It closes cleanly with the low B key.

As a test I shoved a shim (a sticky backed pad) under the Bb key to push the B key a bit more (photo) and that works better (less iron grippy, I've been struggling for a wile and just blamed user error).

So, what's the proper fix? New bit of cork (sanded down?)?
I don't see any skrews to adjust and I suppose bending things is not a great way forward.


IMG_20210421_151817817.jpg
 
Last edited:
Yes, cork will work (although tech cork would be a better material for these situations as it doesn't compress over time). Go slightly thicker than needed, then with a strip of sandpaper between cork and Bb lever, take the cork down to the required thickness so that B closes with Bb (keep leaklight in the bell so you can see how much you're sanding).
 
For that application I like to install a small self adhesive disk and then carefully bend the "lever" up or down using flat smooth jawed pliers. In some instances I put a flat tongue depressor under the B key cup and bend the B touch up to regulate. Bending keys scares some folks, but techs do it all the time and it is done at the factory as well. The old joke is "I don't bend keys, I straighten them". 🙂
 
Last edited:
Yep, just bend the 'tab'. Standard practice.
However, you may want to consider why it went out of regulation in the first place. The Bb touchpiece looks a little high to me, so maybe the bell key table has taken a knock?
 
For that application I like to install a small self adhesive disk and then carefully bend the "lever" up or down using flat smooth jawed pliers. In some instances I put a flat tongue depressor under the B key cup and bend the B touch up to regulate. Bending keys scares some folks, but techs do it all the time and it is done at the factory as well. The old joke is "I don't bend keys, I straighten them". 🙂

I'm sorry to say that in some situations it's difficult to avoid bending keys. It's obviously not my preference, but when you don't have adjusting screws, it can do the trick.

What you need to remember when you do it is that metal has memory and tends to return to it's initial position. So bending may need to be done in steps, to ensure it gets to a stable status.

Last year I purchased a tenor sax from a member here that arrived in some sort of distress with a number of keys not closing. No screws, or not where it matters to fix the issues. So for once I bent keys and it worked fine after a few iterations... It's now holding it's regulation and I tweaked it over a year ago.

I don't play that often these days so the last thing I want is to have to waste time tweaking my horns.
 
Yep, just bend the 'tab'. Standard practice.
However, you may want to consider why it went out of regulation in the first place. The Bb touchpiece looks a little high to me, so maybe the bell key table has taken a knock?
It may have. Not by me AFAIK. The thing hasn't left the practice room in a few years except for a couple of services. And the last tech didn't say anything particularly...
It's quite an old horn, belonged to a gigging musician as backup etc. So I'm not expecting anything like perfection and it's probably not worth £€$lots of work.
 
It's annoying how things get bent out of shape while the instrument is in the case and unused. It doesn't take much to deregulate the bell keys.
On the stand, used most days.
But the corks on this thing, and the wide verity if other pad materials are of many indeterminate ages and qualities...

One day i might buy myself something else, when I have the skills to do so, and make this a bit of a project.
 
Any luck figuring out the real cause? I have a Yamaha yas-23 that the keys looks very much like yours…
I was wondering about that from your othrr thread.
My tenor, as I mentioned above, is a pretty battered specimen so the cause could be anything from having lived a tough life too bad transportation.
On the other hand, the bend in the touch is not a big problem at my level of playing and it's been serviced - and the tech either didn't think it was an issue or couldn't be bothered....
Frankly, I bought the shabby sax with the intent of getting good enough so that when I reached its limit, I would have enough experience to buy something better... One day! onwards and upwards.
 
Last edited:
Since SP_22 bounced this, I thought I'd take another look.
For caparison, here's a photo taken from the same angle as Stephan's picture in his review

Clearly the touch is standing proud, but level with the other tabs... so? it's two axis "bend"? And the curved arm/rod/leaver? Is it cast? More brittle? Something I wouldn't try to bend!

Something to take up with the tek at some point.
And nice to know that the struggles I've always had with Bb on this horn are not purely user error as I'd assumed.

IMG_20210507_103147487.jpg
 
Slop in the mechanism can also create this problem. There are numerous places where a bent key could cause this, and it could simply be a missing cork.
 
Some instruments are a constant work in progress.
I'd suggest that they all are.
There are several areas on a saxophone that require observation.
e.g. Palm keys attract plenty of condensation.
The low Eb/D# key also attracts moisture along with dust/debris and should be regularly monitored for leaks.
Any key that sits in sealed position in fact.
cheers, Mark.
 
One day i might buy myself something else, when I have the skills to do so, and make this a bit of a project.
Well, I finally broke.
Having moved to Legere and relieved myself of reed aggravation; i decided to get an intermediate horn to remove (for a while) the never ending mechanical aggravation.
The Vito/yts23 has all sorts of signs of a long, hard life - dodgy soldering, wonky bell, wonky tone holes - that I've managed to work around/with... And it's fine. And then needs fettling.
So.... I got a Bettersax tenor.
Rational: 1/ I can't make it to a big shop anytime soon and the local market is limited and I don't want to go up market without trying first. 2/ having read a few times that it's more Yani than Yamma, i thought that'd be educational. 3/ seems from @Stephen Howard to be mechanically sound.

First impressions;
It's heavier; 3.50kg Vs 3.15kg.
I took it to a dark room with a leak light and it was fine...
... But I did adjust the Bb from D E F screw a tad, to close properly.
The neck is a very snug fit.
It's got fewer / different adjustment screws. None on the DEF Linkage bar...
It's got a neet "close Bell C# when closing bell B" mechanism which needed a little adjustment.
The left hand Pinky table is very rollable - but here's a false spot where the C# glitches when closing Bb. A but further along and its fine. I don't know if that's improvable but I'll get used to it. I found the small rod through one roller proud and screwed it in.
No other screws/rods where proud.
It's got a RH "altisimo" F# padel. That'll take some practice. There's some of the extra 0.35kg...

It worked easily with my Theo Wanne Essential 7 jazz and Legere French 2.5. and why not.

All the notes present and correct. Which is nice. Sounds good. To my undiscerning ears, all I can say is "warm" through the range to alt G. After a couple of hours, I feel pretty well in control - give or take the LH pinky table as above.

Smooth playing, everyone
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,359
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom